In just six months, Stephanie Williamson was evicted from one home that
she was renting, and she is about to be evicted from a second.
Both of the Reno homes Williamson rented were foreclosed on.
“As a single mom with two boys, I don’t exactly have all this extra income to be shelling out deposits,” Williamson said.
The
number of renters being evicted from homes because of foreclosures has
ballooned in the past couple of years, said Kent Qian of the National
Housing Law Project, a nonprofit that provides legal assistance and
advocacy advice for renters and homeowners. And many tenants don’t
fully understand their rights, which have recently expanded because of
both state and federal legislation.
Williamson’s first
rental was a lease-to-own, and the 39-year-old thought she’d found the
perfect spot for her family. She and her two sons were settled on the
quiet cul-de-sac and friendly with neighbors. A garden was starting to
flourish.
But when she finally learned her landlord had been skipping mortgage payments for nearly a year, Williamson’s life was uprooted.
Despite
investing in multiple home repairs, Williamson was forced to pack
everything up and move across town in March. Her children changed
schools, leaving their friends behind.
She found a new home through a property management company and thought she would be safe. But she wasn’t.
Just three weeks after she moved in, before everyone finished unpacking, she found a notice of default taped to her door.
“The
biggest problem renters are facing now is that they can be paying their
rent on time each month, but still have no guarantee their home is
being safeguarded at all,” said Rhea Gertken, directing attorney for
Nevada Legal Services in Reno.
Though she hasn’t been
formally evicted yet, Williamson said she’s “playing the waiting game”
in a house that hardly looks like a home, because, “I don’t want to
bother putting up pictures if I’ll just be taking them down in a few
weeks.”
“I’m just waiting for someone to come knock on the door and tell me to move out,” she said.
Williamson is far from alone in suddenly being evicted because of a foreclosure.
In
a housing market saturated with foreclosures — Washoe County saw 6,790
homes foreclosed on in the first half of this year alone — Northern
Nevada director of Consumer Credit Affiliates Jill Perry said
understanding tenant rights is crucial for renters in an unstable
market.
A growing issue
Nationally, about 40 percent of foreclosed properties are rentals, Qian said.
And
in Washoe County and Nevada, an increasing number of people are renting
their homes to make their mortgage payments, Perry said. But being a
landlord takes preparation, and doesn’t come without a cost.
“You have to be realistic,” Perry said. “It takes a lot of money to be a landlord.”
So
how do renters protect themselves? By knowing their rights and
asserting them, both before entering into a rental agreement and upon
receipt of a foreclosure notice or notice of default on the home,
Gertken said.
When a tenant’s home is foreclosed, the
process from the first delinquent payment through the final transfer of
title is long — up to seven months, because most lenders let a
homeowner go three months delinquent before sending out a notice of
default, and another four until the time of sale.
But in some cases, the tenant isn’t aware until a foreclosure notice is posted on the door of the property.
Government support
Nevada Assembly Bill 140, made effective last October, outlines new obligations in the landlord-tenant relationship.
It
places liability on the landlords, who are obligated to disclose to a
tenant if their property goes into foreclosure. Additionally, banks now
are obligated to notify tenants of a property default. If a default is
recorded, a foreclosure trustee must notify any potential tenant that
the property might be subject to foreclosure, Gertken said.
But,
Gertken said, “I don’t know how effective this will be,” as it is a
difficult law to enforce. Despite their obligation, Gertken thinks many
landlords still won’t divulge necessary financial information to their
tenants.
Geoffrey Giles, a Reno attorney who handles foreclosure mediation,
said many landlords he has worked with worry their tenants will no
longer pay rent if they know the landlord is in financial trouble.
In
2009, a report by the National Law Center on Homelessness and Poverty
and the National Low Income Housing Coalition entitled “Without Just
Cause” detailed the general lack of tenant rights across the U.S.
The
report summarized that: “As the foreclosure crisis continues and
intensifies, more and more renters are being evicted — often without
notice. Moreover ... in the vast majority of states, there is little in
the law to protect tenants’ legitimate interests.”
It also
recommended the federal government take immediate action to protect
tenants in foreclosures, including provision of fair notice to tenants,
preservation of existing tenancies and legal assistance. Largely
because of this report, Qian said, Congress passed a law that took
effect in May 2009, the Protecting Tenants At Foreclosure Act.
Under
the new law, which is in effect until 2014, tenants get a minimum of 90
days notice before they are forced to move out of a home because of
foreclosure. Formerly, Nevadans got only three days notice, Gertken
said.
This period begins once the transfer of title on the home is complete. The law stands even if there is no lease agreement.
If
a lease is in effect, the law also requires the bank, foreclosure
trustee or other new owner continue honoring a tenant’s existing lease
terms, unless a new owner wishes to immediately take permanent
residence in the home.
Asserting their rights
Ultimately, Qian said, if tenants don’t understand and assert their rights, often they forfeit them.
The
Staying Home Report, which was released by the NLCHP last month,
pointed out several compliance problems with the federal law.
Oftentimes, Qian said, tenants can be misinformed by agents who don’t even know the laws themselves.
Giles said the biggest issue is ambiguous language in notices placed on the home.
“A lot of times tenants get notices that are very cleverly contrived,” he said.
Qian said the most common ambiguity is that separate terms can for a
number of parties, from homeowners to renters. These parties are issued
varying amounts of time to vacate. Tenants don’t know which applies to
them, and they assume their deadline is the first one.
“Most
of the renters I’ve worked with get real panicky when a notice is
posted on their door,” Giles said. “They move out way before they have
to, and that’s too bad.”
Another problem, Qian said, is
that banks should be doing due diligence to find out whether someone is
renting a property. But they often leave the task to real estate
agents, whose incentive is to sell the property quickly.
“They
have a conflict of interest in terms of vacating the property to sell,”
Qian said. “So oftentimes, issues with the PTFA have to do with how the
laws are implemented on the ground, as this may be different from
banks’ actual policies.”
Qian said this is why some banks
will hire property managers, rather than real estate agents, as the
first point of contact with a renter.
Some banks use a
“Cash for Keys” program, in which they offer varying sums of money to
entice tenants to leave a home quickly so it can be sold.
Reno
resident Cassie Miller chose to use this program last year, and said it
resulted in the most stressful week of her life. Though she was given
$4,900 to move out, she had only a week to do it, and that week fell
during college midterms.
“I don’t know if I would do the same thing again,” the 22-year-old said.
But Miller added that had she not researched her rights, the deal would never have happened.
“No one came forward and told me my options,” she said. “I was lucky to know about them, but many people don’t.”
Despite the many challenges, Perry said the situation has already begun improving.
“About
a year ago, the problem was huge,” she said. “Tenants were really
caught off-guard by what was going on, but that has started to slow
down.”
People are learning how to work through the issue, she said.
Still, she urges homeowners: “Do the right thing. Give your tenants the option to move out if you’re delinquent.”
Gertken,
the attorney for Nevada Legal Services, advises tenants to do their
research so they know exactly what they’re getting into.
“I know more now than I’ll probably ever need to...” Williamson said. “But you never know.”
FAIR USE NOTICE. This
document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been
specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this
article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of
tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair
use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the
U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes
of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the
copyright owner.