Herrera wins Court sanctions against CitiApartments for ‘obfuscation, delay’

Tuesday, February 2, 2010
Office of the City Attorney of San Francisco

SAN FRANCISCO (Feb. 2, 2010) — City Attorney Dennis Herrera has won
Court-ordered sanctions against a labyrinthine web of defendants
involved in the operation of CitiApartments and Skyline Realty, the
residential property management and investment behemoth Herrera first
sued in 2006 for its stunning array of unlawful business practices. The
order, which was signed by San Francisco Superior Court Judge John E.
Munter last month and obtained this morning, compels each of the
two-dozen corporate, trust and individual defendants currently named in
the suit to respond to discovery requests in compliance with rules of
civil procedure, and to pay sanctions to the City totaling $50,129.50,
which reflects San Francisco’s fees and costs to pursue its motion to
compel. Munter’s order requires all of the defendants to comply with
the order by Feb. 19, 2010.

"CitiApartments deserved to be sanctioned for its continued defiance
in this case, and I’m gratified to Judge Munter for calling these
tactics exactly what they are — ‘obfuscation, delay and meritless
objections,’" said Herrera. "I hope this sanction sends a message to
Frank Lembi, Walter Lembi and all of the defendants responsible for
CitiApartments’ lawless conduct that there is a limit to judicial
patience, and they’ve reached it. This has been a long, difficult case
to address what is perhaps the most egregious corruption of San
Francisco’s residential housing market in modern history. We remain
committed to pursuing this case aggressively, and I hope these
sanctions are a tipping point that hastens our progress toward a just
outcome."

Herrera originally filed suit against CitiApartments, Skyline Realty
and nine named subsidiary companies in August 2006, detailing an
outrageous pattern of corporate lawlessness in which rental units would
be illegally recovered from tenants; renovated in clear violation of
building and safety codes; and then unlawfully relet at dramatically
increased rental rates — occasionally as short-term corporate housing,
representing still another violation of local law. According to the
complaint Herrera filed following his office’s investigation,
CitiApartments’ employed harrowing tactics to intimidate tenants into
surrendering their rent controlled tenancies, including unannounced
visits by armed paramilitary-like agents; unauthorized entry into
rental units; utility shutoffs; changed locks; and retaliation against
tenants who refused to accept buy-out offers. Once in control of
vacated units, CitiApartments often undertook extensive remodeling work
without the requisite permits and inspections necessary to assure
compliance with state and local safety and building codes.

At a hearing last December, Judge Munter announced his intention to
issue the sanction, saying: "Starting in February of 2008 counsel for
plaintiffs have engaged in substantial, indeed Herculean, efforts to
resolve the instant discovery disputes with the Corporate Entity
Defendants through repeated correspondence and numerous meetings with
defense counsel. Those good faith efforts by plaintiffs’ counsel to
informally resolve the disputes have proved unsuccessful. In this
Court’s opinion, plaintiffs’ discovery requests have been repeatedly
met with obfuscation, delay and meritless objections made by the
Corporate Entity Defendants in an effort to avoid providing appropriate
discovery….In each instance where the Court grants this motion, the
Court finds and concludes that there was an unreasonable failure by
defendants to fully and fairly respond to plaintiffs’ discovery
requests. More specifically, in each instance where the Court grants
this motion, the Court finds and concludes that defendants have engaged
in misuse of the discovery process by failing to respond properly or at
all to proper discovery requests, and/or making unmeritorious
objections to proper discovery requests, and/or making evasive
responses to proper discovery requests, and/or failing to verify
responses."

Throughout more than three years of complex litigation, the
defendants’ litigation strategy has been marked by continued defiance
and elaborate financial shell games that forced Herrera to twice move
successfully to amend his civil complaint to include additional related
corporate, trust and individual alter-egos. Fully 37 defendants are now
specifically named in the suit, including founder Frank Lembi and his
son, Walter Lembi, whom Herrera sued as individuals. At its zenith —
prior to the real estate market meltdown beginning in 2008 —
CitiApartments boasted some more than 200 buildings and 6,000 units in
its portfolio, making it among San Francisco’s largest residential
property owners.

Defendants currently named in Herrera’s lawsuit are: Skyline Realty
Inc., Citiapartments Inc., Citi Funding Group Inc., Citisuites LLC,
Lembi Group Inc., Lembi Group Partners LLC, Urban Property Management,
Inc., Citiwide Rentals, Inc., Frank Lembi, Walter Lembi, David Raynal,
Taylor Lembi, Frank Lembi As Trustee Of The Frank E. Lembi Survivor’s
Trust Dated February 17, 1984, As Restated On June 2, 1999, Frank
Lembi, As Trustee Of The Olga Lembi Residual Trust Created Under The
Provisions Of Part Three Of The Lembi Family Trust Dated February 17,
1984, Walter Lembi, As Trustee Of The Walter And Linda Lembi Family
Trust Dated June 30, 2004, David Raynal, As Trustee Of The David M.
Raynal Revocable Trust Dated May 9, 2002, 737 Pine DE LLC, 737 Pine B10
DE LLC, 737 Pine B10 Mezz DE LLC, 1155 LLC, Gaylord Hotel LLC, LSL
Properties B14 DE LLC, LSL Property Holdings II DE LLC, LSL Property
Holdings II Mezz LLC, Nob Hill Tower DE LLC, Nob Hill Tower Mezz DE
LLC, Prime Apartment Properties LLC, Prime Apartment Properties B10 DE
LLC, Prime Apartment Properties B10 Mezz DE LLC, Trophy Properties B10
DE LLC, Trophy Properties IV DE LLC, Trophy Properties IV B8A LLC,
Trophy Properties IV Mezz DE LLC, Trophy Properties V LLC, Trophy
Properties V DE LLC, Trophy Properties VI LLC, Trophy Properties IV B8A
Manager LLC.

The case is City and County of San Francisco and People of the State of California v. Skyline Realty, Inc. et al.,
San Francisco Superior Court Case No. 06-455241. Documentation on the
case, including the Court-ordered sanction, is available on the City
Attorney’s Web site at the following URL: http://www.sfcityattorney.org/

Help build power for renters' rights: