How CalPERS bet big on real estate and lost

Monday, May 3, 2010
Ed Mendel
Calpensions

In a “lessons learned” report, the CalPERS staff analyzes how real
estate investments, once a leading profit center, had lost nearly half
their value by early this year, a performance ranking at the bottom
among large public pension funds.

CalPERS has had well-publicized real estate losses — among them
nearly $1 billion in a Los Angeles area residential development, $500
million in New York rental units, and $91 million on a stalled
commercial development in Boston.

The report
said CalPERS
made policy changes allowing more risk and debt,
followed by large ill-timed investments at the height of the real estate
boom, resulting in a real estate portfolio worth $13.7 billion in
January, down 47.5 percent for the year.

CalPERS sold $16 billion worth of income-producing and other low
risk real estate, said the report, and then spent the money while buying
$30 billion worth of higher risk real estate as the market peaked in
2005 and 2006.

Adding to the risk, CalPERS used a form of debt backed by CalPERS
itself rather than the property. And as the real estate holdings became
larger and more complex, CalPERS management was hampered by an
inadequate data system.

Ted Eliopoulos, the CalPERS senior real estate officer, who has been
working on reforms since taking the post three years ago, told the
investment committee last week the report was a chance to “reflect” on
experience and “provide hopefully some insight.”

A memo
from Pension
Consulting Alliance presented with the staff
report said CalPERS real estate investments, which began in 1983,
followed a “lower risk strategy” for nearly two decades.

But in 2002, CalPERS began a shift to a “higher risk strategy” with
more debt, looser guidelines for partners, fewer stable income-producing
investments, and a “dramatic” investment increase making the management
and sale of assets difficult.

Another riskier change mentioned in the memo: “Large concentrated
investments such as LandSource, Peter Cooper Village, and Centerpoint
increased exposure to specific submarkets and strategies.”

Here are brief descriptions from various news sources of some
well-publicized CalPERS real estate losses.

–LandSource: CalPERS paid $970 million in January 2007 for a
majority stake in a Lennar Corp. development on the 15,000-acre Newhall
Ranch north of Los Angeles. The project declared bankruptcy 15 months
later. CalPERS severed ties with the advisor that recommended the
investment, MacFarlane
Partners
of San Francisco.

–Stuyvesant Town and
Peter Cooper
Village: CalPERS invested $500 million in the $5.4
billion purchase by Tishman Speyer and BlackRock of 11,227 apartments
on 80 acres in New York City. The plan was to replace rent-controlled
tenants with market rents. But the courts objected, and the owners
defaulted on a loan.

–Centerpoint: A CalPERS operative, CalEast,
paid $3.4 billion
in January 2005 for the largest industrial
landlord in the Chicago area. An analyst told Forbes he thought CalPERS
paid $900 million more than the value of the property, apparently to get
the Centerpoint management team. CalEast value plunged in the economic
downturn.

–East Palo Alto: CalPERS invested $100 million in a Page Mill
Properties plan to upgrade 1,700
rent-controlled units
and charge market rents. Critics said
1,500 low-income tenants were displaced. After a complex legal battle,
the lender foreclosed.

–Columbus Center: CalPERS invested $91 million in
a plan to build
condos, hotel rooms and stores over a section
of the Massachusetts turnpike in Boston, triggering a 13-year battle
with neighborhood opponents and 130 community meetings. Opponents want
CalPERS to pay $4 million to $5 million to clean up the partially
excavated site.

–Capitol Mall Towers: CalPERS invested $100 million in April 2006
in a proposal for twin 53-story
condo towers
and a hotel in Sacramento, not far from CalPERS
headquarters. As the real estate bubble burst, CalPERS bought out the
developer 14 months later for an undisclosed sum and still owns the
undeveloped block.

–Koin Center: CalPERS and a partner paid $109 million in 2007 to buy
the bottom 19 floors of a landmark building
in Portland
,
known as the “mechanical pencil” because of its
shape. Last July they defaulted on a $70 million mortgage and gave up
ownership.

CalPERS was riding high during the height of the real estate boom.
In June 2006, the investment committee was told last week, annual real
estate returns averaged 22 percent during the five previous years.

The CalPERS senior investment officer during the real estate boom,
Mike McCook, was listed as one of the “30 most influential people in
private equity real estate” in a November 2006 issue of Private Equity
Real Estate.

“Our performance has exceeded every benchmark that we had,” McCook
told the publication. “When you do that and there aren’t a lot of
complaints from either partners or union sources, then you must be doing
your job right.”

(The publication said McCook had left CalPERS after nearly five
years in the post and would be going to work for Kenwood Investments, a
private equity real estate firm in San Francisco founded in 1999 by
Darius Anderson.

(Anderson agreed this month to pay a
$500,000 settlement
in a New York probe of kickbacks for
obtaining pension fund investments. Anderson, who received “placement
agent” fees for a CalPERS investment, was not charged in New York.

(McCook now works with Resmark Equity Partners in Los Angeles. He
did not return a phone call asking for comment on the CalPERS staff
report last week.)

Most real estate investors have had big losses in recent years. But
CalPERS, using “leverage” or debt to make major higher-risk investments
at the height of the boom, is one of the hardest hit.

The staff report said CalPERS, in percentage terms, had the biggest
losses among a half dozen large pension funds in the last three years. A
Wilshire report last month puts CalPERS 10-year real estate returns in
the bottom 1 percent of large funds.

“If you look at CalPERS since the inception it’s just under seven
percent positive,” Eliopoulos said of the real estate returns over the
last three decades. “But this has been a very difficult stretch with the
mistakes we have outlined here.”

Another perspective is that real estate is about 7 percent of a
CalPERS investment portfolio currently valued at $210 billion. That’s
less than the 10 percent target allocation for real estate.

Among the real estate reforms made during the last three years are
policies to control debt and contracts, require reviews of some
investment decisions by a staff committee and consultant, new databases
and a performance review of investment partners.

The Pension Consulting Alliance is suggesting that CalPERS return to
the “less aggressive” investment real estate strategies used before
2002, many generating stable income. CalPERS is doing a year-long look
at overall investment strategies.

Board member Priya Mathur said CalPERS did not “hide our heads” and
has dealt with the difficult issue of real estate losses. She and other
board members congratulated the staff for years of hard work to
restructure the program.

“I hope we can stop having these discussions where we continue to
berate ourselves for past misactions,” Mathur said. “But I think this
really is a great way for us to move forward.”

Reporter Ed Mendel covered the Capitol in Sacramento for nearly
three decades, most recently for the San Diego Union-Tribune. More
stories are at http://calpensions.com/
 Posted 30 Apr 10

FAIR USE NOTICE. This document may contain
copyrighted material the
use of which may not have been specifically authorized by the copyright
owner. Tenants Together is making this article available on our website
in an effort to advance the understanding of tenant rights issues in
California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such
copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the U.S.
Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for
purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain
permission from the copyright owner.

Help build power for renters' rights: