Fremont mobile home park residents again face major rent increase or park closure

Monday, May 24, 2010
Matthew Artz
The Oakland Tribune

FREMONT — Residents of an
over-55 mobile home park once again are being threatened with the
park's closure unless the owners are granted a major rent increase.

The
owners of Besaro Mobile Home Park in north Fremont have appealed in
state and federal court a hearing officer's ruling last year denying
them the right to increase rents by as much as 40 percent on some
tenants.

If the appeals fail, the owners will close the park, said their attorney, Anthony Rodriguez.

The
30-acre, 236-space park at 4141 Deep Creek Road has been at the center
of a long-standing battle between the owners and the city, which has
strict guidelines limiting rent increases at mobile home parks.

In
court papers filed earlier this month, Rodriguez argued that Fremont's
rent control law has prevented Besaro from "catching up with rents at
(Fremont's) Southlake and Niles Canyon" mobile home parks.

In 2008, average rents at Besaro were $669 compared with $715 at Niles Canyon and $782 at Southlake.

But
park residents say the owners' proposal to bring rents from the current
average of $669 to $895 would force several of them from their homes.

"Many
of the residents are elderly, living on fixed incomes and fighting to
survive in these tough economic conditions," wrote Besaro Homeowner
Association President Larry Alsterlind.

The owners had offered to rescind rent increases for hardship cases, but residents don't trust the owners to safeguard their financial information, Alsterlind said.

In
2001, a hearing officer granted park owners a major rent increase, but
last year, Judge Ruth Astle rejected the owners' request, citing that
their profit margins and expenses had held steady in recent years.

The park turned a $1.18 million profit in 2007, according to the most recent city records.

Besaro
was developed in the 1970s by four men and is now run by their heirs,
who include David Beretta, a prominent Fremont property owner, and Jack
Rogers, a former city of Fremont department head, who managed Suzanne
Chan's successful 2008 City Council campaign.

The owners recently
lost a legal battle with Fremont over a city law that limits how much
they can increase rents when a mobile home park space becomes vacant.

Mobile
homes can cost more than $30,000 to move, and there are few vacancies
at nearby parks. Consequently, the value of mobile homes is tied to the
stability of the park where they're located.

In the case of
Besaro, the owners' repeated threats to close the park have made it
difficult for residents to sell their homes and recoup their
investments. If the owners succeed with their appeal, they'll keep the
park open longer but still plan to close it eventually, Rodriguez said.
"The underlying land is worth so much."

Rodriguez anticipated it
would take two to three years for the appeals process to play out. If
the owners decide to close the park, they likely would sue the city
over its ordinance requiring mobile park owners to pay for their
tenants' moving expenses if they go out of business.

FAIR USE NOTICE. This
document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been
specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this
article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of
tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair
use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the
U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes
of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the
copyright owner.

Help build power for renters' rights: