completed its report on the City of Davis Affordable Housing Program.
The Grand Jury investigated allegations regarding the administration of
the affordable housing program in Davis. The Grand Jury found that over
time the City has successfully evolved an affordable housing program
that currently ensures fairness in the selection process and retains
rental properties and some homes in the program. Approximately 700 low
and moderate income households achieved home ownership through the
program since its inception about 20 years ago.
the City was far less successful with the Davis Area Cooperative
Housing Authority (DACHA). DACHA encountered practical and affordability
problems from the outset and currently no longer exists as an entity.
Among other conclusions, the Grand Jury found that greater care should
have been taken initially by the City and the Redevelopment Agency when
performing legal analysis of documents such as DACHA’s articles of
incorporation and bylaws and that better initial oversight of DACHA by
the City could have prevented this situation.
Grand Jury found that no inappropriate gift or use of public money was
made at any time, for any purpose by the City in connection with DACHA.
However, the City has incurred losses that may not be recovered and may
increase in the future. Better initial oversight of DACHA could have
prevented this.
Yolo County Grand Jury functions as a citizen ‘watchdog’ organization
to review the operations and performance of county and city governments,
school districts, and special districts. Based on these assessments,
the Grand Jury publishes its findings and may recommend constructive
action to improve the quality and effectiveness of local government.
public can access the full Davis Affordable Housing report and the six
reports released in April at the Grand Jury website:
http://www.yolocounty.org/index.aspx?page=780. The Grand Jury will
release an additional report next week, May 23rd. The last four
investigative reports and the final published volume containing all
twelve reports for the year will be issued on June 30.
Grand Jury investigated allegations of unfairness and misuse of public
funds in the administration of the affordable housing program in the
City of Davis (the City). The Grand Jury found that the City’s efforts
and policies administering affordable housing evolved over the past 30
years. The City’s original vision was to allow low and moderate income
households to achieve home ownership equity without restrictions on the
resale value of the properties. There was no lottery procedure to select
potential buyers and no open bid procedures to select potential
developers.
700 low and moderate income households achieved home ownership through
the program. Due to the absence of resale restrictions on value, there
are currently only 90 homes locked into the affordable housing program.
In response to public comment about the loss of homes from the program
and perceived unfairness in selecting eligible homeowners and
developers, the City successfully evolved an affordable housing program
that ensures fairness in the selection process and retains homes in the
program.
was far less successful with the Davis Area Cooperative Housing
Authority (DACHA). DACHA encountered practical and affordability
problems from the outset and currently no longer exists as an entity. As
of May 2011, the 20 properties built under the auspices of DACHA
remained in the affordable housing program, but the DACHA cooperative
has dissolved as a legal entity. The City has been involved in a lengthy
and expensive legal dispute with the original developers/consultants
for several years. This dispute has culminated in a lawsuit by the
developers/consultants which seeks to take possession of the DACHA
properties and any monetary proceeds from these properties from the City
and its citizens. Better initial oversight of DACHA by the City could
have prevented this. When the City has a financial interest in a
project, especially one based on a new or different concept, the City
should provide oversight to ensure that the project meets its goals and
does not result in a loss to the public.
inappropriate gift or use of public money was made at any time, for any
purpose by the City in connection with DACHA. However, the City has
incurred losses that may not be recovered and may increase in the
future. Better initial oversight of DACHA could have prevented this.
Code section 925(a) states “The grand jury may at any time examine the
books and records of any incorporated city or joint powers agency
located in the county. In addition to any other investigatory powers
granted by this chapter, the grand jury may investigate departments,
functions, and the method or system of performing the duties of any such
city or joint powers agency and make such recommendations as it may
deem proper and fit.”
Penal Code Section 933.1 further provides that “A grand jury may at any
time examine the books and records of a redevelopment agency … and, in
addition to any other investigatory powers granted by this chapter, may
investigate and report upon the method or system of performing the
duties of such agency of authority.”
investigation was initiated in response to complaints about the
fairness, alleged cover-up and misuse of public funds in administering
the Affordable Housing Program by the City and the Davis Redevelopment
Agency (DRA) in general, and DACHA specifically. That these are matters
of public interest to the citizens of the City and the Grand Jury is
demonstrated by the many articles and public comments published in local
media and the filing of multiple lawsuits.
Grand Jury interviewed City staff and attended City Council meetings to
determine and understand the development, evolution and current
administration of the affordable housing program in the City. The Grand
Jury reviewed information on the City’s web site, communications from
the public to and about the City, the ordinance concerning affordable
housing, staff communications with the City Council, financial documents
including audits, legal documents, and State and Federal government
requirements for affordable housing.
Grand Jury interviewed representatives of affordable housing developers
of rental and ownership equity projects and representatives of the
City. The Grand Jury also interviewed representatives of Rancho Yolo
Senior Community concerning conversion to an affordable housing
cooperative in the City.
the 1970s the City recognized a demand for affordable housing. A
variety of housing types and options were available to meet this demand.
Redevelopment agencies, including the DRA, were required by state law
in 1986 to set aside at least 20% of their tax increment funds for
affordable housing. Tax increment funds are generated from property
value increases in the redevelopment zone. In 1987 the City Council
adopted an inclusionary housing policy in its General Plan that required
all new housing subdivisions to include provision for affordable
housing. An inclusionary policy is a requirement that all residential
projects provide a specified percentage of affordable housing in the
development. This inclusionary requirement was subsequently approved as
the City’s Affordable Housing Ordinance in 1990.
1990 requirements, which are still in effect, are: 1) Ownership
projects with five or more units must have 25% of units be affordable;
2) Rental projects with five to 19 units must have 25% of units be
affordable; and 3) Rental projects with 20 units or more must have 35%
of units be affordable. The ownership units are usually provided through
a combination of on-site development by the for-profit developer and
land dedication to the City that is used to develop affordable housing
by a local nonprofit housing organization. Affordable rental units are
usually either built within the market rate development or through a
land dedication by the developer. To date, approximately 1,800
affordable units, of which approximately 1,100 are rental units, have
been built in the City under the auspices of this program.
the 1990 ordinance a housing unit was considered affordable if it cost
no more than 30% of an eligible household’s monthly income for rent and
utilities. Eligibility requirements for the units ranged from very low
to moderate income levels. The moderate category was added in 2005 and
suspended in 2009. An extremely low income household is currently
defined as one with household income at or below 30% of the Yolo County
median income (currently $72,500 for a family of four) and a moderate
income household is one at or below 120% of Yolo County median income.
Thus, the maximum household income for inclusion in these would be
$21,750 and $87,000 respectively. The maximum monthly rent would be 30%
of these income levels, divided by twelve.
equity accumulation restrictions were required in the loan documents or
deeds for affordable ownership units under the 1990 ordinance. The City
believed any increase in home value should be passed on to the low
income homeowners. This meant that the original buyers of the affordable
homes could sell the homes at market value to purchasers who had no
income restrictions. The sole limitation put on buyers was a requirement
they occupy the home for two years. No buyer/tenant selection
guidelines such as lotteries were included in the 1990 ordinance.
of the City’s approximately 700 affordable housing ownership units were
built during the 1990s and early 2000s. Of these 700 units, only 90
still remain in the affordable housing program. The rest were sold at
market value with significant profit to the sellers. The resold units
lacked affordable housing restrictions such as income restrictions for
buyers and equity accumulation limits. The 90 affordable units are: a)
60 units built in Green Terrace during the 1990s, b) the 20 DACHA units
built in 2003 and 2004, c) five units on Park Santiago, and d) five
units on Cassel Lane. According to the City, the reason for the slowdown
in unit construction is the lack of new building projects in the City
over the last 10 years. There are currently five ongoing or proposed
developments that include provision for affordable housing. These
include 18 affordable units in the Verona subdivision which are
currently under construction and approximately 20 to 21 units in the
proposed development in Chiles Ranch.
from the affordable housing program became apparent. The loss of units
from Wildhorse and Simmons Estates in particular aroused significant
public debate about whether permitting the sale of affordable units at
market value was an appropriate use of land dedicated by the developers
to the affordable housing program. Further questions were raised about
the fairness of the selection process for the original low income
buyers. The City responded by creating the Affordable Housing Task Force
and amending the 1990 ordinance.
altering the rules in several ways for access to affordable ownership
units. The maximum percentage of family income that could be used to pay
for housing costs and utilities was raised from 30% to 35% to help the
program compete better in the then booming housing market. Resale equity
escalation was limited to a small yearly percentage increase of the
unit value. This is currently set at a maximum of 3.75% per year. The
selection process for rental and ownership equity purchases also
received greater scrutiny with provision for equitable selection
processes such as lotteries and better oversight to ensure appropriate
purchasers/renters. In 2006, the affordable housing ordinance was
further amended to require all owners to sign the deed and occupy the
unit for the entire ownership period. The City is continuing to review
the affordable program and held a workshop in January 2010 to review all
aspects of the program to meet the City Council’s goal for housing. The
City’s goal is: “Advance an array of housing options targeting
affordability, internal growth, University-related needs and housing
needs of special populations”.
limitations on growth, has resulted in less housing development and
fewer affordable units becoming available. The downturn has also made
the resale of affordable housing units with deed restrictions
significantly restricting equity accumulation more of a challenge
because of the availability of lower priced regular housing units with
no limits on the potential resale profit. Another problem faced by the
affordable housing program is the increased difficulty of obtaining
financing for low end borrowers in the current market. The financing
problem is exacerbated by the City’s requirement that it have the “right
of first refusal”, which means that the City has the option to purchase
the affordable unit in the event of sale. This enables the City to
assure that any purchaser fulfills the income level requirements of the
affordable housing program. Despite these difficulties the City reports
significant interest in the affordable housing units in the new Verona
development, as well as increased interest in available DACHA units.
are operating as planned, with income confirmation, open bidding by
developers for projects and lotteries of eligible buyers to ensure
selection fairness. Tenants/owners informed the Grand Jury that they are
satisfied with management of the units and are finding financing at
interest rates low enough to keep the units affordable.
City of Davis as part of its affordable housing program. Pursuant to
the “regulatory agreement” signed by DACHA and the City, members were
required to invest approximately $16,000 to a maximum of $20,000 to own a
share of the cooperative. Annual equity accumulation was restricted to a
maximum of 10% of the $20,000 equity stake, or $2,000. The houses were
owned by the cooperative with the members owning a share in the
cooperative organization. As shareholders, residents owned the
cooperative as an undivided whole, with the exclusive right to occupy a
specific unit within the cooperative. The members were able to claim
ownership tax benefits, and upon termination of their membership the
initial share price plus any appreciation on the share price was
returned. One of the hopes of the developers was that the local
businesses would assist their employees with the purchase of the
cooperative share to enable them to live in the City where they work.
regulatory agreement with the City required the cooperative to charge
members the minimum “carrying charge”. This was essentially a form of
rent designed to recover mortgages, taxes and operating expenses. The
carrying charges were limited to 30% of 110% of the median income in
Yolo County to ensure affordability. This was approximately $1,425 to
$1,568 per month initially, depending on whether the units were two or
three bedrooms. The agreement also made DACHA responsible for all
management functions, with the City retaining “the right to conduct an
annual (or more frequently if deemed reasonably necessary by the City)
review of the management practices and financial status of the
Development.”
regulatory agreement ensured that if units were sold by DACHA, future
purchasers would be subject to the restrictions in the regulatory
agreement. This was done by including a “covenant running with the land”
in both the regulatory agreement and the deeds. This covenant
permanently restricted subsequent purchasers/owners of the properties in
DACHA to the rules embodied in DACHA’s regulatory agreement with the
City, ensuring that the units would remain affordable in perpetuity.
that the City intended that the units can never be sold at fair market
value. The maximum resale value of the property is determined by
arithmetic formula, which is more easily understood by an example. The
calculation is based on the “allowable monthly cost burden” for a family
purchasing a three bedroom house. The example assumes a 30 year (360
month) mortgage at a 5% interest rate. The maximum allowable income for
a family of four at 100% of area median income is $72,500, and the
allowable monthly cost burden is 35% of $ $72,500 divided by 12, or
$2,115 per month. Impounds such as property tax, PMI and hazard
insurance are subtracted, leaving $1,546 per month available to service
the mortgage. The allowable monthly cost burden is now multiplied by the
number of months in the mortgage. In this example, the amount is $1,546
x 360 = $556,410.
formula now works backward to determine the principal, given the loan’s
interest rate. In this example, assuming an interest rate of 5%, the
restricted resale price is $298,881. The results can be obtained using
an amortization table. A simple way to summarize this formula is that
lower interest rates, increases in the allowable cost burden percentage
and increases in the percentage of area median income used to determine
eligibility increase the sale price, and the opposite reduces the
calculated value of the home for sale purposes. Table 1 illustrates
these calculations.
it was intended by the City that the DACHA units would always be
subject to the restrictions in the regulatory agreement via the covenant
running with the land, there was a limited exception arising from the
method of financing. Private banks required that the covenant be
subordinated to their rights in the event of foreclosure. This meant
that the 13 DACHA units financed by the private banks (River City Bank
and First Northern Bank) could be sold at market value to purchasers
without income restrictions during a foreclosure sale. City
representatives have steadfastly maintained throughout the Grand Jury’s
investigation that they know of no other way to remove the restrictive
covenant.
DACHA was created under the auspices of the City’s affordable housing
program, DACHA was a private nonprofit corporation that contracted with a
private consultant to assist in development of its housing. DACHA
contracted with the consultant to construct a total of 67 units, with
the consultant to receive “$8,000 per unit for units that Consultant
obtains from a private developer, where the consultant participates in
the financing and marketing of the units, but does not have an active
role in the architectural and planning portions of the development… and
$12,000 per units that Consultant initiates the development and
participates in all phases of the development…” The consultant also
provided extensive noncontractual consulting services, billed at $120
and $125 per hour.
incorporated in December of 2002. The articles of incorporation made
the developers/consultants the beneficiary of DACHA’s assets, including
the housing units, in the event of DACHA’s dissolution. Although the
articles of incorporation thus made the developers/consultants the owner
of DACHA’s housing units if DACHA failed, the articles also required
the beneficiary to pay off DACHA’s debts. The developers set up DACHA,
acted as consultant and broker, designated themselves as beneficiary and
selected the original board of directors, which was comprised of
prominent members of the community who were to be replaced by tenants as
the number of units increased.
to the City, DACHA was a private entity and the City had no direct
connection to, or responsibility for, DACHA. The City indicated that
although DACHA was established under City rules, partially financed by
the City, and the City reserved the right to review the carrying charges
and audit DACHA, the City’s role was that of any other lien holder. The
City also had the right to appoint a voting member of DACHA’s initial
board, but preferred a nonvoting “ex officio” seat. City staff regularly
attended board meetings until 2005, when the City appointed a formal
board member.
City completed its assessment of DACHA in September of 2002, prior to
incorporation. The City’s projections showed DACHA’s projected carrying
costs exceeded the City’s rules for low income housing. Accordingly it
was recommended that the City finance the first loan in order to reduce
carrying charges by $200 per month. Even at that level the carrying
charges were considered to be at the upper end of compliance with
affordable housing rules. City representatives informed the Grand Jury
that there was concern at the outset that the complexities of running
and financing DACHA could prove difficult for low income buyers who were
making their first real estate purchase. It was the City’s
understanding that DACHA members were to receive training and a packet
of information with a facts and questions handout (FAQ).
City staff report dated September 2002 requested a legal analysis of
the relevant legal documents such as the bylaws, articles of
incorporation and loan documents be performed by the City Attorney’s
office. This report was presented to the City Council.
December 2002 and January 2003 the DRA approved a loan of $100,000 for
expenses related to creation of DACHA and $1,140,000 for the first seven
units. These were to be built on Tufts Place. The $1,140,000 loan was a
30 year loan at 5.5% fixed interest, which was below market rates at
the time. DACHA’s monthly mortgage payment to the City was $6,472.79.
The $100,000 loan was to be repaid in annual installments of $10,000
beginning in 2013.
next 13 units were financed by private banks. In order to keep the
carrying costs at an amount allowed by the affordable housing rules,
very little principal was paid. The payments were essentially “interest
only”. In 2003 and 2004 seven additional homes on Arena Drive, Marden
Drive and Albany Circle were financed by First Northern Bank. These
loans had initial interest rates ranging from 6.25% to 6.67% and
prepayment penalties of 5% in the first year, declining by 1% per year
in subsequent years. In 2005 River City Bank financed the final 6 houses
on Glacier Place with a loan of $1,119,000. The interest rate was
apparently fixed at 6.37% with a balloon payment of the entire amount
due in 2015. Prepayment penalties were 5% during the first two years,
decreasing by 1% every two years. Over the course of 3 years a total of
20 homes were built for DACHA. Table 2 illustrates the sources of
financing to construct the 20 DACHA units.
of the applicants, who were all selected via lottery of eligible low
income buyers, did not have the money required to purchase shares in
DACHA. This was during a period of time in the housing market when most
people could get a home mortgage with little down payment and minimal
credit review. The developers/consultants decided to loan money to DACHA
to complete the share purchase requirements. The total of these loans
was difficult to determine. It appears to have been approximately
$152,000 to $170,000. Some of these loans included a balloon payment and
a prepayment penalty. Interest rates were typically 3% above a
specified institutional rate such as five year treasury bills. The net
result of these loans was increased economic pressure on DACHA, as
repayment was in addition to carrying charges that were already at or
beyond the maximum permitted by the regulatory agreement. The City
indicated it was unaware of these loans, and that any discussion of the
loans would have occurred during closed session of the DACHA board.
May of 2005 DACHA members wrote the City Council (the City Council
members also comprise the Board of the DRA) regarding purported high
costs of DACHA above the carrying charges. These included management
fees of $900 to $1,100 per unit per year, estimated consulting costs of
$690 per unit per year as well as landscaping and utilities of at least
$100 per unit per month. There was also concern about high turnover
resulting in property tax increases as well as the approaching need to
refinance, potentially increasing carrying charges.
this point the carrying charges ranged between approximately $1,520 to
$1,780 per month. Given the real estate boom at the time, DACHA was
becoming less competitive in the market. The City responded by
appointing a board member to represent its interests, asking staff to
perform an analysis of DACHA, and paying $18,000 for an audit.
audit report was delivered in June of 2006. The auditor was unable to
complete the fiscal analysis due to DACHA’s inadequate record keeping.
Financial data such as balance sheets, loan and interest information and
minutes were missing, and there was no adequate explanation for money
present in two DACHA accounts. However, the audit raised important
questions regarding DACHA’s financial viability. The auditor’s main
concerns were: 1) the absence of reserves that were required. The
failure to keep reserves meant that the city would likely be responsible
to fill the gap for such items as capital repairs and emergencies; 2)
the employment of interest only loans was considered a long term risk to
DACHA. They also posed a potential long term risk to city resources as
they were an “indefinite debt”; and, 3) most troubling were long term
projections by the auditor.
most optimistic projection assumed a vacancy rate of only 3.5%, and
showed a probable net loss for DACHA over 30 years of $160,000. Under a
worst case scenario of applicable variables, including a 5.5 % vacancy
rate, the probable loss rose to over $2,500,000. The audit concluded
that DACHA’s woes needed to be fixed before DACHA expanded and that it
should be compared with other affordable housing models.
the audit was pending DACHA cancelled its contract with the consultant
and refused to build any further units. A lawsuit ensued and has
continued in one form or another to the present. It is beyond the scope
of the Grand Jury to prefer one side over the other, or to assess the
various legal positions and theories, and this report makes no attempt
to do so.
its inception until March of 2007 DACHA regularly made its mortgage
payments to the City. From March 2007 to August 2008 the City forbore to
collect the mortgage payments in order to enable DACHA to pay its legal
fees. The total forbearance amount was $116,510.22. (18 months times
$6,472.79)
January of 2008 the City decided to refinance DACHA using money
exclusively from its redevelopment funds. The City considered the
following factors important in making this decision: 1) cash flow
problems encountered by DACHA; 2) affordability problems for DACHA
members; 3) the small size of the units, the legal problems, and
carrying charges in excess of local rents for comparable units made
marketing difficult; 4) loan repayments were coming due and some
lenders were prepared to reduce prepayment penalties if payment was made
in the near term; and, 5) only commercial interest rates were available
if the RDA did not refinance.
important reason for the refinance was the City’s concern that the
DACHA housing units remain in the affordable housing program. The
covenants running with the land were subordinate to the interests of the
private banks in the event of foreclosure. A refinancing by the City
would permit the homes to stay in the affordable housing program if the
City foreclosed. The City also was concerned about the beneficiary
provision in DACHA’s articles of incorporation that made a third party
the owner of the homes if DACHA dissolved. The loan refinance document
made the City the sole beneficiary of the properties in the event of
DACHA’s dissolution. Additionally, if the City foreclosed it would
obtain title to the DACHA properties from DACHA. There would therefore
be no assets in DACHA to go to a beneficiary regardless of who the
beneficiary was.
refinance was completed in June of 2008 and the new regulatory
agreement with DACHA was signed in August of 2008. The new agreement
between DACHA and the City made the City DACHA’s beneficiary if DACHA
dissolved. It also changed the maximum carrying charges to 30% of 80% of
the median Yolo County income, and continued the requirement that all
affordability restrictions be covenants running with the land. This had
the effect of making the units more affordable, but also had the effect
of reducing the value of the property in the event it became necessary
for the City to step in and sell all the properties. At this time the
homes were valued at approximately $235,000 for two bedroom homes and
$293,000 for three bedroom homes.
amount of the loan was $4,153,428.62 at 3% over a term of 55 years.
Mortgage payments were $ 12,877.16 per month. Table 3 shows the use of
the refinance loan funds:
addition to solving the pressing need to refinance the interest only
private bank loans, this refinance was intended to resolve at least
three other fiscal issues. First, the $116,510 that the City forbore was
“wrapped into the term” of the refinance loan. The City planned to
recoup the money by extending the length of time for repayment. Second,
although the original consultant loans were approximately $152,000, the
lien holder refused to waive any prepayment penalties or interest. DACHA
borrowed $247,000 to repay the $152,000 consultant loan. Third, the
$202,000 share stabilization portion of the loan was made so that DACHA
could refund money DACHA shareholders originally paid in excess of
$6,250 per unit. Thus, the share buy in became $6,250 per unit rather
than various amounts up to a maximum of $20,000. Combined with the
reduced carrying charges (30% of 80 % of the median Yolo County income)
it was hoped the units were more affordable and marketable.
September 2008 to September 2009 DACHA paid the City the monthly
mortgage payments. However, in June of 2009 the lawsuit by the
developers/consultants against DACHA went to binding arbitration. The
plaintiff asked for $506,000. This was composed of a demand for $376,000
in contractual damages for failure to build the additional 47 units
($8,000 per unit times 47) and approximately $130,000 for services not
enumerated in its contract with DACHA, but which plaintiff asserted had
been provided. The arbitrator awarded plaintiff $331,872 plus 10%
interest per annum beginning on June 18, 2009 ($282,000 for unbuilt
units and $49,872 for noncontractual services). The arbitration award
also stated “It is not the task of this arbitrator to wade through years
of history between the City of Davis, DACHA and all other interested
parties to determine who is right and who is wrong, as to the viability
of this model or the financial health of DACHA or any of the myriad
other issues involving these parties. The City of Davis maintains a very
commendable goal of affordable housing. Along with this goal, there
comes a host of other problems which are not part of this arbitration.
One thing is clear from the audit report and that is that the criticisms
in the report do not negate the contractual obligations.”
October of 2009 DACHA’s bank accounts were levied to pay the
arbitration award. The $57,000 in DACHA’s bank accounts was seized. To
date, this is all that is known by the Grand Jury to have been paid by
DACHA. However, the Grand Jury was informed that an attempt is being
made to make some low income tenants pay the remaining arbitration
award.
seizure of funds to satisfy the arbitration award caused DACHA to
default on its mortgage payments to the City, which then initiated
foreclosure proceedings in December of 2009. From December 2009 until
the foreclosure in April of 2010 the City required that all carrying
charges be paid into a trust account created by the City pursuant to
Civil Code sections 2398(c) and (g). The City told the Grand Jury that
this was done to prevent attempts to collect the arbitration award from
interfering with the City’s collection of mortgage payments. During this
5 month period not all carrying charges were paid by DACHA
shareholders. The total arrearage was $13,229. The City made no direct
attempt to collect the arrearage, instead taking the position that this
was up to DACHA’s management company. Despite the arrearage, the funds
paid into the trust account were adequate to cover DACHA’s mortgage
obligations.
important effect of the foreclosure proceedings would be to likely
transfer ownership of the 20 affordable housing units from DACHA to the
DRA, as the DRA would have a credit in the amount of its $4,153,429
mortgage at the foreclosure sale. Thus, any competing purchaser would
have to spend in excess of $4,153,429 at the foreclosure sale to obtain
the DACHA units. With the shareholders paying their carrying charges to
the City rather than DACHA, and the impending foreclosure about to
transfer title of the units from DACHA to the City, DACHA would have no
assets left upon which to levy to satisfy the arbitration judgment. The
original beneficiary would also be the beneficiary of no properties in
the event of DACHA’s dissolution.
an effort to maintain its rights as a judgment creditor, the prevailing
party at the arbitration filed a petition asking that DACHA be declared
involuntarily bankrupt in Federal Court in Sacramento. This filing
requested the foreclosure proceedings be stopped (“stayed”) and a
finding that DACHA was not a nonprofit organization, based at least in
part on the “share stabilization” refund of $202,000 to DACHA’s members.
The Federal Bankruptcy Court denied the request to stay the foreclosure
proceedings, denied the petition to force involuntary bankruptcy on
DACHA, and awarded DACHA $45,000 in attorney’s fees. The order entering
judgment in favor of DACHA stated “Also, DACHA’s partial refund of
initial member contributions was not a dividend as it only refunded
contributions. It was not a distribution or return of investments. And,
it was a one time distribution, made with the intention of equalizing
the members’ interests in DACHA. Paying interest on the partial refunds
was not a dividend either because it was consistent with DACHA’s bylaws,
adopted in 2002 upon its formation.”
the bankruptcy proceedings a demand was made by DACHA’s bankruptcy
attorneys upon the City to release approximately $30,000 from the
carrying charges in the City’s DACHA trust account to pay a portion of
DACHA’s legal fees. The City complied. This was the only payment made by
the City for DACHA’s attorney fees.
City completed its foreclosure on DACHA in mid-2010, becoming the owner
of the units. The City paid $20,267.58 for services to complete the
foreclosure. The former shareholders signed leases and are now tenants
paying rent rather than carrying charges. From the time of foreclosure
through February of 2011 all rent has been paid with the exception of
$763.81 by an exiting tenant. The rent collected has exceeded the costs.
However, the tenants no longer pay property taxes or management fees.
As the owner of the properties, the City is now responsible for all
management and maintenance of these units. The City believes that the
staff time, expenses and expertise necessary to continue to manage these
units as affordable housing make it impractical to continue as the
landlord. In anticipation of these difficulties, in January of 2010 the
City began to consider options such as selling or transferring the units
to another agency or nonprofit to be leased as affordable housing, or
selling the housing units as affordable housing units, with requirements
of owner occupancy, a right of first refusal, and restrictions on price
appreciation.
in early 2007 and ongoing to the present, the City has incurred
significant legal fees in conjunction with DACHA. In October of 2010
the Yolo County Superior Court ordered that the City be added as a
defendant to an ongoing lawsuit against DACHA. Although the Court
dismissed the claim for monetary damages against the City, it allowed
the issue of whether the original consultant or the City is the proper
beneficiary of the 20 units in the event of the dissolution of DACHA to
proceed to trial. Complainant also contends the refinance and subsequent
foreclosure that transferred the title out of DACHA is invalid because
the shareholders and board lacked the ability to authorize the transfer.
The ownership of the units is at stake. This matter is set for trial in
October of 2011. Additionally, a government tort claim for monetary
damages was filed against the City. The City rejected this claim and
contends it is time barred. On March 21, 2011 the developers/consultants
filed a lawsuit against the City based on the tort claim. The lawsuit
seeks to take possession of the DACHA properties from the City and its
citizens as well as any rents or proceeds from the properties. The
City’s legal fees to date are well in excess of $200,000 and mounting.
the City Council meeting on February 1, 2011 the City was presented
with a staff proposal, which was in response to previous council
direction, to sell the 20 DACHA units. The staff recommended the units
be sold as affordable housing at 100% of Yolo County median income. The
resulting proposal would sell two bedroom homes for a maximum of
$209,250 and three bedroom homes for a maximum of $244,250. Families
making as much as 120% of the Yolo County median income were to be
allowed to purchase the homes to enlarge the pool of eligible
applicants. The maximum sale price for the 20 units totaled $4,500,000.
After deduction of a broker fee of $270,000, the City hoped to net
$150,000 after repayment to the City of the outstanding loan balance of
$4,081,844. It was unknown whether the City could actually sell the
homes for this amount due to the impact the affordability covenants have
on the value of the homes.
developers/consultants alleged that the City’s maximum sales price was a
change from the sales price in 2008 that decreased the value of the
DACHA units by approximately $1,000,000. It was the City’s position
that this change made the units more affordable. In April 2011 the City
released new valuations for the DACHA units. According to the City the
same “affordable” units at 100% YCMI now have a maximum sale value of
$259,829 for two bedroom units and $298,881 for three bedroom units. If
successfully sold for these prices, the City would receive a minimum of
an additional $1,000,000. Settlement negotiations have begun.
the Grand Jury’s investigation the City has been steadfast in its
belief that the restrictive covenants could not be removed. However,
during the City Council meeting of February 1, 2011, it was claimed by
the developers/consultants that the homes could be sold for market
value, provided all profits were recycled into the affordable housing
program. The City council has asked that this legal question be
researched by the City attorney. Council also asked that a market value
appraisal be performed on the 20 DACHA units. The eight two bedroom
units appraised at $275, 000 through $390,000, and the 12 three bedrooms
units at $320,000 through $420,000. In total, 20 units appraised at
$7,021,000.
The City has a long established program for affordable housing that has
developed over the years by trying different models and using
inclusionary programs to mix affordable housing with conventional
housing. The City has worked hard to improve the affordable housing
program, resulting in a program that has become fairer and more
successful for all participants, including developers, renters and
ownership housing buyers.
The City has a currently well documented affordable housing program.
Documents are posted on a web site and are also readily available at a
counter at City Hall. The City was very cooperative and provided good
information to the Grand Jury concerning the affordable housing program.
Much of this information is available for review by the general public.
The ownership/equity based affordable housing model is challenging to
develop, market and administer. There are many influences on the success
of such projects, including unit availability, financing and resale
restrictions. The difficulty of ensuring unit costs are competitive with
local rents, and the state of the general economy, make it difficult to
compete with units that have no restrictions on equity accumulation and
the number of eligible buyers.
In 1990 the City envisioned the affordable ownership units as a way to
permit low to moderate income families to gain wealth through home
ownership. This resulted in more than 600 of the approximately 700
affordable ownership units permanently passing out of the program. Due
to the City’s growth restrictions and the housing bubble, the net result
is only 90 units are currently affordable.
The DACHA project was approved when other equity type affordable
housing projects were being criticized and a new affordable limited
equity cooperative was conceived. This was to be a way to keep the units
affordable forever and encourage people working in the City to live in
the City and possibly have their employers help with the equity payment.
Greater care should have been taken initially by the City and the DRA
when performing legal analysis of documents such as DACHA’s articles of
incorporation and bylaws. Had the City been made DACHA’s beneficiary at
the outset it is probable that many of the current problems, including
the ongoing lawsuit by the original developers/consultants seeking to
take possession of the DACHA properties and their rents/proceeds from
the City and its citizens, with resulting large attorney fees and staff
costs, could have been avoided.
The City has maintained that DACHA was a private organization and
therefore the City had no greater responsibility to take a more active
role than any other lien holder when DACHA was first formed. Although
this may be technically or legally accurate, beginning in 2005 the
amount of staff time and energy, constant oversight and investment of
large amounts of public funds proves this initial attitude was
unrealistic. If the City was going to assume the degree of
responsibility observed by the Grand Jury, it should have done more from
the outset. In particular, more should have been done to assist the
shareholders to fulfill their obligation to create a total of 67
affordable housing units. The DACHA shareholders were inexperienced
first time home buyers who were required to build and market 67 homes,
manage the properties, assure capital improvement reserves were
sufficient, and refinance sophisticated commercial loans. A handout with
FAQ’s was insufficient for this purpose.
The City’s awareness of financing issues that led it to make the first
loan to DACHA, combined with the City’s concern that initial carrying
charges were at the maximum level allowed under its affordable housing
rules mandated that the City monitor DACHA’s progress carefully. There
were not enough eligible buyers with required down payments for shares
of DACHA. As a consequence personal loans with balloon payments and
prepayment penalties were made to DACHA in order to attract prospective
share purchasers. There was insufficient discussion between the City and
the developers/consultants regarding this problem. The City should have
exercised its right to appoint a DACHA board member long before it did
so in June 2005, when concerns by residents came to light. The failure
to take proper cognizance of the developing problems and the failure to
appoint a board member earlier was failure of oversight by the City.
There were many factors in DACHA’s failure, including the failure of
oversight by the City, the collapse of the housing bubble, the recent
recession, and the filing of a lawsuit against DACHA. No one factor is
found to be the likely primary cause or a substantial factor in DACHA’s
failure.
City acted responsibly by making many attempts to preserve DACHA as
part of its affordable housing program. These attempts include changing
the maximum carrying charges, reducing the cost of the homes, reducing
the initial share price to $6,250 and refinancing the outstanding loans.
The City’s actions were made in good faith and with transparency. The
Grand Jury found no evidence of a cover up.
The loan of $202,000 to DACHA for share stabilization was not an
inappropriate gift of public money. A loan that must be repaid is not a
gift. DACHA’s insolvency due to a lawsuit means the loan will not be
repaid. However, the filing of a suit and its aftermath does not
transform the loan into a gift. Most importantly, even assuming the loan
had not been made, the City and the DRA would have faced a significant
moral dilemma at the time of foreclosure regarding whether to permit
DACHA shareholders to receive a refund of some or all of their share
investments, that is for the citizens and their elected representatives
to decide.
No improper gift of public money was made to pay DACHA’s legal fees. The
only money transferred from the City to DACHA to pay attorney fees was
$30,000 from a trust account created to protect the City’s right to
collect its mortgage. The money in the account was from the carrying
charges received directly from DACHA and therefore was not public money.
The City also forbore to collect $116,510 in mortgage payments to
permit DACHA to pay its attorneys. However, this money was “wrapped”
into the refinance loan by extending its term and therefore was a loan
rather than a gift.
During the period of time DACHA’s carrying charges were paid into the
City’s trust account, approximately $13,000 in arrearages occurred. This
did not result in any loss to the City or any gift of public money, as
simple arithmetic shows that even after deduction of the $30,000 in
attorney fees to defend against the involuntary bankruptcy, the funds in
the trust account were more than adequate to make the mortgage payments
of $12,877 per month.
Although there may have been serious delinquencies in payments of
carrying charges by shareholders to DACHA, there was no failure by DACHA
to make mortgage payments to the City. The City was not damaged by any
such delinquencies and no public money was lost as a consequence of any
such delinquencies.
Subsequent to the foreclosure, the City has successfully managed the
former DACHA properties and collected almost every penny of rent due.
There has therefore been no further loss to the city or gift of public
money subsequent to the foreclosure.
The City’s assumption in February 2011 that it will show a “profit” of
$150,000 upon sale of the DACHA units for $4,500,000 does not take into
account significant costs and is therefore erroneous. Such costs as the
audit ($18,000), foreclosure costs ($20,000), the forbearance money
which will never be recaptured ($116,510) and the legal fees (over
$200,000) should be considered in any profit/loss calculation. The new
sale valuations of April 2011 may cover these expenses, assuming the
units can actually be sold at these prices. However, the new valuations
are less consistent with the affordable housing concept.
Changes in the calculated value of a unit as a result of either
including it in the affordable housing program or changes in the
affordable housing rules or covenants do not cause an improper gift of
public money to occur. Placing deed restrictions with affordability
covenants on the properties is what makes them affordable. To call that a
gift of public money is to call all affordable housing such a gift. To
the extent the maximum selling price is approximately $50,000 per unit
less than in 2008, it is speculative to say that the units could now be
sold at 2008 price points. Perhaps more fundamentally, to sell the units
at the higher price level even if possible does not support the
affordable housing concept. Unsustainable share costs with expensive
financing were major factors in the DACHA debacle from the outset and
are to be avoided if at all possible.
No inappropriate gift or use of public money was made at any time for
any purpose by the City in connection with DACHA. However, the City has
incurred losses that may not be recovered and may increase in the
future. Better initial oversight of DACHA could have prevented this.
The City and RDA need to be sure their oversight and expenditure of
taxpayer dollar responsibilities are taken into account when affordable
housing projects meet challenging implementation and sustainability
problems.
City and RDA should do a more thorough job of analyzing the risks and
benefits of any novel project before deciding to invest significant
taxpayer funds in it. This should include public policy, legal and
financial reviews of any documents that form the basis of such a
project.
City and RDA should do a more careful job of deciding at the outset of
any privately developed project involving the investment of significant
public funds what the degree of public involvement will be, and ensure
the plan has a clear means of implementation.
report was issued by the Grand Jury with exception of two jurors. These
jurors were excluded from all parts of the investigation, including
interviews, deliberations, and the writing, review and acceptance of the
report.
FAIR
USE NOTICE. Tenants Together is not the author of this article and the posting
of this document does not imply any endorsement of the content by Tenants
Together. This document may contain copyrighted material the use of which
may not have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants
Together is making this article available on our website in an effort to
advance the understanding of tenant rights issues in California. We believe
that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided
for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this
copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you
must obtain permission from the copyright owner.