Judge delays landlord’s lawsuit

Saturday, January 8, 2011
Bob Okon
The Herald-News

A Will County judge this week stalled a landlord’s attempt to collect rent on a house tied up in bankruptcy.

The house is one of three on the same block in the
Springwood South subdivision owned by Chitralekha Thakkar. All three
houses on Meadowsedge Lane are in foreclosure. And the tenants have been
holding back rent, saying they believe their security deposits and
leases are in jeopardy because of the bankruptcy.

So far, judges in small claims court have not
agreed with the tenants that the bankruptcy and foreclosures should
prevent the landlord from collecting rent.

But Judge Rick Mason told Thakkar and her husband,
who goes by “Mike,” at a hearing Thursday that their lawsuit to force
rent payment from the Beavers family cannot proceed because of the
bankruptcy. Mason noted that the bankruptcy comes with an “automatic
stay” that prevents the Thakkars from pursuing legal action unless the
stay is lifted.

“The court is unaware of any order lifting the
automatic stay,” said Mason, who had previously continued the case so he
could check on the Thakkar bankruptcy. “The (bankruptcy) trustee was
not aware of any order to lift the automatic stay.”

Mason again continued the case, this time till
Feb. 18, when the bankruptcy may be discharged, and cautioned Robert and
Catherine Beavers, “You understand that you can’t live in there
rent-free.” Mason noted that he could later order all rent to be paid
and even allow Thakkar to evict the Beavers.

Ongoing foreclosure saga

The outcome of this week’s hearing was one more
legal twist in a situation that has been bewildering to the three
tenants who questioned why the Thakkars were able to rent out houses
that were in foreclosure. In the Beavers case, their house at 917
Meadowsedge was in foreclosure already when they moved in.

The Beavers and other tenants said they were never
informed by the Thakkars of the foreclosures and only learned that the
houses were in financial jeopardy when process servers started showing
up looking for their landlord.

The tenants said they are willing to pay rent but
question who they should pay. They are looking for protection against
the loss of their security deposits since their landlord is in
bankruptcy. They also worry that they will lose their leases and be
ordered out of the houses when the banks take them over.

Blaine Bowen, next-door neighbor to the Beavers,
lost his case in December in spite of the bankruptcy when Will County
Judge Ray Rossi gave Thakkar authority to move him out of the house.
Rossi, however, ordered Bowen to pay only $600, not the $1,370 Thakkar
had sought for unpaid rent in November.

Bowen considered appealing Rossi’s ruling but now
says he just wants to move out. He said this week that he found another
house but wants his $1,295 security deposit.

“I’m going to call him (Mike Thakkar) and give him
the keys and ask him for the security deposit,” Bowen said. “If he
doesn’t give it to me, I’m going to take him to court.”

The Thakkars have declined to talk to The Herald-News, which first reported about the situation on Meadowsedge Lane on Dec. 19.

FAIR USE NOTICE. This
document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been
specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this
article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of
tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair
use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the
U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes
of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the
copyright owner.

Help build power for renters' rights: