Gentrification Evictions Could Amount to Elder Abuse

Thursday, March 10, 2016
Brendan P. Bartholomew
San Francisco Examiner

Evictions in the Bay Area, where the cost of living has skyrocketed in recent years, appear to have taken a fatal turn.

The death of a 97-year-old woman in Burlingame on March 3 was widely reported by local and international news agencies, with quotes from friends and supporters of Marie Hatch claiming she was “done in” by the stress of being evicted from her home of 66 years.

But what many reports missed, according to a local housing activist, is that Hatch was only the latest Peninsula senior resident who died shortly after being hit with eviction notices or staggering rent increases.

Hatch lived with her friend Georgia Rothrock, 85, in a modest, brown-and-white cottage at the corner of California Drive and Oak Grove Avenue. Despite the home’s location on a noisy thoroughfare, next to a busy auto mechanic’s shop, real estate website Zillow pegs the dwelling’s value at $1.2 million.

Lawyer Nanci Nishimura, who represented Hatch on a pro bono basis, said she will continue to fight the eviction on Rothrock’s behalf. Nishimura’s firm, Cotchett, Pitre, & McCarthy, LLP, is suing landlord David Kantz.

Kantz said he could not comment on the case.

The lawsuit alleges the cottage’s original owner, the late Vivian Kroeze, promised Hatch she could live in the home until Hatch died. Hatch had served as Kroeze’s caregiver, and the agreement constituted an oral contract, which was honored by Kroeze’s daughter and granddaughter, Nishimura said.

Kantz was married to Kroeze’s granddaughter when she was murdered in 2006, and gained control of the property as a result of her death. Kantz has claimed his late wife’s trust requires him to sell the cottage, according to Nishimura, but he has failed to produce a copy of the trust.

When Hatch received a 60-day eviction notice 10 days before Christmas last year, she had a panic attack and heart palpitations and was rushed to an emergency room, Nishimura said. This led to a lengthy hospitalization, and Hatch died soon after she was released from the hospital.

“For a senior citizen in this housing market, eviction is a death knell,” Nishimura said.

This type of story is all too familiar to Cynthia Cornell, who said she knows of at least three other local seniors who died soon after losing their homes. Cornell said she started her activist group, Burlingame Advocates for Renter Protections, after the deaths of her former neighbors, Gene and Patty Collins.

The Collinses had lived in an apartment building for seniors, Cornell said, but the building was sold, and the new owner immediately raised the Collins’ rent by $1,000.

“They struggled to pay for rent, food and medicine, and Gene died from the stress six months after being displaced,” Cornell noted. “He was trying to figure out how to make extra money at 79.”

Patty Collins was diagnosed with cancer and died two years ago. Cornell believes she might have had more strength to fight the illness if she had not been devastated by the loss of her husband and home.

And about a year ago, Cornell said, another friend, who was 80, died within 60 days of being evicted from his San Mateo apartment.

Cornell declined to provide his full name due to privacy concerns.

And just days before Hatch’s death earlier this month, Burlingame resident Darryl Wagner’s alleged suicide ignited rumors he had taken his life after a rent increase.

John Kevranian, a Burlingame business owner, said he heard from one of his customers that Wagner was informed of the rent increase and said he “couldn’t take it,” before he reportedly died by suicide.

The San Francisco Examiner was unable to independently verify claims that Wagner had spoken of a rent hike prior to his death.

Wagner’s landlord and brother both did not respond to interview requests.

The lawsuit against Kantz includes allegations of elder abuse, and Cornell has long described gentrification evictions as a form of elder abuse.

“My friends were the canaries in the coal mine,” Cornell said. “This is a cancer spreading to other elderly people and everyone else in the county and beyond.”

Issue: 
FAIR USE NOTICE. Tenants Together is not the author of this article and the posting of this document does not imply any endorsement of the content by Tenants Together. This document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.

Help build power for renters' rights: