FBI probes L.A. Housing Dept.'s actions in affordable housing project

Friday, April 9, 2010
Jessica Garrison
Los Angeles Times

The FBI is investigating an affordable-housing deal in which Los
Angeles officials channeled $26 million to a development company
officer who they knew was under criminal investigation for alleged
misuse of public funds, city officials said Thursday.

The officer, David Rubin, was indicted last fall in New York for
alleged bid rigging and fraud, charges unconnected to the L.A. project.

The $26 million went toward construction of a 92-unit apartment
building near downtown L.A. for seniors, some of them homeless and
disabled. Though ready for occupants, it has sat empty since December
while many prospective tenants live in shelters or substandard housing.

The city's Housing Authority, concerned about irregularities in the
deal, has refused to release money that would pay the tenants' rent.
Without that rental income, the developer, Enhanced Affordable, could
be forced into default. In turn, the city could be on the hook for
millions of state and federal dollars that it helped arrange for the
developer, City Controller Wendy Greuel said in an interview Thursday.
She added that the way officials handled the deal "defies
comprehension."

But advocates for the homeless are incensed for another reason. They
say it is inexcusable that the city is allowing a new building to sit
vacant while homeless seniors suffer.

"It's terrible. It's a travesty. These people are sick . . . some of
them will die prematurely without housing," said Ruth Schwartz,
executive director of Shelter Partnership, which helped find homeless
seniors for the project.

She added that she wants the city and the mayor to find "the political
will" to work out the red tape and "help move the people in."

The controversial deal was the subject of an audit released Thursday by Greuel's office.

FBI agents have requested notes and documents gathered during the audit, the controller's office said.

An FBI spokeswoman said the agency could not confirm or deny any involvement in the matter.

The city agency involved in the deal is the Housing Department, which
oversees compliance with rent control laws and aids construction of
privately run, affordable apartments. The Housing Authority, a separate
agency, manages federal Section 8 rental vouchers and city-owned
housing projects.

The audit found that in 2007 and 2008, Housing Department officials
"blatantly disregarded information that . . . one of the partners was
under federal investigation."

Officials "then chose not to share this information with the city
attorney or other stakeholders," Greuel said in a letter to Mayor
Antonio Villaraigosa and other city leaders.

The audit does not accuse any city officials of criminal behavior or allege that the $26 million was misspent.

Doug Guthrie, the newly appointed head of the Housing Department, said
he was working to find a way to "get these people housed."

Guthrie succeeded Mercedes Marquez, who headed the agency when the deal
went through. She has since moved on to a job at the U.S. Housing and
Urban Development department in Washington, D.C. Marquez could not be
reached for comment.

"We are left today with a much-needed project [that] sits empty," Greuel said, calling it "a fiasco."

Officials in the Housing Department, she added, "appeared to act in the
developer's best interest, as opposed to the best interest of the city
and the taxpayers."

City officials should notify the city attorney, the City Council and
other officials of legal issues involving prospective developers and
conduct more thorough background investigations, the audit said.

Rubin's attorney, Donald Etra, declined to comment, directing calls to
Marc Gelman, chief executive of Enhanced Affordable. Gelman said the
company had done nothing wrong, adding that it severed ties with Rubin
after requests from officials in the Housing Department whom he
declined to name.

Gelman blamed squabbling city agencies for keeping homeless seniors
from moving in to the new building and said he might sue the city for
not releasing the rent money.

"It's all political. . . . I have an empty building that every day
costs money to operate, pay the debt . . . a minimum of a few thousand
dollars a day," Gelman said. "And these poor homeless people, we have
them coming to our office, our building, on a daily basis."

FAIR USE NOTICE. This document may contain copyrighted material the
use of which may not have been specifically authorized by the copyright
owner. Tenants Together is making this article available on our website
in an effort to advance the understanding of tenant rights issues in
California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such
copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the U.S.
Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for
purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain
permission from the copyright owner. 

Help build power for renters' rights: