Folsom dumps affordable housing mandate

Monday, January 17, 2011
Loretta Kalb
The Sacramento Bee

The city of Folsom, sued a decade ago over the community's lack
of affordable housing, will soon stop requiring developers to provide
low- income units with every large residential project.

The City
Council instead plans to rely on voluntary initiatives and builder
incentives to meet the state's affordable housing goals, saying the
mandatory program hasn't worked and has stymied market-rate projects.

The
unanimous vote last Tuesday night, to be affirmed by an expected pro
forma final vote later, ends a nine-year-old city ordinance aimed at
meeting the housing needs of limited wage earners in new development
areas.

The vote was criticized by housing advocates, lauded by builders' representatives and defended by council members.

"All
you ideologues out there may think you have the theoretical solution"
to getting affordable housing built, a video of the meeting shows
Councilman Jeffrey Starsky saying. But "this is the city that actually
puts things on the ground and gets it done.

"You will see in the next 10 years we're going to actually build this stuff."

The
voluntary measures are expected to encourage future affordable housing
projects in high-density areas, near rail lines and transit centers.
City officials say much of the demand will be for rental housing.

Folsom's
existing plan was established by ordinance in 2002 after Legal Services
of Northern California filed suit on behalf of a Folsom resident over
the city's failure to provide for affordable housing.

The city is
required to provide zoning for affordable dwellings. So it settled the
2001 suit in part by agreeing to rezone 128 acres. It also sought,
through the ordinance, to keep 15 percent of future development
affordable.

In total, a dozen jurisdictions in the region have
so-called "inclusionary" ordinances incorporating housing for moderate,
low- and very low-income residents with market-rate projects.

Folsom's
decision will not affect similar housing programs that exist inside
redevelopment areas. Outside the city, many jurisdictions in the region
already rely on voluntary measures to reach their affordable housing
goals.

Housing advocates sought unsuccessfully to discourage the Folsom City Council's outright abandonment of the program.

Mona
Tawatao, regional counsel for Legal Services, urged more modest steps,
suggesting in a Jan. 3 letter that some elements of the ordinance could
be suspended until the economy recovers.

The Sacramento Housing Alliance, represented by Legal Services, issued its own warning.

Eliminating
the ordinance entirely will make it difficult for affordable units to
become part of large, planned unit developments in the city's expansion
area south of Highway 50, Shamus Roller, executive director of the
Housing Alliance, told the council.

"We're looking at our legal options," Roller said later during an interview.

The
Folsom ordinance requires builders of residential projects with 10 or
more units to set aside 15 percent of the homes for limited income
residents.

In the early years of the last decade, mainly as the
real estate market was powering up, 264 homes were built under the
ordinance, according to a staff report.

But when the downturn hit
and construction stalled, financially squeezed developers complained
that the requirement to build affordable-rate units amounted to a
subsidy that rendered market-rate units too costly.

Cathy
Creswell, acting director of the state Department of Housing and
Community Development, said nothing in state law requires a city to have
a mandatory program.

But, she said, if Folsom eliminates the
program, the city still must demonstrate how it intends to meet its
future housing needs.

FAIR USE NOTICE. This
document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been
specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this
article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of
tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair
use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the
U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes
of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the
copyright owner.

Help build power for renters' rights: