The Neighborhood Stabilization Program (NSP) was established to stabilize communities that have suffered from foreclosures and abandonment. See description here. NSP authorizes recipients (states, nonprofits and others) to acquire foreclosed properties and then resell them to qualified buyers. Recipients target certain areas that have concentrations of foreclosures in order to stabilize the rest of the neighborhood using NSP funding.
One requirement of NSP is the seller of the foreclosed property (often a lender) must certify it has complied with the Protecting Tenants at Foreclosure Act (PTAF). HUD Guidance here. Description of PTAF here — essentially the law requires owners of foreclosed properties to honor leases of bonafide tenants (or give at least 90 days notice to vacate if the lease is expired). If the seller refuses to certify compliance with PTAF, the recipient can still acquire the property for the program but they must attempt to determine whether PTAF was complied with. Only if the recipient believes PTAF was complied with AND ASSUMES THE LIABILITY IF IT IS WRONG, can the recipient can acquire the property using NSP funds. HUD Guidance here.
Recipients such as the state of Texas have focused acquiring properties from Fannie Mae since it is the largest lender in the world and undoubtedly has one of the largest portfolios of foreclosed property. It is also worth mentioning again that Fannie Mae is under the control of the federal government at present.
Not surprisingly, Fannie Mae refuses to certify it complies with the Protecting Tenants at Foreclosure Act (PTAF). See statement of Texas agency below. Again, Fannie Mae refuses to sign a document saying it has complied with the law, a document required for participation in the federal Neighborhood Specialization Program (NSP).
I say not surprisingly because Fannie Mae’s system to evict the occupants of the properties it forecloses on is flawed and they know it. While they blame their lawyers and realtors for mistakes and take no responsibility for them (story here), they refuse to design a system that would prevent violations of PTAF. Thus, they know they violate PTAF in some cases and refuse to certify compliance because they have no idea whether they have complied or not. (I guess it would be worse if they certify something they know to be false. Talk to Westchester County New York about false certifications, story here.) So rather than design a better system that works and sign the certification, they hope states like Texas take the risk itself, or move on to another lender.
The failure of holders of REO to fully certify compliance with PTAF is the largest current obstacle to obligating NSP dollars. Fannie Mae and FHA foreclosed homes are the most important to our subrecipients as they are the most prolific. We developed a Texas NSP Purchase Addendum to be used on all applicable transactions to ensure that [PTAF] requirements were met. Fannie Mae refuses to certify, but has at least maintained a dialogue with us. Despite our repeated attempts to decipher exactly what in the Addendum is so objectionable, we still haven’t precisely identified the problem; we believe the principal issue to be PTAF. Fannie tells us that they are PTAF compliant because they are doing all they can. They claim they have established a due diligence process to identify any bona fide tenants. However, we think that their process falls short.
Michael Lyttle, Texas Department of Housing and Community Affairs, February 26, 2010.
And what is the effect of lenders like Fannie Mae refusing to certify compliance with PTAF? Texas reports that the PTAF certification is hands down the number one problem with implementation of the program — a program designed to get eligible families into affordable homes, while stabilizing neighborhoods. So while Fannie Mae sits on its hands and lets its henchman push tenant families out of their homes illegally, it smartly refuses to certify compliance and shove the liability to others interested in stabilizing their communities.
I am sure explanations are coming my way soon. In fairness to Fannie Mae I contacted them about this issue a week ago. Fannie explained that they have documents they are willing to sign for recipients that have worked (I have not seen these documents as yet). It appears Texas merely wants Fannie to follow the law as written, which should be something the federal government agrees with.
FAIR USE NOTICE. This document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.