Foreclosures can make you sick, report says

Thursday, September 2, 2010
Victoria Colliver
San Francisco Chronicle




As Dianne Huntsberry was losing her home last
year, the result of a financing scam, she also wound up in the hospital -
twice - for what seemed like heart problems.

"I thought I was having a heart attack - I didn't know what was going
on," said Huntsberry, 51, who said an unlicensed broker convinced her
to put his name on the deed of her Oakland home in exchange for a low
rate, but then took the equity and signed the home over to a bank.

Huntsberry's heart palpitations turned out to be an anxiety attack,
which she attributed to the foreclosure. She was put on medication for
high blood pressure and stress. Today, nearly a year later, she still
struggles with health issues: weight gain, canker sores, skin problems,
acid reflux and insomnia.

A report released Wednesday found foreclosures have not only economic
consequences, but create health problems for the people and families
involved - and those effects can ripple throughout a community.

In a survey of nearly 400 residents in two Oakland neighborhoods
particularly hard hit by the foreclosure crisis, the Alameda County
Public Health Department and Causa Justa/Just Cause, a housing rights
group, teamed up to look at how people undergoing foreclosure experience
higher levels of stress and increased medical problems. Tenants living
in buildings in foreclosure have similar problems.

More health troubles

The research builds on work already conducted by Alameda County
health officials showing that areas with the highest rates of
foreclosures, such as the East and West Oakland neighborhoods surveyed
in the report, already have life expectancies about 10 years less than
other parts of Alameda County due to various social and economic
factors, including high unemployment and crime rates.

Foreclosures exacerbate the health problems.

The report "really highlights much of what we know about communities
that are already overburdened by poor health outcomes," said Sandra
Witt, deputy director of the Alameda County Public Health Department.

According to the report, which was funded by the California
Endowment, a private foundation promoting health care, 1 in 4 Oakland
property owners received a notice of default on their mortgage,
signaling the start of foreclosure proceedings.

The survey found that residents who are going through foreclosure or
recently lost their homes were more than twice as likely to say that
their mental and physical health had worsened over the past two years
than those not going through foreclosure. Those residents were also
twice as likely to report stress, depression or anxiety over the past
month.

Residents in the two Oakland neighborhoods reported increased crime
levels, with vacant properties serving as magnets for illegal activity.
Adding to the strain, foreclosures disrupted social connections as
neighbors moved out, a problem that can be particularly difficult on
children who may have to change schools.

"This kind of financial distress leads to intense levels of stress,
which, in turn, makes it not at all surprising to find people who are
suffering emotional and, in some cases, physical consequences," said
Paul Leonard, director of the California office of the Center for
Responsible Lending, a consumer advocacy group.

Leonard said the report documents the kinds of impacts that health
and housing experts hear about anecdotally. "This provides some really
concrete evidence that foreclosures have many different kinds of
negative impacts on borrowers and communities," he said.

Health problems are not limited to property owners, but extend to
tenants who may not even know the property is in peril until they
receive notice that their utilities will be shut off or when bank agents
contact them.

200,000 displaced

About 37 percent of the foreclosed units in California were occupied
by renters in 2009, which means that about 200,000 residents were
displaced, according to a May report by Tenants Together, a statewide
renters' rights organization based in San Francisco.

"When people think of the foreclosure crisis, they tend to think of
the homeowners," said Gabe Treves, program coordinator with the group.
He added that foreclosures cause tenants stress and often force them to
live in substandard conditions.

"Tenants are absolutely the innocent victims of the foreclosure crisis," he said.

After she lost her home, Huntsberry, who works in security at a
state health lab in Richmond, moved into an Oakland apartment that's
about a fifth of the size of the home she owned for 13 years. She said
she still wakes up in the wee hours of the morning and often turns to
prayer.

"I've just been robbed of everything, and I have nothing to show for it," she said.

In sickness and in foreclosure

Last
summer, representatives from Causa Justa/Just Cause interviewed 388
residents in East and West Oakland, two of the harder-hit neighborhoods,
to investigate the impact of the foreclosures on health. Here are some
of the findings:

-- Residents going through foreclosure or those who had recently lost
their homes were twice as likely as others to say their mental and
physical health had become worse over the past two years.

-- More than 3 in 10 foreclosed residents reported forgoing medical care due to money concerns.

-- 31 percent of tenants in foreclosed buildings said they were
living with mold, rodents, cockroaches or other unhealthy conditions.

Read the report: The Alameda County Public Health
Department will post the report, "Rebuilding Neighborhoods, Restoring
Health," this afternoon at www.acphd.org.

Source: Alameda County Public Health Department; Causa Justa/Just Cause

Help for tenants

Tenants in
foreclosed properties can contact Tenants Together at
tenantstogether.org.

 

FAIR USE NOTICE. This
document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been
specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this
article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of
tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair
use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the
U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes
of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the
copyright owner.

Help build power for renters' rights: