Two housing law experts spoke Thursday about new affordable housing laws at a Tri-Valley Affordable Housing Committee meeting.
Inclusionary zoning, an ordinance some cities use to require a certain portion of new housing be affordable to low- and moderate-income renters or buyers, has become an integral part of city planning, said Barbara Kautz, a lawyer from Goldfarb & Lipman LLP.
It's become an "accepted part of community planning in the Bay Area and there's a perception that it is the best way to get affordable housing," she said.
But the ordinance has come under fire from developers who contend that it is unlawful, according to Mike Rawson, an attorney with the Public Interest Law Project.
In a recent 2009 Los Angeles case, a developer won a court decision that found that the Costa-Hawkins Rental Housing Act bars cities from requiring that a property have affordable rent.
"Anytime you go into Costa-Hawkins, landlords will fall on their swords to save the law," Rawson said.
However, the legislation was enacted in 1996 as a rent-control device and "wasn't meant to impact inclusionary zoning in the way it is now," Kautz said.
The recent ruling also found that in-lieu fees, which some cities use as an alternative to the inclusionary requirement, were an improper option unless a comprehensive study, called a nexus study, linked the fee to housing needs.
The ruling also found that affordable units could be imposed on a developer only through a contractual agreement.
Kevin Gailey, chief of planning for Danville, said providing incentive for that agreement is a vital first step.
"I don't think we need to do anything besides offer extra density to a developers to entice them into an inclusionary agreement," he said at the meeting. "Being pragmatic is key for us. Affordability is linked to density so getting denser for-rent projects is important."
Another obstacle for cities is the monitoring of affordable housing, Kautz said.
"A lot of nonprofit development agencies aren't interested in tracking a percentage of units to make sure they are affordable because of the manpower it takes to do that, especially when units are scattered around," she said.
Representatives from cities outside the Tri-Valley area also attended and shared their expertise on inclusionary zoning, including May Lee, housing and redevelopment project manager for Fremont.
That city was in the midst of updating its inclusionary zoning ordinance when the 2009 ruling came down, according to Lee. The city then contracted a nexus study before formulating a fee the developer would be required to pay in lieu of inclusionary requirements.
Some cities' housing departments have used such in-lieu fees to benefit homebuyers, said Laura Simpson, Walnut Creek's housing program manager.
Housing departments that lack the resources to help homeowners, especially those in foreclosure, can reach out to other entities that specialize in the issue, according to Kautz.
"Habitat for Humanity has some partnerships with cities, so they probably have a lot of expertise in putting their hands on foreclosed homes," she said.
The affordable housing committee also is working on the newest edition of the Tri-Valley Housing Opportunities Guide, a comprehensive look into Contra Costa County housing. The committee expects the guide to be printed by the end of the year, according to Corrine Horn, assistant planner for Danville.
At the meeting, committee members publicized two real estate-related classes that will be hosted at the Dublin Public Library at 200 Civic Plaza.
• Foreclosure Workshop, 9 a.m. to noon Nov. 6
Topics will include avoiding foreclosures, and foreclosure-related scams and recovering money from those scams.
"There was such a great response at the last workshop that we wanted to reach out to a larger audience so we contacted faith-based entities for this upcoming one," said Gaylene Burkett, a Dublin housing representative. She said there will be six real estate counselors at the workshop, several more than at the last one.
• Homebuyer Education Class, 9:30 a.m. to 5 p.m. Saturday
The class will teach participants about the home purchasing process, financial management, getting a mortgage loan, reviewing credit scores and more. Cost is $30 for a booklet and other materials.
To register, call 925-373-3130, Ext. 302 or e-mail info@tvhoc.org. Registration at the door is available.
FAIR USE NOTICE. This
document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been
specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this
article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of
tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair
use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the
U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes
of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the
copyright owner.