After roughly 90 minutes of angry testimony from
tenants and landlords, a Los Angeles City Council committee called
Wednesday for a four-month prohibition on rent increases at an estimated
630,000 apartments.
On a 3-1 vote, the Council’s Housing,
Community and Economic Development Committee supported a plan to bar
owners of rent-controlled buildings – properties with two or more units
that were constructed before 1978 – from raising rents on July 1.
The
proposed moratorium heads to the City Council for a vote on Friday,
setting the stage for a showdown between landlords and renters, both of
whom said they have been struggling in the economic downturn. Under the
plan, the moratorium could be extended an extra two months, to Dec. 31.
Councilman
Herb Wesson, who heads the committee, said the moratorium would give
council members time to assess a proposal to tie rent increases to the
inflation rate. Wesson said his plan would serve as a compromise with
Councilman Richard Alarcon, who wanted to ban landlords from raising
rents on rent-controlled buildings for a full year.
Alarcon said
landlords should not impose new costs on their tenants in the middle of a
recession.
“Do I want to allow a group to increase its income when the people that
they are providing apartments to are losing income? I have to say, I
can’t be a party to that,” Alarcon told the audience. “I cannot align
myself with allowing people to benefit when tens of thousands are
struggling in Los Angeles.”
Landlords spoke out against the plan,
with some saying it would prompt them to have their property values
reassessed downward to reflect their reduced value. Others said they
would have a difficult time finding the money to repair and maintain
their properties.
“This is financial suicide for the city,” said
Yolanda Gonzalez, who owns four apartments in Venice and another 14 in
Boyle Heights.
Renters rights groups contend that unless a
moratorium is enacted, the city’s rent stabilization law would allow
rent to go up by 3% on July 1 -- even though inflation was less than
zero last year. Tenants now paying $1,000 a month, for example, would
see their costs rise to $1,030. In certain large buildings where
landlords pay for the utilities, rents could go up by as much as 5%.
Landlords
and tenants packed the committee’s hearing room and a spillover room at
on the 10th Floor of City Hall at Wednesday’s meeting.
Two
building owners said rent control already made it to impossible to get
loans to make long-term repairs. A third complained that the moratorium
would go into effect on the same day that the Department of Water and
Power imposes a 4.8% electricity rate hike.
Renters, in turn,
talked about reductions in Social Security payments and their ongoing
struggle to find work.
Venice resident Cindy Chambers told the
committee that she lost her job in November 2008 and recently received a
written notice that her rent would go up.
“My landlord knows my
situation,” Chambers said. “In fact, a few months ago he told me that
living on unemployment must be a good life.”
Backers of the
moratorium include the Coalition for Economic Survival and the Los
Angeles Community Action Network, two tenant groups. Foes of the plan
include the Los Angeles Area Chamber of Commerce and the Central City
Assn., two business groups.
Councilwoman Jan Perry cast the lone
vote against the proposal, saying it “polarizes the situation” between
renters and landlords. Councilman Ed Reyes favored it, saying that as
many as 75% of his constituents are renters.
“There are thousands
and thousands of people out there in the working class who just don’t
have a voice.”
-- David Zahniser at Los Angeles City Hall
FAIR USE NOTICE. This
document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been
specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this
article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of
tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair
use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the
U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes
of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the
copyright owner.