Headlines everywhere have described
the foreclosure tsunami that continues to overwhelm the housing market.
Less noticed has been the impact on single-family homes that are used
as lucrative care facilities for the elderly.
In California, residents of such homes pay an average of $2,500 a
month for a shared bedroom and $3,500 a month for a private bedroom,
according to California Registry, which helps place senior citizens.
But, as my article
in Sunday’s Bay Area report describes, financial overreaching by some
proprietors has led to foreclosure, and some elderly residents and
their relatives have learned of this only when a notice is tacked on
the house or sheriff’s deputies arrive to evict them.
My reporting also provided a look at the shadowy side of the business of buying and selling properties for licensed elder care.
The commercial real estate Web site loopnet.com
advertises a six-bed board and care facility for elderly in “the heart
of San Francisco,” whose owner “needs to sell.” The ad calls the asking
price of $155,000 “a steal,” citing a $14,000 monthly income from its
six residents and a five-year term of “interest-only payments.” But,
the ad warns, “Do Not Approach Care Home as Staff are unaware of the
sale.”
Sometimes even the licensed administrators managing an elder care
home have been blindsided by an eviction notice resulting from a
mortgage default. Inocencia Arindaeng, the administrator of a facility
in Walnut Creek, Calif., has said in court documents that this happened
to her. She had signed a “lease to purchase” agreement with the owner
of the property in 2007, according to court records, and diligently
paid her monthly rent to the owner while caring for her elderly
charges, who range in age from 86 to 97. The complaint said the owner
did not use Ms. Arindaeng’s money to pay the mortgage.
Ms. Arindaeng did not know the extent of the financial mess she was
in until she and the elderly tenants she cared for received an eviction
notice on March 18, 2009.
In addition to examining the questionable practices of some owners,
I ran across at least one Web site that has found a market niche in
these elder-care homes.
Carehomesusa.com, which
caters to those who want to buy, sell or trade such homes, suggests
that many care facility foreclosures are linked to predatory lending.
It poses the hypothetical situation of an owner called Bill, who is “in
the red by $4,000 a month” as the result of an adjustable mortgage.
The site goes on to warn potential customers: “If you bought your
facility in the last several years with 100 percent financing, interest
only or even a negative amortization mortgage, and you locked yourself
into a high interest rate with a prepayment penalty clause, more or
less, you have the same trouble [sic] just as Bill does.
A short sale,” it concludes, “might be a solution for you.”
Jeffrey Lai, an administrator of carehomesusa.com, said in an
interview that short sales — sales based on an agreement between an
owner and his lender that allows a sale at a price below the
outstanding loan amount — were becoming more popular.
“Many buyers who purchased in the last three years are so under
water,” Mr. Lai said, “because of high mortgage payments, and property
values haven’t appreciated the way they thought, or they may have an
adjustable mortgage that has come back to hurt them.”
He added, “We sell endless care homes all over the U.S. in Arkansas,
Kansas and mainly California, and we have a database of thousands of
interested buyers.”
The question is whether residents and their relatives have any
assurance that the new generation of proprietors will have — and
perhaps will be required by law to have — more solid financial
underpinnings than their predecessors.
FAIR USE NOTICE. This document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the copyright owner