How renters get stuck in foreclosure mess

Wednesday, April 21, 2010
BRITTANY LEVINE
Orange County Register

There's a federal law that's supposed to protect renters who get
caught in a foreclosure battle between their landlord and the bank, but
a conflict involving San Clemente renters highlights how the law can
fall short when it comes to prepaid rent and other issues.

On Feb. 1, Farmers & Merchants Bank took over a foreclosed
apartment complex at 1520 N. El Camino Real because the owner, Nilop
Investments LLC, owed the bank about $7.7 million from a construction
loan, a bank representative said.

Some renters at the complex were asked to pay March rent to the
bank's property management company and leave in 90 days, even though
the renters had fixed-term leases and said they already paid the
previous owner rent.

When the tenants refused to pay double rent for March and said they
wanted to live out the remainder of their leases, property manager
Pacific West Asset Management filed unlawful detainer complaints in
mid-March, the first step toward evicting tenants.

NON-PROFIT HELP

The Fair Housing Foundation, a non-profit, tried to intervene
unsuccessfully on behalf of the renters, citing a Federal Law called
the Helping Families Save Their Homes Act, which protects renters
during foreclosures.

On Tuesday, two of the four renters went to court to challenge their evictions.

Bruce Entezam, who signed an 11 month lease in January and paid
$12,000 in advance to the previous owner, settled with the building's
new owner for a confidential amount and agreed to move out soon before
his trial.

The other renter, Mark Sammons, attempted to fight, using the new federal law.

Sammons, who had a year-long lease and paid through March, was
ordered by the judge to leave in 10 days. Sammons said Pacific West
offered to make a settlement with him, too, but he didn't do so because
he thought his lease and the Home Act would ensure a win.

"The judge just absolutely didn't care," about the Home Act, said
Sammons. "He said it only applies to people who pay rent, but I did pay
my rent. I just paid it to the previous owner." Sammons was ordered to
pay $2,000, which covers March rent and attorney's fees. Sammons says
he paid his rent for April before the court appearance and was willing
to pay for every month afterwards except March.

WHICH LAW IS FOLLOWED?

In May 2009, the Obama Administration passed the Home Act to protect
renters during foreclosure situations amidst the turbulent housing
market.

The Act says that if a lease is signed before a foreclosure, renters
should be able to live in the home for the remainder of the lease. The
law doesn't apply to month-to-month renters, who must leave after
receiving a 90 day notice. Before the law passed, a foreclosure wiped
out existing leases, turning all renters into month-to-monthers.

The Home Act doesn't specifically mention what happens in a case of
prepaid rent, said Steven Kellman, an attorney and foreclosure expert.

"They passed this federal law, which is so vague and California law
is so specific that trying to match up the specific system with the
vague law doesn't work," said Kellman, president of San Diego's Tenants
Legal Center. "The federal law seems as if it wants to help you out,
but it's really just a quick kind of Band-Aid patch."

The Home Act only applies to those that sign leases before a notice
of foreclosure, Kellman said. The problem is in California, the term
notice of foreclosure, which is used in the federal law, doesn't
technically exist, he said. Instead, California terms include: notice
of default, which can begin the foreclosure process, and notice of
trustee sale, the day a new owner takes over.

The San Clemente renters signed leases in January with Leo Goldberg,
a general contractor charged with managing the property for Nilop.
Goldberg gave discounts to those who paid in advance. A month later,
renters were notified of a trustee sale. The notice of default was
filed in April.

Another real estate attorney, Calvin Yap of Oswald & Yap LLP in
Irvine, said the bank should have notified tenants after the notice of
default was issued and told residents that rent should be directed to
them, not the previous owner. However, the bank says it did not know
people were living in the building, which was built last year.

In past California cases that have dealt with the Home Act, some
judges have used the default date as the notice of foreclosure cutoff,
Kellman said. He suggested renters look for a notice of default, not
just a notice of trustee sale before signing leases. Another issue is
that the Home Act doesn't touch on prepaid rent.

Superior Court Judge Corey Cramin told Sammons he should have paid
the March rent to Pacific West and then go after Goldberg for the money
he prepaid, Sammons said.

Goldberg said he informed residents when they moved in that he was
undergoing financial negotiations with the bank, but residents said he
never mentioned foreclosure. Goldberg said he gave everyone their
deposits back and asked them to leave by February. However, tenants say
he never asked them to leave and they never received their deposits
back. Goldberg was also living in the building, not paying rent, a bank
representative said. Some renters said they plan on suing Goldberg
directly, although Goldberg maintains he has done nothing wrong.

"If they want to go to court, let them go to court," he said. "When
it comes to money, people will do anything they want. They lie. I'm not
afraid."

Messages left for David Goldberg, the man listed as president on
Nilop's Chapter 11 bankruptcy records, at his Laguna Niguel home, were
not returned.

PROPOSED SETTLEMENT

Justin Dean, who is scheduled to appear in court soon for a similar
case, said he was offered a settlement by Sue Graban, a Pacific West
property manager, if he moves out in 10 days. If he settles out of
court, Pacific West would waive his March rent, which he said he paid
to Goldberg.

"I've never been harassed so much and so blatantly," said Dean, who
doesn't know what he's going to do, but knows he doesn't want to end up
like Sammons. He said Pacific West had taken boxes out of his apartment
during inspection without asking and often locked the doors leading
into the building from the stairwell, the only way to get in since the
elevator is broken.

Because of the broken elevator, Sammons said he had to carry his
daughter, who had leukemia, up the stairs to their apartment, which has
a broken shower. Things got so bad, his daughter moved in with her
mother. Pacific West's attorney Leslie Bower said she would not discuss
the situation.

On Tuesday the city sent Pacific West a notice saying people living
in the complex need to vacate because conditions aren't up to code. If
Pacific West is going to be collecting rent and occupying the building
they need to apply for a temporary occupancy permit, but the city has
yet to get one, said Mike Jorgensen, a city building official. Goldberg
had a temporary occupancy permit granted by the city valid from Oct.
21, 2009 to Jan. 29, 2010.

George McFedries, head of the bank's credit administration
department, said: "We really feel sorry for these tenants. They've been
duped. We're not here to harm the tenants, but we have to finish the
building and sell it."

Contact the writer: blevine@ocregister.com or 949-492-5135

FAIR USE NOTICE. This document may contain copyrighted material the
use of which may not have been specifically authorized by the copyright
owner. Tenants Together is making this article available on our website
in an effort to advance the understanding of tenant rights issues in
California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such
copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the U.S.
Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for
purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain
permission from the copyright owner.  

Help build power for renters' rights: