Foreclosures leave renters in a quandary

Sunday, October 17, 2010
Mike Perrault
The Desert Sun

A group of residents at the gated, upscale Villorrio Village in Palm Springs are discovering just how much a property owner's financial woes can impact their lives.

Default notices were recently posted on 13 condo doors, confirming what many tenants already knew or suspected: Owner Maurice Monnig and his firm, Palm Springs Gardens LLP, leased the condos to residents but ultimately defaulted on a $3 million-plus loan.

Monnig's lender has started foreclosure proceedings, and court-appointed receiver Ross Crowe, who is executive managing director of CRC Impresa LLC, has stepped in to oversee the property.

A public auction to sell the property is scheduled by year's end.

Tenants such as Paul and Nezha Roide are left wondering what will happen to their security deposits, advanced rent payments and homeowners' association dues.

The couple and other tenants aren't sure whether to continue paying rent or sign a proposed new 12-month lease with rent hikes. They worry that persistent problems with plumbing, air conditioning and other issues will go unheeded.

“All we want is a fair shake,” Roide said. “Indeed, the bank could sell the property. I don't know what happens if we sign a year's lease. The bank could say quite literally, ‘Hey, that wasn't our deal.'”

Similar scenarios have played out across the Coachella Valley as commercial and home foreclosures mount in the slumping economy. Those in condos, apartments and houses often are unsure about their options.

Laws such as the federal Protecting Tenants at Foreclosure Act that went into effect last year, along with recent changes in California civil code, are designed to ensure tenants have rights and adequate time to find alternative housing, said Aurelia Wick, managing attorney for Inland Counties Legal Services' Housing Law Services Center in Indio.
California Attorney General Jerry Brown announced in June that he has launched an investigation aimed at protecting the rights of “forgotten victims” of the housing market collapse — tens of thousands of tenants facing eviction from properties that have been foreclosed on by banks.

Brown sent letters to dozens of banks, loan servicers, private investors and law firms demanding information about whether they were complying with federal, state and local laws regarding foreclosed properties and treatment of tenants.

Although tenant situations vary based on the type of bankruptcy, foreclosure or other action taking place, generally renters must be given 90 days' notice, and new owners must honor leases, Wick said.
Refusing to pay

At Villorrio, Crowe is trying to answer tenants' questions about security deposits, rental payments, leases and repairs on the 5-year-old condos.

He has spent years as a receiver.

Scott Brooks is an accountant and tenant who has complained that he only has enough hot water for about a 45-second shower. Some condos are “wracked with plumbing problems,” Brooks said.

Amid all the uncertainties, some tenants are being offered new yearlong leases that Crowe said must be honored by the current borrower, lender or future owner and lender.

“We extended offers of reduced rent, reduced pet deposits as well as one month free rent, amortized over a new 12-month term as incentive to keep tenants and maintain stability in the assets,” he said.

But some tenants in the condos at 1050 E. Baristo Road said the proposed lease actually means rent increases and higher fees to keep pets.

Crowe said CRC Impresa conducted a market study and established a market rent of $1.17 per square foot. So proposed new leases were based on each condo's square footage.

He said the Roides, for instance, would see a $43 monthly savings in a new 12-month lease.

Some tenants said they're unsure whether to keep paying rent just weeks before the property is to be auctioned after having paid security deposits and advance rent to Monnig.

Crowe said some tenants refused to pay October's rent and that, along with other issues, has caused friction between he and some tenants.
Sheila Erger, a resident in the complex for two years, said she sent a certified letter to Crowe asking that her prepaid rent be applied to cover October and November.

But like some other residents, Erger this week was given a “Notice to Pay Rent or Quit,” giving her three days to pay up or vacate the property.

The past-due rent notices came with $100 late fees.

Crowe said the notices were sent out to tenants who “refused to provide proof of rent payment” and to others who simply have not paid rent in October per their lease obligations.

He said notices were not sent to tenants who provided proof of prepaid rent from their banks.

Gary Whitehead, a Palm Springs accountant and paralegal who has volunteered to help some tenants, questioned the validity of CRC Impresa's three-day notices.

“A lot of times, three-day notices are flawed,” he said.

Some tenants said they've been notified of rent increases based on $1.17 per square foot market rent.

Crowe said the lender or future buyer will be responsible for returning security deposits to tenants when they move out.

But Roide said he and some other tenants still question whether the receiver will honor security deposits and prepaid rent that they put down in good faith on the leases when they paid the owner.

Some tenants have sought legal help, and others aren't sure what to do.

“No one wants an eviction on their record, but we want to stand up for our rights,” said Roide, who worries the couple might have to move out just as they're planning to welcome their kids home for the holidays.

Some tenants fear their deposit money was “lost” amid the financial turmoil and is not available to the receivership.

As for repairs, Crowe said he can “address problems” going forward as of about Oct. 1.

“A maintenance vendor has been approved to begin investigating and repairing problems this week, and we have no idea how long that effort will take,” Crowe said.

Brown said more than one-third of all the residential units in foreclosures across California are rentals, according to tenants' rights groups such as Tenants Together.

A spokesman for his office said more than 200,000 tenants in the state have been uprooted during the housing crisis.

FAIR USE NOTICE. This document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.

Help build power for renters' rights: