Judges Rewrite Ellis Act Without Legislative Approval

Monday, June 21, 2010
Dean Preston
Beyond Chron

This week, appellate judges re-wrote California's Ellis Act to find
that a landlord cannot waive its rights under the Ellis Act. The Case
is Embassy LLC v. City of Santa Monica.

The State Legislature is supposed to make the law which the courts then
apply. When it comes to California's Ellis Act, however, we have two
legislative bodies: The elected legislature that enacted the law and
the judiciary that rewrites the Act to benefit landlords.

Here's what happened in the Santa Monica case. The
City and landlord Embassy LLC entered into a settlement agreement ten
years ago in which the landlord expressly waived its right to withdraw
the rental units under California's Ellis Act. Subsequently, in August
2008, the same landlord sought to withdraw the units and evict the
tenants under the Ellis Act. The City rejected the filing based on the
landlord's waiver of the right to invoke the Ellis Act in the earlier
settlement agreement.

The landlord sued to compel the city to allow it to withdraw the units
from the rental market, notwithstanding the fact that the landlord had
given up the right to invoke Ellis. The landlord asserted that the
waiver it had signed was unenforceable as a matter of law. The trial
court correctly threw out the landlord's lawsuit. The landlord appealed.

Earlier this week, the Court of Appeal sided with the landlord. The
court reached the remarkable conclusion that "the Ellis Act provides
that a contractual waiver is unenforceable."

Of course, the Ellis Act says no such thing. The Act says nothing about
contractual waivers. Nor would there be any reason for the Act to
address waivers by a landlord. The point of the Act was to give a
landlord who complies with the Act a way out of the rental market, not
empower landlords who falsely promise to stay in the rental market the
ability to violate their written agreements.

When the legislature wants to provide that rights are nonwaivable, it
knows how to do it. There are California statutes that specify that
tenants cannot waive certain rights such as the right to jury trial,
the right to proper notice of eviction and the right to habitable
living conditions. This reflects the determination of the legislature
that tenants usually have little bargaining power and should not be
held to contractual provisions that require them to waive statutory
rights.

There is no similar "nonwaiver" provision in California law for
landlords, and certainly not one in the Ellis Act. At least there
wasn't until the Court of Appeal created one this week without
legislative approval.

The City of Santa Monica will now decide whether to petition the
California Supreme Court for review of this obviously incorrect
decision.


FAIR USE NOTICE. This
document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been
specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this
article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of
tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair
use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the
U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes
of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the
copyright owner.

Help build power for renters' rights: