Herrera settles CitiApartments litigation with tough injunctions, up to $10 million penalty

Wednesday, March 30, 2011
Office of the City Attorney
San Francisco Office of the City Attorney

City Attorney Dennis Herrera today
announced the settlement of a contentious four-and-a-half-year legal
battle with CitiApartments and its complex web of corporate and
individual affiliates with an unprecedented injunction to protect San
Francisco tenants, and penalties that could reach as high as $10 million
over the next five years, depending on the defendants' financial
condition. San Francisco Superior Court Judge John E. Munter approved
the injunction late yesterday, which is part of the 88-page settlement
agreement.

Herrera sued the once high-flying rental property behemoth in
Aug. 2006 for a stunning array of unlawful business and tenant
harassment practices, which often harrowingly dispossessed long-term
residents of their rent-controlled apartments. The coerced vacancies
freed the landlord to make significant -- and almost uniformly
unpermitted -- renovations to units, and then re-rent them to new
tenants at dramatically increased market rates. The illegal business
model appears to have enabled CitiApartments, Skyline Realty and other
entities under the sway of real estate family patriarch Frank Lembi to
aggressively outbid competitors for residential properties throughout
San Francisco for several years -- before lawsuits and a sharp economic
downturn forced the aspiring empire into bankruptcies, foreclosures and
receiverships.

"After a years-long legal battle over shocking anti-tenant and
anti-competitive practices, we've secured the toughest, most detailed
injunction to protect tenants in San Francisco history," said Herrera.
"This injunction allows us to aggressively police CitiApartments and its
affiliates, now and in the future. It financially punishes the
offenders to the extent their assets allow, while assuring additional
penalties against their future income. It sends a strong message to
would-be mimics of the dire consequences for similar lawlessness, and
our resolve to pursue and punish it. But the success of this case
doesn't belong to the City Attorney's Office alone. It belongs, too, to
the San Francisco Department of Building Inspection and the Building
Inspection Commission. Perhaps most important, it belongs to all the
tenants, activists and journalists who helped provide us with the
ammunition necessary to take on the Lembi real estate empire from the
start. I'm especially grateful to all the community advocates from
'CitiStop' for their tireless efforts."

Case background
Herrera's litigation included extensive evidence gathered
through the City Attorney's Office's own investigation as well as from
the nearly 300 tenants and witnesses who contacted Herrera's office in
the weeks after he filed suit. The City's case was additionally aided by
tenants and witnesses identified in an award-winning investigative
series that the San Francisco Bay Guardian published in March 2006, and
by the aggressive community outreach efforts of a coalition called
"CitiStop." That coalition was supported by the San Francisco Tenants
Union, the Housing Rights Committee of San Francisco, the San Francisco
Labor Council, the Harvey Milk LGBT Democratic Club, the Alice B. Toklas
LGBT Democratic Club, the San Francisco Peoples Organization, SEIU
Local 790 and St. Peter's Housing Committee, which is now known as Causa
Justa.

With the City Attorney's financial investigation ongoing
throughout the course of the litigation, and the years-long discovery
battle unfolding, Herrera was forced to amend the City's complaint three
times to fully capture within the scope of the case the Lembi family's
byzantine array of business entities, trusts and partnerships. In fact,
in his Third Amended Complaint, Herrera successfully petitioned to
include Frank Lembi, Walter Lembi (now deceased) and Lembi nephew David
Raynal as individual defendants.

The long-held belief among some real estate observers that the
Lembis' unlawful business model was unsustainable was ultimately
confirmed by problems that included mounting lawsuits and 2008's severe
economic decline, which appears to have been particularly cataclysmic.
After nearly four years of legal delay tactics, which included the Lembi
defendants' midcourse change in legal counsel, the City's tenacious
discovery battle over financial and other records finally culminated
last year in some $50,000 in court ordered sanctions against
CitiApartments affiliates for non-compliance. Judge Munter's
uncharacteristically harsh order at the time affirmed that the City
Attorney's Office had "engaged in substantial, indeed Herculean, efforts
to resolve the instant discovery disputes," adding: "In this Court's
opinion, plaintiffs' discovery requests have been repeatedly met with
obfuscation, delay and meritless objections made by the Corporate Entity
Defendants in an effort to avoid providing appropriate discovery." The
sanctions strongly signaled the limits of judicial patience, and proved
to be a key turning point in the case.

The settlement's financial terms
The total dollar value of assessed penalties is largely
contingent on the defendants' financial condition moving forward. The
agreement's maximum dollar value could reach $10 million over the next
five years (not counting additional penalties and damages that would
accrue for injunctive violations). It could alternatively be as low as
$2 million over the next ten years (plus interest on the outstanding
balance of $1.6 million, and also not counting penalties and damages).
Not by accident, the settlement includes a financial incentive that
could reduce total penalties to the defendants to approximately one
million dollars, with interest. That unprecedented stipulated provision
would require all entities controlled by the defendants, now and in the
future, to forever cease property management operations within the City
and County of San Francisco -- permanently and irrevocably.

The defendants made an initial payment for civil penalties in the
amount of $400,000 on March 29, 2011. The corporate entity defendants
must additionally pay civil penalties of $1,600,000, for which payment
could be in full, or in installments of no less than $13,500 per month
(together with interest on the balance outstanding of the $1,600,000
due). The permanent and irrevocable "leave-and-never-come-back" option
would require installment payments totaling no less than $324,000, plus
interest, after two years.

Net proceeds from any sale or refinancing among the defendants or
their interests within five years will entitle the City to 20 percent
of those proceeds up to a total of $8,000,000. Any failure to report a
sale or refinancing would entitle the City to liquidated damages of
$25,000, in addition to a 20 percent of the net proceeds. Any material
misrepresentation or omission regarding defendants' interests will be a
violation and entitle the City to additional liquidated damages in the
amount equal to 50 percent of each asset defendants failed to disclose.
Any violation of the injunctive terms will subject the defendants to
civil penalties between $2,500 and $6,000 for each violation, and
attorneys' fees and costs to enforce.

The settlement's injunctive terms
Given the City's unfortunate history with the defendants'
business practices, and their penchant for obfuscatory corporate
structure, the City Attorney's Office meticulously negotiated tough,
thorough, and enforceable injunctive terms. Those provisions are fully
comprised in settlement documents on the City Attorney's Web site,
including a five-year injunction, which must -- by court order -- be
posted in a prominent and public place on each floor of each property
owned, managed, operated or maintained by the defendants or their future
entities. Failure to abide by the injunctive terms would invoke
additional penalties and fees. These are the summarized highlights:

  • Notification Requirements. All defendants'
    current and future entities must notify the San Francisco City
    Attorney's Office of any sale, acquisition or transfer within thirty
    days. The City Attorney must also be informed of newly created business
    entities under the defendants' majority control.
  • Tenant protections. Numerous
    anti-harassment provisions-including and in some respects exceeding Prop
    M provisions that a California appellate court invalidated as a matter
    of law-are imposed in the injunction by stipulation. Thus, defendants'
    current and future entities are prohibited from entering units without
    notice; preventing or interfering with the entry of guests or
    caregivers; requesting information about tenants' immigration status;
    retaliating through legal or administrative processes; or threatening to
    evict or evicting a tenant without lawful justification. The defendants
    must respond to all tenants' requests for repairs within 72 hours, and
    establish protocols for changing locks and providing keys, including
    adequate notice; and provide all buildings with a residential caretaker.
  • Buyout and relocation protocols. The
    injunction establishes enforceable protocols to protect tenants in
    proposing buyouts and relocations, including requiring written
    communications and the right of tenants to be on a "No Contact" list.
    The defendants may not use buy-out monies to apply to damage, past due
    rent, or other charges, and households will retain rights to rescind
    agreements up to and including the date of the tenants' receipt of the
    buy-out amount.
  • Remodeling and construction protections, code violations.
    The injunction establishes enforceable protocols to protect tenants
    from harassment or disruption for remodeling or construction, including
    providing tenants advance notice. It restricts non-emergency
    construction or remodeling work to the hours of 7:00 a.m. to 8:00 p.m.,
    and requires that all permits be obtained, all appropriate codes adhered
    to, and a strict regimen set to address all code violations, now and in
    the future.

The case is City and County of San Francisco and People of the State of California v. Skyline Realty, Inc. et al., San Francisco Superior Court Case No. CGC 06-455-241, filed Aug. 16, 2006.

FAIR
USE NOTICE. Tenants Together is not the author of this article and the posting
of this document does not imply any endorsement of the content by Tenants
Together.  This document may contain copyrighted material the use of which
may not have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants
Together is making this article available on our website in an effort to
advance the understanding of tenant rights issues in California. We believe
that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided
for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this
copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you
must obtain permission from the copyright owner.

Help build power for renters' rights: