According to the Contra Costa Times, the California Apartment Association announced today that they collected over 7,000 signatures from Richmond residents to repeal renters’ protections. They need 4,100 valid signatures to turn in by Sept. 4. The signatures still need to be validated and turned in before they can be used.
According to the city attorney, if 10 percent of registered voters sign the petition and the signatures are validated, the ordinance is suspended. Then the City Council could repeal the ordinance or put it on the ballot at the next regular municipal election, scheduled for Nov. 16, 2016.
During July, a majority of Richmond City Council members voted to pass an ordinance to protect renters from displacement, which included rent control and just cause eviction protections.
It was a long-term effort to stop the displacement of renters facing eviction from increasing high rents, greedy landlords and sales of rental properties by realtors displacing families in the process. Rents have increased more than 24 percent in recent years in Richmond.
It was also the first time in 30 years that rent control was passed by a California city to protect vulnerable renters facing the choice of going hungry to pay the rent or being pushed out of their housing.
Many groups were behind the organizing effort to protect renters from displacement in Richmond, including AFSCME Local 3299, ACCE (Alliance of Californians for Community Empowerment), Tenants Together, Asian Pacific Environmental Network, Building Blocks for Kids Richmond Collaborative, California Nurses Association, Contra Costa Interfaith Supporting Community Organization, Centro Latino Cuzcatian, CUIDO (Communities United in Support of Olmstead), Eviction Defense Center, EBHO (East Bay Housing Organization), Iron Triangle Neighborhood Council, Richmond Progressive Alliance, Saffron Strand, SEIU Local 1021, Urban Habitat and Urban Tilth.
On the other side, many landlords, realtors, speculators, apartment owners and the wealthy elite have been opposed. Renters’ protections prevent the maximum exploitation of renters, especially the many families with children and the elderly who are being forced out of their housing due to increasing rents or no-cause evictions.
While announcing how many signatures were collected to repeal renters’ protections in Richmond, Tom Bannon of the California Apartment Association is reported as saying, “Rent control has been a failed public policy and doesn’t do what it’s intended to do.”
Eleanor Walden, former Berkeley Rent Stabilization member, is on the other side. “I want to congratulate Gayle McLaughlin and the Richmond Progressive Alliance for their efforts to establish rent stabilization in Richmond,” she said. “Rent control is about the right for decent housing for Richmond citizens who are poor and working class.
“The greed of the landlords and the stupidity of those who accept their self-serving line of argument obscures the facts: The unspoken underlying objection to controlled rent has to do with color and class bias in America. Small landlords who supply housing at rent controlled rates get a reasonable return on their investment or they can appeal to the Board for necessary increases upon justification. It is the corporate landholders who have the resources to mount opposition to decent housing legislation for their exaggerated profits.”
Feagley Realtors involved in attack on Richmond’s rent control
Jerry Feagley, owner of Feagley Realtors in Richmond, is involved in the attack against renters’ protections, including rent control and just cause eviction protection for tenants. Feagley Realtors has three offices. Petitions have been available at his offices for landlords to sign who are involved in the attack against renters’ protections.
During a discussion with Mr. Feagley on Sept. 3, he stated that he is against renters’ protections. He also mentioned that he has spoken out against renters’ protections at Richmond’s Council meetings.
“I spoke out against renters’ protections at the Richmond Council meetings,” said Feagley. “I believe that rent control creates higher rents for tenants. The existing system works fine, so why fix it if it is not broken?”
When I asked Mr. Feagley who is behind the petition to repeal renters’ protections in Richmond, he stated: “A number of property owners have organized together to come up with the petition against renters’ protections. I do not know if it will be successful, but I understand that they are very close to having collected enough signatures to repeal renters’ protections.”
Mr. Feagley did not mention how much money he may have chipped in for the attack against renters’ protections in Richmond. He also refused to name others involved in the attack against renters or how many property owners actually are involved in the scheme. Additionally, he did not state why as a realtor he was concerned about higher rents for Richmond’s tenants.
Generally, realtors are totally against renters’ protections and just cause eviction protections because they want a property to be emptied of its tenants when it is being sold. They make more money when selling a property emptied of its tenants.
Confusion and lack of transparency
A recent report by the Contra Costa Times stated: “The source of the petition has remained in the shadows, renewing fears about big-money interests meddling in local politics and generating claims of misinformation being spread by paid signature gatherers to secure support.”
Other newspapers reported that it was a mystery as to who is behind the petition to repeal renters’ protections in Richmond.
According to reports, one person after another has also claimed that the people gathering signatures for the petition to repeal the renters’ protections have been telling lies to the public in an effort to trick them into signing it.
Richmond Public Library assistant Stacey Agnitsch stated that she was approached twice by petition gatherers who she believed lied to her when they falsely claimed the petition would make rent control stronger. Another resident named Eli Moore reported that a petitioner came to his door and claimed that the referendum was to prevent rents from going up because the city has voted to raise rents by 40 percent, which is not true.
An email sent out by the Richmond Progressive Alliance on Aug. 27 states: “We are reaching out to notify you of a misleading petition to repeal the new rent control ordinance in Richmond, Calif. This petition is being circulated by paid professionals who are now earning $12.50 per signature, funded by an anonymous group.
“If you have been contacted by one of these circulators, please disregard their fraudulent claims that the petition will support rent control. Not all of these circulators are making misleading or fraudulent claims, but we have received dozens of reports from residents and have cause to believe that up to half of their signatures are from supporters who have been otherwise fooled.
“This petition will not support rent control, and the groups working to stabilize rents in Richmond do not endorse it. The community groups supporting rent control are listed at the bottom of this message.”
This petition if validated will SUSPEND the ordinance until November 2016. During that time landlords will be free to unfairly raise rents and evict tenants without just cause.
It is now being reported that the signature gatherers have been getting paid as much as $20 a signature to repeal rent control in Richmond.
Lori Kossowsky, a tenant advocate said, “I know several signature gatherers who have declined to collect signatures to repeal rent control in Richmond because they believe that it is immoral to be involved in such an endeavor. I also believe that many signature gatherers lied and confused people as a way to get them to sign the petition.”
It was reported that Tom Bannon of the California Apartment Association said, “I’m disappointed if there was confusion among folks who were asked to sign, but I have not heard that this was a widespread problem.”
FAIR USE NOTICE. Tenants Together is not the author of this article and the posting of this document does not imply any endorsement of the content by Tenants Together. This document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.