Irvine Trial Lawyer Gregory G. Brown Settles Multi-Plaintiff Apartment Complex Dispute for $1,600,000 After Trial and Defenda...

Monday, October 4, 2010
PRWeb

After 3 years of litigation, the "battle of Roxbury" resolves. The
case involved a sixteen unit apartment complex. Plaintiffs alleged many
problems ranging from violating rent control, to fraud, to breach of
contract to breach of the warranty of habitability. The case first went
to trial in the Los Angeles Superior Court, but was split into two
separate phases (Case No: BC381214 lead / consolidated with BC382717,
BC384500, BC388672, BC386060, BC387811, BC389385, and BC403026). The
first phase was a two week Court trial where allegations of unfair
business practices under Business & Professions Code Section 17200
were addressed before all other claims. In finding for the Plaintiffs,
the trial judge noted on the record that Defendant Aniko Kaye’s
credibility “was zero”. Kaye had testified over a two day period and,
according to Irvine Trial Lawyer Gregory Brown, "her contradictions were
so prevalent, it was hard to keep track. The impact was increased when
video tape deposition testimony of outright contradictions was played
in open Court."

After prevailing in the first phase, the Court set the second jury
trial phase. After opening statement by Gregory G. Brown and initial
trial witnesses, Defendant Kaye filed for bankruptcy protection (CASE
NO. 2:09-bk-38287-BR -CHAPTER 11 proceeding). Shortly thereafter, the
Bankruptcy Court granted leave from the automatic bankruptcy stay and
ordered the case be transferred back to the Superior Court to resume
trial (in front of the same Judge). Just before trial was set to
resume, a settlement conference was set up and Defendant’s prior
$200,000 offer was increased to $1,600,000 to resolve all nine
Plaintiff’s claims.

FACTS: Plaintiff George Sharp ,Was a tenant in an apartment building
owned by defendant Aniko Kaye, located at 484 South Roxbury Drive,
beginning in July 2004. Sharp, along with nine other tenants, filed
suit against Kaye, alleging they had been living in substandard housing
,with damp living conditions, plumbing issues, heating problems, as well
as air conditioning and security issues, lack of lighting, insects,
odors, drinking water contamination, and intentional exposure to
asbestos fibers and lead paint.

PLAINTIFF CONTENTIONS: The tenants contended that, if they
complained, Kaye would retaliate against them by filing eviction
actions, making false reports about pet abandonment, and filing false
police reports, in order to harass them. The tenants further claimed
Kaye refused to fix problems and raised the rent for anyone who filed
suit against her. The tenants alleged violations of the Los Angeles Rent
Stabilization Ordinances, breach of implied warranty of habitability,
breach of contract, retaliation, negligence~ nuisance, and unfair
business practices.

INJURIES: The tenants claimed to suffer allergies, asthma,
bronchitis, chronic headaches, depression, anxiety, eye irritation,
colds, heartburn, sinusitis, and sleeplessness.

DAMAGES: The tenants sought damages for overpayment of rent and emotional distress.

RESULT: The parties reached a settlement for $1.6 million.

Irvine Trial Lawyer Gregory G. Brown is a partner in the Orange
County Business Litigation and Trial Law Firm of Brown &
Charbonneau, LLP and specialize in complex business and trial matters.
Gregory G. Brown is a Certified Trial Specialist and has been selected
for inclusion by Super Lawyers for the last three years in a row
(representing the top 5% of California Attorneys). Brown &
Charbonneau, LLP is well known for being hard hitting, aggressive
litigators and trial specialists. They practice business litigation,
commercial litigation, real estate litigation, family law and personal
injury litigation throughout Southern California.

For more information, visit www.bc-llp.com

FAIR USE NOTICE. This
document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been
specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this
article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of
tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair
use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the
U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes
of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the
copyright owner.

Help build power for renters' rights: