Kagan: Cal ruling on religious landlady 'outrageous'

Saturday, June 26, 2010
Bob Egelko
The San Francisco Chronicle

When the California Supreme Court ruled in 1996 that a landlady had
to rent an apartment to an unwed couple despite her religious
objections to non-marital sex, civil rights groups and gay-rights
advocates applauded the court's commitment to anti-discriminaiton laws.
But a number of religious organizations, mostly conservative, saw the
ruling as a threat to individual freedom and backed an appeal to the
U.S. Supreme Court.

It turns out that they had an ally in the Clinton administration, a
lawyer in the White House counsel's office named Elena Kagan.

The court's reasoning "seems to me quite outrageous," Kagan said in
an August 1996 staff memo, one of a mound of documents released to
senators in advance of Monday's Judiciary Committee hearing on her
nomination to the U.S. Supreme Court.

She said the ruling endangered religious freedom in California, and
the Clinton administration should file papers supporting the landlady's
appeal. The administration stayed out of the case, the appeal was
denied and the ruling remains on the books.

It
was a case of rights in conflict, and Kagan -- whose most recent job,
solicitor general, put her in charge of the Obama administration's
Supreme Court cases -- came down on the side of the religious
practitioner incorporating her beliefs into her business.

he landlady, Evelyn Smith of Chico, refused to rent an apartment in
1987 to Gail Randall and Ken Phillips, telling them she believed sex
outside of marriage was sinful. In a 4-3 ruling nearly a decade later,
the California court said Smith was bound by a state law that
prohibited discrimination based on marital status.

While the state can't force people to violate their religious
beliefs to obtain benefits -- for example, working on the Sabbath to
stay eligible for unemployment -- California wasn't interfering with
Smith's beliefs by requiring her to follow the law, the court said.
Justice Kathryn Mickle Werdegar said Smith wasn't religiously compelled
to stay in the apartment business, and she could invest her money
elsewhere. Unlike the unemployment case and others involving
individuals who may have to choose between their beliefs and
subsistence benefits, Werdegar said, Smith's choice affected the rights
of others, her prospective tenants.

Kagan was unimpressed. By the same reasoning, she said in the White
House memo, a court could conclude that "a state law does not impose a
substantial burden on religion because the complainant is free to move
to another state."

She said the court's logic would also undermine the Religious
Freedom Restoration Act, a 1993 federal law that prohibited states from
imposing severe burdens on private religious practices in most cases.
Kagan may have foreseen what was about to happen to the law: a 1997
U.S. Supreme Court ruling that struck it down as an unconstitutional
interference with state authority. It's been replaced by a narrower law
that applies mainly to zoning disputes and people in prisons and mental
hospitals.

Sacramento lawyer Marian Johnston, the deputy state attorney general
who successfully argued the Smith case, says she doesn't think Kagan
understood the ruling.

The court "made it clear they were not interfering with the
landlady's right to believe however she wanted to believe, but she
couldn't insert those beliefs into being a landlady," Johnston said in
a recent interview, after learning of Kagan's memo.

"You can't impose your religious beliefs on someone else when you're
operating in the business world. If you believe there should be
segregation, would you be allowed not to rent to blacks? I assume the
answer is no."


FAIR USE NOTICE. This
document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been
specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this
article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of
tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair
use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the
U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes
of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the
copyright owner.

Help build power for renters' rights: