Some 25 years ago, when I first started working up here, I typeset a 36-point headline that taught me a lesson about political power in North County.
Above a story about Escondido’s mobile-home communities, I wrote “trailer parks.”
You would have thought I used a racial slur. The calls and handwritten letters poured in.
The senior citizens who rented land for their “coaches” bitterly resented the low-rent, low-class stereotype of trailer parks. I was scornfully invited to tour spacious manufactured houses that weren’t going anywhere, certainly not to Yosemite for a family vacation.
This passionate bloc of voters — and newspaper readers — demanded not only respect but something much more valuable: rent control. They felt they were owed home security — and they were ready to fight for it.
Bowing to the pressure, Oceanside’s council passed a rent-control ordinance in 1984. In 1988, Escondido voters approved Proposition K, a contested ordinance that led to a landmark 1991 U.S. Supreme Court decision upholding rent control, which was widely interpreted to mean that the city could regulate rents even after the coach was sold, a power called “vacancy control.”
In retrospect, this high-court victory was the high-water mark of mobile-home power in North County. Park owners who hated rent control in general — and vacancy control in particular — filed a flurry of lawsuits against the devils in the details of Escondido’s ordinance.
Escondido would spent millions defending what it had won in the Supreme Court. Finally, in 1996, the 4th District Court of Appeal ruled that Prop. K did not bar park owners from raising rents on new tenants to a fair market value.
The same year, an initiative went on the ballot to reinstate vacancy control. Proposition O was defeated. Two years later, a similar proposition cratered. Clearly, the tide had turned in Escondido. No longer could mobile homes be sold with a guarantee of the same low rent enjoyed by the seller. In theory, rent control remained in place, but park owners won what they coveted most — the ability to raise rents when coaches changed hands. Once a new rent was established, rent control kicked in again.
In light of this history of rise and fall, last week’s 3-2 vote by the Oceanside City Council to phase out rent control completely makes political sense.
In Oceanside, the power of mobile-home park residents has declined. Even Melba Bishop, the former councilwoman who spearheaded Oceanside’s 1984 ordinance, grudgingly concedes that point.
The conservative majority on the council — Jerry Kern, Gary Felien and Jack Feller — know they can side with park owners and survive, if not thrive.
Framed by Kern as a fair compromise to current renters, the abolition of rent control upon the sale of a mobile-home means that the low-rent guarantee cannot be factored into a future sale price. Coach owners must accept that the equity in their homes will take a hit.
Park owners, who reportedly are making a decent profit, argue that the parks will be better maintained if more revenue is generated. The parks may not be as low-rent but they’ll be higher class.
To those without a dog in the fight, that sounds like a good deal. Raise the municipal tone. Improve the city’s image.
To Bishop, however, the death of rent control is civic heresy. She focuses the story on the poor senior citizens who will be losing a chunk of their estates.
To her, the loss of transferrable rent control could be the difference between living in a decent nursing home or being warehoused.
“You have an ethical responsibility to care for the less fortunate,” Bishop tells me.
Time was, that argument — seniors of modest means and lifestyle deserve a break — carried a ton of weight. No longer, it seems.
The political bloc that 20 years ago could hold politicians hostage has lost its intimidation factor.
The decline started in the late ‘90s when Escondido failed to restore vacancy control. For free-market conservatives, there’s no risk in upholding their anti-rent-control principles — and handing a windfall to park owners who will never stop suing until they win the right to raise rents to what the traffic will bear. (Or, as Bishop predicts, bulldoze the relatively low-rent parks and build condos.)
The reasons for the erosion of mobile-home power are no mystery.
Regional population growth has diminished the mobile-home voting muscle. Park owners have bought a number of mobile homes and turned them into traditional rentals, reducing the number of potential activists. Moreover, the population of parks has diversified. More families. Less unity. Less fire in the aging belly.
No matter how nice they are to live in, mobile-home communities, on a political level, have turned back into trailer parks.
That’s today’s headline.
FAIR
USE NOTICE. Tenants Together is not the author of this article and the posting
of this document does not imply any endorsement of the content by Tenants
Together. This document may contain copyrighted material the use of which
may not have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants
Together is making this article available on our website in an effort to
advance the understanding of tenant rights issues in California. We believe
that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided
for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this
copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you
must obtain permission from the copyright owner.