Feds offer aid to renters as well as homeowners

Sunday, August 15, 2010
Kathleen Pender
The San Francisco Chronicle

Congress and the Obama administration have committed tens of billions of dollars to keep homeowners in their homes.

Renters, who make up about one-third of households nationwide - and
close to two-thirds in San Francisco and other large cities - wish the
government would do a little more for them.

For homeowners, Obama's Making Home Affordable program obtained $50
billion from the Troubled Assets Relief Program plus $25 billion,
mainly from Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac.

Originally this money was supposed to help homeowners refinance or
modify subprime mortgages (which qualified as troubled assets). More
recently it has been used to help those who can't pay their mortgage
because they are unemployed. Last week, the Treasury said it is using
$2 billion to help unemployed homeowners in 17 states, including
California.

The financial reform bill will provide an additional $1 billion to
help homeowners who can't pay their mortgage because of job or medical
problems. Homeowners can get up to $50,000 in mortgage subsidies over
two years.

Congress has not ignored renters. Last year, it passed a law that
lets tenants stay in a home that has been foreclosed upon for 90 days
or, in most cases, until the lease runs out.

The stimulus act, passed in February 2009, provided $4 billion to
public housing agencies for capital and management activities such as
rehabilitating vacant rental units. It also included $2 billion to
provide Section 8 housing assistance payments to owners of multifamily
rental housing units, which also supports housing for low-income
renters.

It also provided $1.5 billion over three years to create a new
program for renters called the Homeless Prevention and Rapid Re-Housing
Program.

Administered by the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban
Development, the program provides short- to medium-term rental
assistance to people who are either homeless (including those in
shelters) or would be homeless without the assistance.

The money was distributed to state and local governments, which in
many cases are working with nonprofit agencies to help those in need.
The program has spent about 25 percent of funds available to help more
than 500,000 people, according to HUD.

Agencies can use the money to provide services such as outreach,
housing search and placement, counseling, legal services and credit
repair. They can also use it to pay for a qualified person's rent,
utility bills, moving expenses and security and utility deposits.
Payments are made directly to the renter's landlord or utility.

HUD allows agencies to pay up to 100 percent of a person's rent for
up to 18 months (including up to six months of unpaid back rent). To
qualify, a household must earn 50 percent or less of the median income
for their area and prove that if it wasn't for this assistance, they
would be homeless.

Local government agencies can set lower income or assistance limits or impose additional eligibility criteria.

San Francisco's program

San Francisco's Human Services Agency is getting $8.7 million over
three years, which it is distributing through six nonprofits such as
Catholic Charities CYO and the Eviction Defense Collaborative. (For
details, see links.sfgate.com/ZKDD.)

It plans to spend roughly $2.8 million for services, $5.5 million
for direct assistance and the rest for administration. To date, the six
agencies combined have spent about $2 million and helped close to 1,000
households, according to Cindy Ward, the agency's manager of family
programs.

It limits rent subsidies to $800 per month and restricts eligibility
to those who earn 35 percent or less of the area's median income and
have at least one additional risk factor such as a sudden loss of
income, disability or recent eviction.

Who gets help

It has helped people such as Enkhtsetseg "Nora" Norovsambuu, 40,
who came to San Francisco seven years ago from Mongolia and was granted
asylum as a domestic abuse victim.

Norovsambuu, who lives in a one-bedroom apartment with her three
children, fell two months behind on her rent after a roommate got tired
of the noise and moved out. She had received an eviction notice when a
friend referred her to Catholic Charities. After verifying her
eligibility for the HUD program, Catholic Charities paid all her back
rent and $187 per month toward her rent for May, June and July, for
total assistance of $2,707.

Norovsambuu has a work-study job at City College, where she is
learning English and plans to train for a nursing-home career. She also
gets a small amount from CalWORKS and food stamps.

After getting a new roommate (who works when the kids are home) and
a second job cleaning houses twice a month, she's now able to pay 100
percent of her $1,073 monthly rent.

Choking back tears, Norovsambuu says the assistance "made a big
difference." Without it, she never could have paid her back rent and
doesn't know where she would have ended up.

Yasmeen Gonzalez was living with her two kids - 1 and 2 years old -
in La Casa de las Madres, a shelter for domestic violence victims, when
she learned about the HUD program. The shelter helped her get an office
job at UCSF through the city's Jobs Now program (also funded with
stimulus money).

And with help from the rental assistance program, she was able to
move into a $1,065-per-month studio apartment in Daly City. The program
pays $784 a month toward rent and she pays the rest. She hopes to stay
on at UCSF when funding for her job ends this fall and return to City
College part time in January.

"This assistance has meant a lot to me," says Gonzalez, 23. "I was able to accomplish a lot in a period of seven months."

The silver lining

Ted Gullicksen, director of the San Francisco Tenants Union, wishes
the government would provide more subsidies for struggling renters and,
when they lose a job, let them break a lease or bring in as many
roommates as the housing code allows.

"During the housing boom, one of the side effects was that rents
went up," he says. When the recession hit, "We were all left paying
really high rents and facing really high unemployment."

He says homeowners are getting more attention than renters because
the foreclosure crisis "shocked people and politicians. One of the
benefits of homeownership is security of tenure. That was upset. The
fact that this had never happened in most people's lifetimes drew a lot
of attention from government.

"Especially among low-income homeowners, there was a strong
perception that they had been pushed into homeownership by conniving
real estate brokers and banks and they were innocent victims of the
crisis."

On the bright side, the housing crisis is giving renters more
respect. "We are seeing more articles saying that tenants aren't
necessary bad, in some cases they are making the right economic
decision," he says.

To learn more about the HUD program, see www.hudhre.info. For a list of state and local governments that have received funds, see links.sfgate.com/ZKBG.

FAIR USE NOTICE. This
document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been
specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this
article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of
tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair
use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the
U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes
of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the
copyright owner.

Help build power for renters' rights: