Lots of people hate their landlords, but it
wouldn't occur to most of these unhappy tenants to take a bus across
town, to their landlord's corporate headquarters, in order to shout at
them from the sidewalk through a loudspeaker. And yet that's exactly
what happened yesterday, in front of the Richmond Street East offices
of MetCap Living, which manages 12,000 units in Ontario, including a few dozen apartment buildings in the GTA—many of them aging, and ten of which are located in Parkdale.
The crowd was about twenty strong, and the occasion for the gathering was the presentation of the Golden Cockroach Award,
a modified sports trophy given at irregular intervals by the Parkdale
Tenants Association to honour (or dishonour) whomever they deem to be
the Worst Landlord of the Year.
At
the microphone, Bart Poesiat, a community worker with Parkdale Legal
Services who had helped organize the event, accused MetCap of a long
litany of slumlord behaviour. The company, he said, allows apartments
to deteriorate until they're barely livable. He also accused MetCap of
bringing tenants to the Landlord and Tenant Board frivolously over rent
disputes, and then delaying proceedings after tenants have already
taken time off from work.
MetCap is, of course, only one of many corporate landlords in
Toronto with upkeep and tenant relations problems; the award is
somewhat arbitrary. Even so, they refused to accept it. "Our buildings
are fully occupied and if things were really an issue, I wouldn't be
able to lease the building," said MetCap president Brent Merrill to the Star yesterday.
"The rent is reasonable and we try to take care of everybody. If some
are not satisfied, it's not for lack of trying." Merrill attributed the
frequent court battles with tenants to his company's diligence in rent
collection, which he said is necessary in order to avoid thousands of
dollars in losses due to bad debt.
Not that MetCap would have been able to accept the award if it had
wanted to. "We had a situation where a landlord came down and grabbed
it, said 'thank you very much,' and we told him he couldn't have it,"
said Poesiat.
There is only one Golden Cockroach. It's like the Stanley Cup.
A man named Louis, who had moved out of his previous Parkdale
apartment building when MetCap took it over about five years ago only
to have his current Parkdale building also taken over by MetCap, is
convinced that the company mistreats its properties and the people who
live in them. After MetCap took over his new building, he said:
"Everything went downhill. We started getting cockroaches, and mice,
and bedbugs. Now the whole building's infested with bedbugs."
Bedbugs are now a citywide epidemic, especially prevalent in large
apartment buildings. Several MetCap properties are listed in the international Bedbug Registry, as are many hundreds of non-MetCap properties.
"My cat is only forty-one weeks old," continued Louis, "and he already caught sixty-eight mice."
Louis pays $820 per month for his one-bedroom apartment, which he
shares with his wife. They are both elderly, and thinking of moving out.
The City, for its part, has spent the past two years aggressively
ramping up inspections of apartment buildings. In 2008, Municipal
Licensing and Standards conducted only fourteen building audits. In
2009, they conducted 187, and this year they plan to do at least two
hundred. Meanwhile, the Mayor's Tower Renewal
program is in the early stages of retrofitting the city's stock of
concrete apartment buildings to make them more energy efficient. On the
provincial end of things, Bhutilla Karpoche, an assistant to Cheri
diNovo, MPP for Parkdale-High Park, told the crowd her boss is planning
to table a bill at Queen's Park to institute "real rent control and
landlord licensing." Until then, tenants with grievances can complain directly to Municipal Licensing and Standards to expedite inspection of their building or unit.
The official grievance process doesn't do much to lift the spirits,
though. The Golden Cockroach, on the other hand, does. It was presented
by a man dressed as Gandalf the Wizard, who said he had come from
Middle Earth to present the statuette to the "lord of the slums."
(Apparently Gandalf is attracted to things with "lord" in their names.)
No official complaint has ever been met with so much applause.
FAIR USE NOTICE. This
document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been
specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this
article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of
tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair
use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the
U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes
of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the
copyright owner.