The owners of San Francisco's massive Parkmerced apartment complex
recently made what sounded like a surprising statement. They were in
danger of defaulting on a $500 million mortgage, but planned to move
forward with a $1.2 billion, multi-decade expansion project on the
property.
A company verging on default could imagine restructuring its debt
and then spending billions in the future, the owners said, due to the
terms of their debt agreement, which provides for an intermediary to
renegotiate the loan so that it can be paid off over time.
But according to real estate finance experts, the middleman, which
is called a special servicer, is required to protect investors who are
owed mortgage payouts - not the owners of the complex, its tenants or
the city - leaving the fate of the 3,221-unit Parkmerced very much in
question.
"The special servicer is going to be looking to maximize the present
value to all the investors and to minimize losses," said Brent Ambrose,
professor of real estate at Pennsylvania State University. "Whether
they work out a deal to extend the loan, manage the property themselves
or recommend foreclosure is very specific to the property; they have
been known to choose foreclosure."
October due date
If between now and October, when the loan is scheduled to come due,
the servicer decides foreclosure is the best route, it's anyone's guess
what will happen to Parkmerced, one of the largest apartment complexes
in the United States.
In other similar instances around the country, banks and other investors have purchased foreclosed properties.
Parkmerced co-owner Stellar Management has sought to place the
Parkmerced problem in the context of the broader real estate crisis, in
which property purchased at the height of the real estate boom saw
values plummet during the bust.
That trouble was exacerbated when many owners, including Stellar
Management, failed to realize expected gains on a strategy to borrow
money, renovate properties and convert rent-controlled units to ones
that would pay market rates.
Stellar Management spokesman P.J. Johnston said more than $150
billion in U.S. commercial real estate loans have been transferred to
special servicers in the past two fiscal quarters.
"It's not just Parkmerced and it's not just Stellar's properties,"
said Johnston. "It's properties purchased in 2005, 2006 and 2007,
around the country and around the world."
Similar plans to renovate buildings and trade up for wealthier
tenants famously failed at other big developments, including Palo
Alto's Page Mill Properties, Manhattan's Stuyvesant Town and Peter
Cooper Village, and Stellar Management's Riverton Houses in New York's
Harlem, which it lost to foreclosure earlier this year.
San Francisco saw the scheme carried out in a building-by-building
fashion by the Lembi Group, which bought more than 150 apartment
buildings in San Francisco in 2006, 2007 and 2008. Since then, dozens
of Lembi buildings have been foreclosed on or given back to lenders.
Stellar Management's financial health is murky and the stakes are
arguably higher for the City of San Francisco on Parkmerced than other
projects that have fallen into foreclosure because of a proposed
development agreement between the owners and the city.
Planning panel review
The San Francisco Planning Commission is scheduled to review soon a
draft environmental impact report for the proposed 30-year project,
which would see the number of units on the 152-acre site in the city's
southwest corner nearly triple to about 8,900.
The owners also have proposed spending millions to reroute a Muni
line through the complex and to pursue environmental improvements, such
as wind turbines, solar panels and storm-water reuse.
The city hopes to complete a development agreement with the owners
by September, whereby the city will lock in benefits, including
affordable housing guarantees, development fees and neighborhood
amenities.
Johnston declined to discuss the details of Stellar Management's
Parkmerced loan or its other current outstanding debt obligations.
But records show that Stellar currently is delinquent on loan
payments for several of its real estate assets, including apartment
complexes in Maryland, New York and Los Angeles, according to real
estate research firm Real Capital Analytics.
Despite the seemingly bleak picture, there is hope for Stellar to
hold on to Parkmerced and to proceed with the proposed development
project, said Andrew Florio, an analyst with Real Capital. In
comparison to Riverton, Florio said Stellar has less outstanding debt
on Parkmerced.
"This is not a 'here we go again' situation," Florio said. "This is
a little different ... succeeding might not be the right word, but
surviving probably is. They feel confident they can work something out
with the special servicer and will retain the property."
Michael Yarne, a development adviser in the Mayor's Office of
Economic and Workforce Development, said he believed Stellar and its
partners would complete the development agreement because, if nothing
else, it makes the property more valuable.
"If worse came to worst and they could not continue with the
project, the development agreement only adds value to the property,"
Yarne said. "I have not seen any indication that they are wavering in
their commitment to the plan."
Parkmerced was developed by Metropolitan Life in the 1940s and 1950s
to provide homes for returning veterans, as were Stuyvesant Town and
Peter Cooper Village, on Manhattan's East Side.
Sprawling complex
The complex features 11 residential towers holding 1,683 apartments,
and a phalanx of two-story garden townhouses, containing 1,538 units.
It sits adjacent to San Francisco State University, Lake Merced and the
Harding Park Golf Course.
Harry Helmsley bought the community in 1970 for $40 million.
Helmsley's wife, Leona, sold it in 1999 to Carmel Partners for $324
million and Stellar Management and Rockpoint Group purchased it in 2005
for $700 million.
The development proposal has encountered relatively little community
resistance for a project of its size and scope, but the project
approval process is in the early stages.
The plan's draft environmental impact report is scheduled to be
heard by the city Planning Commission on Thursday. Ultimately, the
project will need approval from the Board of Supervisors.
E-mail Robert Selna at rselna@sfchronicle.com.