Foreclosure dilemma: To pay rent or not?

Friday, December 9, 2011
Derek Moore
The Press Democrat

At an Oct. 14 Occupy Sonoma rally in the city's Plaza, four-term city councilman Ken Brown grabbed a bullhorn to denounce the greedy banks that he said were responsible for his family's eviction from their rented home.

The sentiment was not surprising coming from a self-proclaimed “hippie politician” who wears sandals and a ponytail at many city functions and generally has a dim view of corporate interests.

But Brown, who this week was selected by his peers to be Sonoma's mayor pro tem, failed to mention at the rally that he and his family have been living rent-free in the Amedeo Court home for months after a bank foreclosed on the landlord.

Since May, Brown and his wife have been pocketing $2,150 a month — or $15,050 through December — while they and two of their children continue to live at the 3-bedroom, 2-bath house.

The couple's actions place them at the center of a national debate over the legal and moral requirements borne by tenants, homeowners and lenders in a housing market that has shifted views of responsibility.

As an elected public official, Brown faces heightened public scrutiny of his actions and also may subject him to state rules on income and gifts.

The 64-year-old Vietnam veteran has not shied away from using his position to help his family's cause, including pleas made at City Council meetings for help finding another place to live.

“Above and beyond my duty to the city of Sonoma and its citizens, I have a duty to my family,” he said.

Attorneys for the Bank of New York Mellon contended in a lawsuit filed Oct. 6 in Sonoma County Superior Court that the councilman and his family essentially had a duty to move out of the house months before the case was settled on November 22.

But at the house this week, Brown disputed the bank's version of events and said he is “clear” that he and his wife “acted within the abilities of a tenant and tenant's rights.”

“We've been renters for three decades and we've never had an issue with a landlord,” Brown said.

Property records show that the home's former owner, Tim Gamber, went into default on the property in September last year. Several other houses that Brown said Gamber built on the court also have been lost to foreclosure.

Gamber could not be reached this week for comment.

Brown said a real estate agent in May offered him $5,700 to move out of the house. Such “cash for keys” transactions are allowed under California law, but Brown said he turned the offer down.

“We have consistently asked to stay here. We have consistently explored the possibility of buying the home,” he said.

The bank lawsuit states that a notice for the tenants to vacate the property within 30 or 90 days was posted on the property on July 6 and also sent there by mail.

Brown and his wife, Jewel Mathieson, submitted signed affidavits stating that they never saw the posting and don't recall receiving a copy of it in the mail.

Under California law, tenants living in a home that has been foreclosed upon must continue to pay rent or risk eviction, according to a spokesman for the state's Department of Consumer Affairs.

But Brown and his wife said they did not know who to pay rent to. “There was absolutely nothing in that notice that discussed payment, and I pursued that avenue,” he said.

Tom Kelly III, Brown's Santa Rosa attorney, said he made similar attempts on Brown's behalf after he became involved with the case in October.

“I was never able to get someone who could exercise any authority,” Kelly said.

Brown said he is out more than $5,000 he said he and his wife paid in deposit fees when they moved into the house.

Brown said he is paid to host a weekly radio show in Sonoma and that he also receives a $300 monthly stipend for serving on the council. His wife co-owns a cannabis dispensary in Santa Rosa.

The couple said their search for another place to live was hindered by the fact they have a dog, and because their search had to be limited to Sonoma so that Brown could continue to serve in city government.

As to their desire to remain where they are, a spokeswoman for Bank of America, which services the loan on the property and handled the foreclosure proceedings, said the couple could have worked with the real estate agent if they were interested in paying rent or purchasing the property.

“To say he didn't know, he had that Realtor information in May, and maybe even earlier,” Jumana Bauwens said.

But in practice, banks generally aren't aggressive about seeking such payments.

“After a foreclosure sale, banks generally do not demand rent from tenants because the bank's goal is to re-market the property to a new homeowner,” Bauwens said.

The banks nevertheless used Brown's non-payment of rent as leverage in their effort to force him and his family out of the house.

The Oct. 6 lawsuit was brought by the Bank of New York Mellon, acting as trustee for CWALT, Inc., or Countrywide Alternative Loan Trust.

A spokesman said BNY Mellon acts as a trustee on certain mortgage-backed securitizations, which are created when a large number of mortgage loans are pooled and placed in a trust. He said in that limited administrative role, the primary function of the bank is to calculate and distribute monthly bond payments to investors.

The servicer — in this case, Bank of America — is responsible for the maintenance of the loan and borrower records and for responding to general questions or inquiries by borrowers. The servicer is also required to service the properties and loans in the event of default or foreclosure proceedings.

“It can get a little confusing, to say the least,” said Kevin Heine with BNY Mellon.

The suit, which named Gamber and tenants of the home as defendants, demanded possession of the property and damages of $130.37 a day, which the suit claimed was the “reasonable daily rental value” of the house. That amounts to $3,965 a month.

But the bank dropped the monetary demands in the settlement reached on Nov. 22. As part of the agreement, Brown and his wife agreed to move out of the house by Jan. 5. The couple this week put down a deposit on another home in Sonoma and are planning to move.

Brent T. White, an Associate Professor of Law at the University of Arizona and an expert on the mortgage crisis, faulted the bank on moral grounds for not being more clear with Brown on where he could have continued to make rental payments, and then turning around and demanding that money as part of the lawsuit seeking his eviction.

“It's the obligation of the bank to inform the new tenant that they now own the home and that they will honor the lease, and that rent should be sent to X address,” White said. “I think a lender who doesn't do that shouldn't complain.”

Brown may have another issue to sort out. A spokeswoman for the state's Fair Political Practices Commission said Friday that the councilman's non-payment of rent could constitute a gift or income under the state's Political Reform Act and may need to be reported.

She said officeholders must file statements of economic interest annually and report all sources of income above $500 and gifts worth more than $50.

FAIR
USE NOTICE. Tenants Together is not the author of this article and the posting
of this document does not imply any endorsement of the content by Tenants
Together.  This document may contain copyrighted material the use of which
may not have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants
Together is making this article available on our website in an effort to
advance the understanding of tenant rights issues in California. We believe
that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided
for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this
copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you
must obtain permission from the copyright owner.

Help build power for renters' rights: