These days, Jack Mingo's story sounds all-too-familiar: when he and his wife applied for a loan for their first home, a 1,700-square-foot, three-bedroom residence in Alameda, he remembers, "I kept waiting for some rational person at the bank to say, 'There's no way you can afford this debt.' But they were very encouraging.'"
He started having misgivings about the $235,000 purchase "the night we signed." And from there, the anxieties just continued to mount. The reality of extra expenses, like roof repairs and property taxes, sunk in. And then the adjustable-rate mortgage rose -- at one point it jumped from $1,400 to $2,200 a month.
Mingo, a 57-year-old freelance writer, whose daughter was five when he bought the home, says, "It ended up being a pretty desperate situation -- not running the heat to save money, that sort of thing. We eventually had to borrow money from family and friends just to stay in the house."
His marriage eventually broke up, and although his ex-wife was able to find work to cover the mortgage on her own and keep the home, it was not without constant worrying about money. The perception of security that initially drew the couple to home ownership "ended up backfiring," he says.
Mingo's tale of getting in over his head with real estate is not a story from the recent housing bust -- he bought his Alameda home in 1990.
But it's an experience that affected him deeply, and a major reason why he hasn't owned another home since. Mingo and his current wife, Erin Barrett, still live in Alameda, but they are avowed renters.
Over the years, they've thought a lot about the practical and psychological implications of home ownership. At just under $2,600, their current rent could be enough for a monthly mortgage on some Bay Area homes, but they've decided that the value and freedoms they gain by renting far outweigh the benefits of owning.
Barrett, 41, who is also a writer (she and Mingo have authored several books together), has recently taken on a part-time managerial job at a local winery. She says Mingo's ill-fated experiment with home ownership served as a cautionary tale for her as well. But the couple's commitment to renting was also reaffirmed several years ago, when they moved with Barrett's two children to Charlottesville, Va, for a year. Their attempt to transition to a smaller, more affordable place ended up being, in Barrett's words, "a complete and utter disaster."
***
In 2001, Barrett says, she and Mingo were growing tired of "the bustle, the large crowds, the pollution, and the cost" of the Bay Area. After researching alternatives, they settled on Charlottesville for several reasons -- its proximity to family (it was equidistant between the their parents' homes), its natural beauty and wealth of outdoor space, its highly ranked schools, its "liberal profile," and its cheaper cost of living.
"If we moved to a place that's cheaper, we could afford to do more," Barrett remembers thinking. "We could maybe some day afford to buy (a home)," she adds. "We were paying about $1,200 in rent for our apartment in Alameda at the time, and if we paid $700 or $800 in Charlottesville (we could use the difference to) come and visit Bay Are a few times a year, and maybe even enjoy it more than we do now."
Things started off well in Virginia. They found a house to rent, for about $800 a month, and it was about twice the size of the apartment they'd left behind in the Bay Area.
The lower cost of living in Charlottesville was a relief. "We felt very secure financially that year," Barrett says. "We flew back (to the Bay Area) for Christmas that year, and we visited both our parents several times."
Still, they encountered quite a few difficulties in their new town. They found it very hard to break in, socially, Barrett says, especially after 9/11, when the community in Charlottesville, much closer to the disaster, turned inward, seeking solace in old relationships instead of welcoming newcomers. To compound their sense of isolation during that unsettling time, Mingo and Barrett also found themselves without the nearby support of family and friends they'd left behind in California.
They were also disappointed in their children's school, and Barrett says they found Charlottesville's culture more politically and socially conservative than they'd expected.
"None of the women worked," Barrett says. "And the social interactions were the exact same ones I left in Alabama" (where she grew up). "The upper middle class men ... they generally would not look me in the eye. Even though I'd said something, they'd respond to [Jack]."
In short, Barrett and Mingo missed home. "I got very depressed that fall," Barrett remembers. "And I kept saying to Jack, 'We've got to go back.' There was a reason I moved to the Bay Area: the tolerance, the openness, the arts, the possibilities."
And so, when their one-year lease was up in Charlottesville, they returned to Alameda -- to the same apartment complex they'd moved out of the previous summer.
***
A couple of years after they returned, Mingo, Barrett and Barrett's two children moved into their current rental, a 4,000-foot white stucco home on the former Alameda Naval Air Station.
It's a light-filled and well-worn structure, and the hub of several evolving spaces and projects.
"We're still trying to figure out what to do with that room," Mingo says, pointing to a sun porch that holds a tangle of furniture and boxes. A Chihuahua, one of a pair that Mingo and Barrett recently adopted, yaps as they show me out to the spacious backyard. A clay oven sits on a large wooden deck and a chicken coop lies empty (the two recently became vegans). In the far corner of the spacious yard, bees circle three large boxes -- Mingo taught himself about beekeeping a couple of years back, and they now sell their honey through a local cafe.
Mingo and Barrett have an easy rapport -- they finish each other's sentences, laugh at each other's jokes, and it's hard to imagine either in the stressed-out states they describe from the past: Barrett in a culture-shocked funk in Charlottesville, or Mingo as a desperate, aggrieved home owner nearly two decades ago.
How much of their current air of comfort and calm -- their aura of lightness -- derives from living without the weight of home ownership?
Impossible to quantify, of course. And in a roundabout way, did Mingo's embattled "investment," years ago, also end up affording him and Barrett some breathing room in the long run? Mingo said he and his ex-wife each received about $72,000 in 2004 when they sold the house they'd bought together in 1990, and he told me that having this money in his bank account in 2004 may have helped him and Barrett to convince their current landlord to rent to them.
When I e-mailed to ask Mingo if that original investment, in 1990, was in any way worth the costs, he replied, "Worth it? God no. It's like asking a prisoner if the years in jail were worth it because he got a free suit and bus fare afterward."
He went on to catalog numerous expenses that more than canceled out that $72,000 "profit," from maxed out credit cards and wiped out savings, to broken appliances, to a monthly mortgage payment that exceeded the rental price of other homes in his neighborhood.
And those were just the financial costs.
"In stress and worry, in the recurring midnight terrors, in the job decisions I made to feed the beast, in the days of hopelessness and snapping at my family, in the shows not seen and trips not taken, in the humiliation of calling friends and family, begging to borrow money -- no. It most definitely wasn't worth it," he wrote. "Buying a house was perhaps the most damaging, stupidest thing I've ever done in my life. It was a lousy investment in every sense; that dream of 'owning a house!' turned into a decade-long nightmare."
***
The process of recounting his financial and psychological losses seems to put Mingo in an agitated state that's hard to square with the laidback writer who showed me around his spacious rental home.
And that trauma clearly informs the way both he and Barrett talk about the many ways in which renting has been liberating for them, and how they rarely long for real estate of their own.
When they returned from Charlottesville, Barrett says she and Mingo resolved to "spend our money on things that create memories -- hiking, biking, canoeing, geocaching, visiting with friends, traveling to visit family, going out to eat."
They both argue that home-ownership is falsely assumed to be a rite of passage in our culture and one that, at different points in their lives, they'd bought into without fully examining.
"It was the dream, of course -- everyone's dream," Mingo remembers thinking when he purchased his home decades ago, a decision that he and his then-wife made in part to demonstrate that "we're grown-ups now."
All these years later, he sees things differently: "To me it feels like a scam similar to the you've-got-to-have-a-diamond-equal-to-three-quarters-of-your salary-or-it's-not-a-real-marriage scam. We have been sold this idea based on nothing other than marketing: you've got to have this house; you've got to have this sparkly diamond."
Although Barrett has never owned a home -- and she was discouraged by Mingo's experience -- she admits that, before her year in Virginia, she still felt uneasy about renting.
"I'm somewhat embarrassed to admit that it was an unconscious need to keep up with the Joneses that drove me to feel discontented here," she says. "I wanted to be able to do what other people were doing. After all, doesn't home ownership equal stability, maturity, being a good parent? I had weirdly convinced myself that I wasn't doing the right thing unless I provided that for my kids. To back up my rationale, all I had to do was look around; this is the goal of most Americans.
But a higher cost of living and having to rent wasn't really what was making her unhappy here, she adds: "It was the illusive concepts of what it means to be grown-up. In our country, these concepts seem to orbit around irrational expectations about life and a twisted vision of what's truly important."
Mingo says that, during the recent collapse of the housing bubble, he felt a certain "extra empathy" for those who, like him, had seen their visions of home ownership turn into nightmares.
"The extra empathy I felt was for the hopeless people as they realized they'd never get out of being underwater. I could vicariously join them as they discovered that heartbreaking relief in dropping their keys in an envelope and mailing it to their mortgage holder -- that heady combination of fear, relief, lightness, sadness, freedom and the possibility of new beginnings."
Rob would like to hear from readers about recent experiences with unemployment. E-mail him at rbaedeker@sfgate.com.
Rob Baedeker is a writer living in Oakland. He is the co-author, with the Kasper Hauser comedy group, of "SkyMaul," Weddings of the Times," and "Obama's Blackberry."
FAIR USE NOTICE. This document may contain copyrighted material the
use of which may not have been specifically authorized by the copyright
owner. Tenants Together is making this article available on our website
in an effort to advance the understanding of tenant rights issues in
California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such
copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the U.S.
Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for
purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain
permission from the copyright owner.