Housing Crisis Runs On: San Mateo Complex Sold, New Owners Evict Every Tenant

Monday, July 27, 2015
Bill Silverfarb
San Mateo Daily Journal

All the families living in a four-unit apartment complex in San Mateo have had their leases terminated so new owners can remodel the aging building.

Tenants at 1824 El Parque Court have until Aug. 24 to move or face legal action, according to a letter sent by Raymond Ong with RWC Property Services.

Longtime owner Eduardo Suarez recently sold the building to Poyuen and Shulin Cheng, who plan to start renovating the building in September.

Ong wouldn’t comment on whether the Chengs would offer the families any assistance or more time to move, for which they are pleading.

Several of the tenants showed up to a San Mateo City Council meeting July 20 to share their stories and ask for help, including Reyna Gonzalez, an organizer with the San Francisco Organizing Project/Peninsula Interfaith Action, a nonprofit that fights for tenant and immigrant rights.

Gonzalez has advocated on behalf of families who have been evicted from their homes without reason but never expected to get an eviction notice herself.

She works in Redwood Shores, attends St. Matthew Catholic Church in San Mateo and has lived at El Parque for 12 years.

“I have been fighting displacement very hard and now I am the one being displaced. It angers me and my family. My grandchildren will have to leave the area,” she said at the council meeting. “I beg you that we work together.”

She said with the area’s skyrocketing rents — they’ve gone up 50 percent in four years — she has been unable to find somewhere else to live.

Another tenant, Jose Navarrete, said his family already spends two-thirds of its income on rent.

“It is unfair to me that families have to pay 100 percent of their incomes for rent. The housing crisis is dashing our American Dream,” he said at the council meeting.

Tenant Lilian Garcia is a stay-at-home mom with three children whose husband earns about $2,800 a month at a local restaurant.

“A two-bedroom is renting for $3,000. We don’t make enough to cover the rent. My husband and I are desperate right now. My son is sad. He asks where will we go and why do we have to leave,” Garcia said.

She also has a daughter who is gradually going deaf and just had a cochlear implant at Lucile Packard Children's Hospital Stanford Thursday.

Garcia spent years trying to convince her insurance company that the procedure was a necessity.

She worries now that her daughter may not get the follow-up care needed if she is forced to leave the area.

Her biggest worry is her daughter but the eviction notice has made her life more chaotic.

“It’s too much,” she said.

She has signed up for housing assistance but said it’s a nearly three-year wait and that there are currently no affordable apartments to rent in the area.

“They say your income should be three times the rent but we don’t have that,” she said. “The rents shot up but our wages didn’t. It’s a bad feeling not to be able to live here.”

She and the rest of the tenants at El Parque want just one thing, to be able to stay in their apartments.

“It doesn’t make sense to have housing for only people who make a certain income. We are on minimum wage, it doesn’t seem fair,” she said.

The family’s current rent is $1,727.50 and they’ve always paid it on time, she said.

Daniel Saver, an attorney with Community Legal Services in East Palo Alto, spoke on behalf of the evicted tenants to the City Council last week.

He told the council that a pattern has evolved in which buildings are sold and new owners evict for renovations and then boost the rents. He mentioned the 73-unit Park Royal apartment complex in San Mateo that is being renovated now. Every tenant had their leases terminated and only a handful signed new leases after the rents went up, in some cases, nearly $1,000 a month.

“Too often I have to say they are allowed to do this,” Saver said about landlords. “It’s unjust but not illegal.”

Saver represents many families who have been evicted and tries to get owners to help their tenants move by giving them more time or offering relocation assistance.

“It’s not just a few bad apples engaging in this sort of conduct,” Saver said about landlords who have raised rents drastically. “You have an entire barrel full of bad apples. I’m not saying every landlord is a bad landlord and we don’t want to put landlords out of business but speculating on the lives of families represents repugnant business values.”

He called on the City Council to act with a sense of urgency related to the housing crisis.

Councilman David Lim was struck by the group at last Monday night’s council meeting.

He has even offered to speak to a landlord directly in the past when he felt a family was being unjustly evicted.

“I think we need to do something. This is just ridiculous. We’re losing all our diversity. We’re losing people who are vital members of our community, people who just want to live here and send their kids to school. We’re hemorrhaging, we’re hemorrhaging diversity. We’re losing quality residents and something has to be done,” Lim told the Daily Journal.

Maricela Gutierrez has lived at the El Parque complex for 12 years. She has raised four children there, two who are now adults struggling to survive in the same economy.

Her oldest daughters, however, have been able to establish credit, something she and her husband have not been able to do.

She works at a hotel at Coyote Point and the husband works at a restaurant in Palo Alto.

She is worried her two youngest children will have to leave the schools they go to and programs in which they participate.

She has had no luck finding a new place and wants to stay put.

Gutierrez hopes the area’s elected officials start speaking out on behalf of residents who are increasingly being displaced as housing costs continue to climb.

Gutierrez spoke through interpreter Aracely Mondragon, who works for SFOP/PIA.

Mondragon has been front and center in the nonprofit’s recent push to protect low-income and immigrant tenants from being evicted for no cause.

She is hoping the crisis puts pressure on the area’s elected leaders to adopt more protections for renters.

The stories of woe she hears on a daily basis don’t depress her, however.

“They make me mad,” she said.

She uses that anger to advocate on behalf of the working poor who are increasingly being priced out of the area as keep rents going up.

“This is about justice,” she said.

A prayer vigil and rally to support the families is planned for 5:30 p.m., Thursday, July 30, 1824 El Parque Court, San Mateo.

FAIR USE NOTICE. Tenants Together is not the author of this article and the posting of this document does not imply any endorsement of the content by Tenants Together. This document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.

Help build power for renters' rights: