L.A. council blocks rent freeze, triggering protests

Saturday, May 22, 2010
Phil Willon and Joel Rubin
Los Angeles Times

The Los Angeles City Council on Friday effectively scuttled a proposed
four-month freeze on rent increases in the city, igniting a chaotic
protest by tenant rights advocates inside the City Hall chambers that
led to three arrests.

The proposed ordinance
would have prevented owners of 630,000 rent-controlled apartments from
raising rents between now and Oct. 31 to provide a respite for tenants
buffeted by the recession. Instead, the council voted 10 to 5 to send
the measure to a committee for further study, a procedural move killing
the proposed freeze and allowing landlords to raise rents by up to 3%
on July 1.

After the vote, outraged tenants and renters rights advocates who had
been waiting five hours for the measure to be considered started
shouting at the council. The protesters, dominated by members of the
Los Angeles Community Action Network, brought the meeting to a
standstill with loud, echoing chants of "No justice, no peace!'' and
other slogans.

Dozens of officers from the Los Angeles Police Department and the
city's General Services Police Department were called in after
protesters filled the main aisle of the John Ferraro Council Chamber
and refused to leave. Officers holding batons formed a mini skirmish
line and began pushing the unruly crowd outside, and tackled and
arrested three members of the community group.

"It was obvious that the small group disrupting the meeting wasn't
pleased with the vote, and they were displaying their displeasure in a
very violent manner," said Councilman Dennis Zine, who was chairing the
meeting and ordered officers to "get them out now'' after several
protesters ignored pleas for order.

Pete White, founder and co-director of the community group, identified
the arrested members as Deanna Weakly, Steve Richardson, and Gerardo
Gomez. Gomez was injured when his face smacked into one of the benches
as police restrained him, according to White.

White, along with about 40 protesters, said he was en route to LAPD's
Central Division station, where the three would be booked. The group
planned to remain there until the suspects gained their release, White
said.

Councilman Richard Alarcon, who proposed the rent freeze, said that
during his years working for Mayor Tom Bradley and serving on the
council he had never seen the "council lose control of its chamber''
and called the arrests a sad day in the city's history. But the protest
and subsequent clash, he said, were triggered by a council vote that
threatens to send some low-income renters onto the streets.

"These people are passionate. It's a very sad day for renters who are
going to have to pay more rent when many of them cannot pay their bills
now,'' Alarcon said. "What we saw today was an expression of their
anger.''

Alarcon's proposal would have imposed a four-month moratorium on rent
increases at buildings constructed before 1978 that have six or more
units, a group that is governed by the city's rent control law. Under
the law, owners of rent-controlled properties are eligible to impose 3%
rent increases on July 1.

The freeze would have given the council time to consider rent control
reforms and consider a comprehensive study on the issue currently
underway by the city's Housing Department, Alarcon said.

However, several landlords testifying before the council said any rent
freeze would be financially devastating to them, noting that they were
being hit with higher utility bills, insurance costs and property taxes.

The freeze was derailed by a motion from Council President Eric
Garcetti, who said it would be wiser for the council to wait and tackle
the broader rent control reforms instead of addressing the issue with a
piecemeal freeze. Voting against Garcetti's motion were council members
Alarcon, Jose Huizar, Herb Wesson and Paul Krekorian.

"Not passing this means that the rent burden will increase here in the
city, where 58% are paying unaffordable rents and 31% are paying 50% or
more of their income to rent," said Larry Gross, executive director of
the Coalition for Economic Survival, a renters rights group. "Not
passing this is to side with injustice at a time when people are being
laid off, furloughed, foreclosed upon and have to chose between paying
rent, medical expenses, food and clothing."

The council on Friday also approved an ordinance that requires lenders
to register foreclosed homes and face fines of up to $1,000 per day if
foreclosed homes fall into disrepair and become a blight to a
neighborhood. The ordinance is expected to raise up to $5 million a
year for the city, money the council wants to use to reduce the number
of layoffs needed to balance the budget.

phil.willon@latimes.com

joel.rubin@latimes.com

FAIR USE NOTICE. This
document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been
specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this
article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of
tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair
use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the
U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes
of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the
copyright owner.

 

Help build power for renters' rights: