Housing subsidy tied to building that's bad for her

Tuesday, May 17, 2011
Victoria Colliver
San Francisco Chronicle

Marie De Pirro wants nothing more than to move out of her subsidized
one-bedroom apartment in a 30-year-old concrete complex near Fisherman's
Wharf because the constant buildup of mold aggravates her respiratory
and other health problems.

Her apartment smells musty, black mold dots the walls near the
windows and a white mildewy film is visible on a jacket hanging in the
living room. But De Pirro, who is on disability and has lived in the
building for 20 years, is virtually trapped.

Since the type of housing subsidy she receives is tied to her
building, she would lose it if she moved. She has tried unsuccessfully
to obtain a different kind of voucher, but because she's not homeless,
she's not a priority.

"I cannot stay here for the rest of my life," said De Pirro, 60, who
has multiple autoimmune disorders, including one that causes numbness in
her extremities and another that has destroyed her salivary glands.

Low-income housing is often plagued with mold and other health
hazards, but those problems can be particularly troublesome to residents
with health problems.

"At some point, the only remedy may be for someone to move," said
Sara Shortt, executive director of the Housing Rights Committee of San
Francisco. "But where are they going to move to? There simply aren't
many options."

A mold problem

Mold and spores are ubiquitous in nature, but when present in high
concentrations can cause or aggravate allergies, respiratory and other
health problems. Ridding an apartment of them requires cleaning out
existing mold and spores and taking steps to prevent them from
returning, such as finding the source of water the fungus needs to
survive.

Landlords are legally obligated to ensure their buildings are
habitable and free from mold, lead paint, garbage, poisonous shrubs,
rodents and other health hazards. In De Pirro's case, the landlord has
cleaned the mold, but she said it keeps returning.

Most people can move if they are displeased with the condition of their building, unless they are restricted by circumstances.

Nearly 9,000 San Franciscans - like De Pirro - live in privately
owned buildings subsidized by the federal Department of Housing and
Urban Development. That means the subsidy is tied to the building.

"If (the subsidy) is strictly attached to the unit, if you move, you
lose it," said Jai Min Cheng, a Bay Area Legal Aid attorney with the
San Francisco Medical-Legal Partnership, a program at San Francisco
General Hospital that helps patients with legal problems.

Cheng said most of her cases having to do with unhealthy housing
conditions involve mold, but, she added, tenants are often scared of
reporting the problem for fear of being evicted.

Many want vouchers

Evicted tenants would be easy to replace. Nearly 30,000 people in San
Francisco are waiting for public housing openings, and 14,000 more want
vouchers that allow them to move if needed.

Cheng suggested that tenants who are unable to move attempt to work
with their landlords to get health hazards taken care of. If the problem
persists, the next step would be to file a complaint with the city's
Department of Building Inspection.

An inspector from that department visited De Pirro's unit in 2009
and, according to the report, smelled a "strong mold odor." But the
building's maintenance crew cleaned the mold days earlier so none was
visible, and the inspector closed the case.

A property manager from De Pirro's complex, Wharf Plaza, said the
management takes mold very seriously and cleans it. The manager, Kareen
Stoll, said because of De Pirro's health issues, she would not allow the
company to use anything other than baking soda and vinegar on any mold
found in her unit. Stoll said management also offered to allow De Pirro
to move to a different unit or building.

But De Pirro said she needs a building with better ventilation and none of their buildings, she said, offers that.

She hasn't given up on her dream to move, but she knows she couldn't
afford to lose her subsidy. She doesn't want to relocate outside the
city because she relies on the city's public transportation and needs to
be near her doctors.

"I have no options, other than being out on the street - which would kill me," she said.

FAIR
USE NOTICE. Tenants Together is not the author of this article and the posting
of this document does not imply any endorsement of the content by Tenants
Together.  This document may contain copyrighted material the use of which
may not have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants
Together is making this article available on our website in an effort to
advance the understanding of tenant rights issues in California. We believe
that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided
for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this
copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you
must obtain permission from the copyright owner.

Help build power for renters' rights: