"It was an important step in the process,"
said Dan Pasquini, a spokesman for City Councilman Daniel Garodnick, on
Tuesday.
Garodnick is a Democrat
who wants the sprawling middle-class apartment complex -- where he lives
-- on Manhattan's Lower East Side converted to condominium or
cooperative apartments.
But at
least one potential buyer has said that the lawsuits that attached to
the property will delay the sale to tenants, outside investors, or a
combination of both.
U.S. District
Court Judge Alvin Hellerstein, of the Southern District in Manhattan,
ruled late Monday that the two apartment properties can now be sold,
four months after CWCapital, the special servicer, sought to foreclose
on the 11,200 apartments in 56 buildings sprawled across 80 acres.
A special servicer oversees troubled loans
that have been securitized. Some $3 billion of the debt used to finance
the $5.4 billion purchase of the apartment complex by a Tishman
Speyer-BlackRock Inc joint venture was securitized into commercial
mortgage-backed bonds.
It's up to
CWCapital to decide when to sell it.
When
interest and attorneys fees are factored in, the Stuyvesant Town/Peter
Cooper Village bondholders are owed at least $3.67 billion, according to
the judge's decision.
Insurer
MetLife sold the apartment complex in 2006, just as the real estate
market was peaking. The property now is valued at about $2 billion.
To its critics, the iconic apartment
complex that was built for World War Two veterans and city workers
symbolized the real estate market's excesses.
Tishman Speyer-BlackRock were criticized
for trying to replace middle-class rent-regulated tenants with people
who could pay higher, market-rate rents.
The
joint venture lost a key state court decision on this issue, which
further imperiled their investment.
Equity
and other investors -- such as California pension fund Calpers,
Government of Singapore Investment Corp, and SL Green Realty Corp --
have seen their stakes wiped out.
THE
EPIC CONTINUES
Still to be hashed
out are the taxes and possible punitive damages for tenants stemming
from the state court case and these issues will delay a sale, said
Richard LeFrak, chairman of the giant property and energy company LeFrak
Organization.
"StuyTown is like
'War and Peace,'" LeFrak said last week at the Reuters Global Real Estate and
Infrastructure Summit. "It's going to take some time. There's not
going to be instant activity here."
LeFrak
said that differences between creditors and tenants will likely
complicate a sale.
"I think in the
end it's the government that's going to have a lot to say," he said.
"Whoever is going to buy this thing has to
go to Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac," LeFrak said. "Let's assume you have
to get a mortgage of $1.5 billion, exactly where do you get such a
thing?"
The two agencies helped
finance the purchase, buying some of the bonds carved out of the $3
billion mortgage, which was spread across five CMBS deals.
The case is Bank of America et al v. PCV ST
Owner LP et, U.S. District Court, Southern District of New York, No.
1:10-cv-1178.
FAIR USE NOTICE. This
document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been
specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this
article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of
tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair
use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the
U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes
of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the
copyright owner.