Lack of affordable housing disproportionately affects people with HIV/AIDS

Wednesday, May 19, 2010
Roger Brigham
Edge

Nearly three decades into the AIDS epidemic, a lack
of affordable housing for those who live with the virus leaves them
increasingly vulnerable as cities struggle to balance their budgets.

In
Atlanta, wheelchair-bound AIDS activist Patrick Ford became homeless
when a friend with whom he was living moved away and he could not find
affordable housing. New York City Mayor Michael Bloomberg has proposed
slashing the AIDS housing funding municipal law mandates. And in San
Francisco, where the phrase "affordable housing" is a permanent
oxymoron, those with HIV/AIDS on government assistance often cannot
qualify for what housing there is, and they face rampant homophobia
from staff and fellow city shelter residents.

Advocates and
experts told EDGE a general shortage of affordable housing in municipal
areas, a decrease in government funds and services in general-and AIDS
services in particular-and in many cases what they describe as a
hypocritical lack of advocacy for housing by LGBT and HIV/AIDS service
organizations more concerned about addressing other agendas have
contributed to this crisis.

"The housing situation for people
with AIDS in San Francisco is criminal -- absolutely criminal," said
Brian Basinger, director of the AIDS Housing Alliance/SF.
"When you ask LGTB organizations to stand up for people’s housing
rights, they are silent. They say, ’Oh, we don’t take positions on
public policy. But they will be out there working for marriage rights
or stroking for ENDA [the Employment Non-Discrimination Act.]"

Proposed budget cuts anger New York activists

David Thorpe, a spokesperson for the New York-based Housing Works, agreed.

"Homelessness
is on the rise here in New York City, and that inevitably means
trouble, because the rate of HIV infection is much higher in homeless
shelters than in the general population," he said. "(City) HIV/AIDS
Services Administration already has more than they can handle."

Bloomberg’s
proposed budget would cut $4.8 million for AIDS caseworkers, $1.8
million in supportive housing contracts, $900,000 in HIV prevention
programs, and $500,000 in hot meal service. This comes after Bloomberg
asked New York Gov. David Paterson in April to veto a bill that would
limit the percentage of income HASA [HIV/AIDS Service Administration]
clients spent on rent to 30 percent.

Housing Works charges
Bloomberg’s proposal to cut 248 case managers violates Local Law 49. In
a press conference on the steps of City Hall on Tuesday, May 18,
attorney Armen H. Merjian said Housing Works would sue the city of the
HASA cuts are made.

"HASA cuts are simply illegal," added Council Member Annabel Palma [D-Bronx] "HASA can’t face 248 less case managers."

Under Local Law 49, New York City is required to provide housing for persons within 24 hours of need in emergency.

"The
problem is that some people with AIDS spend a long time in emergency
housing--months, or even years," said Kristin Goodwin, director of New
York City Policy and Organizing for Housing Works. "Emergency housing
was never intended to be, nor should it be, a permanent solution. HASA
itself actually considers these folks ’homeless’ according to housing
eligibility for certain programs, so it obviously should not be where
someone lives for longer than absolutely necessary. Currently there are
over 900 people in HASA’s emergency housing, most living in commercial
single-room occupancy units (SROs). Most are still waiting to
permanently placed into medically-appropriate housing."

But as
with many cities, New York does not recognize HIV infection as the
trigger to initiate city services. Individuals must have two
opportunistic infections or a T-cell count below 200 to qualify.

"Unfortunately,
being HIV positive is not enough to get housing assistance," said
Thorpe. "We’re trying to get the state to re-define how they define HIV
diseases. It’s counterproductive to ask people to get sick before they
can get medications, because the benefits are what keep them healthy."

What constitutes affordable housing?

Nancy Bernstine, executive director of the National AIDS Housing Coalition, stressed a lack of affordable housing remains an issue across the country-and the barometer under which officials define it.

"The
telling thing is there is not one county in the entire country where a
person earning the minimum wage can afford an apartment," Bernstine
said.

Analysits say individuals can be expected to use 30
percent of their incomes for housing, with the remaining 70 percent
going to other living expenses other expenses. Under that formula,
according to the National Low Income Housing Coalition, an individual
living in New York or California would need to hold down more than
three 40-hour a week minimum wage jobs to be able to afford basic
housing.

Bernstine said the national coalition was currently
advocating for additional funding, ensuring the administration focus on
housing in formulating its AIDS strategy, and that White funding not
directed toward medical services be used for HIV housing.

"We
think that as a result of some of these advocacy efforts, we’ve
mollified what might have been a really horrible situation with people
losing their housing money," Bernstine said.

The Centers for
Disease Control and Prevention estimates 56,300 Americans are infected
with HIV annually and 1.2 million people in this country live with HIV.
A disproportionate number of those individuals have low or no income,
yet localized programs funded by the federal Housing Opportunities for
Persons program served only 56,000 household in 2009.

San Francisco activists detail lack of HIV/AIDS-specific housing

Basinger
said a San Francisco study of people with HIV/AIDS who have access to
city services found less than 40 percent had stable housing.

"Sixty
percent of us are homeless," Basinger said as she pointed to 2007
statistics showed that 10 percent of the total population had AIDS.
"That’s not people who are infected -- that’s full blown AIDS."

San
Francisco Mayor Gavin Newsom has pledged to tackle the homeless
situation in San Francisco with "care, not cash." The AIDS Housing
Alliance is one organization in the city that continues to address the
problem, but Basinger said city bureaucracy continues to provide
barriers.

"They are little itty bitty things that drive me
crazy," he said. "San Francisco is a service rich and housing poor
town. That’s because nobody is out there other than us advocating for
more housing for people with AIDS. There is a tremendous lack of
affordable housing. We absolutely have to have a champion at the board
of supervisors who has this cause as a top concern and who is strong in
their advocacy."

The remedy for stretched resources does not
always mean asking for more money, but using existing funding
differently. Basinger suggested overpaid executives of HIV/AIDS service
organizations "need to lose their jobs so we can use those funds for
other things."

"We need to take steps to change the paradigm
where we re-prioritize the resources that we already have--more housing
even if that means less services," he said.

Another solution he
proposes is to require HIV/AIDS service organizations to offer at least
51 percent of their staff positions to people with the virus.

"That way folks can have the income that allows them to have a roof over their heads," said Basinger.

California Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger cut monthly disability payments six times in the last year with few protests.

"The
people with AIDS have fallen below the minimum threshold," said
Basinger. "Now those people don’t even have enough money to apply for
the ’affordable’ housing."

Basinger added studies showed half
the homeless people in San Francisco with AIDS lost their residences
because of tenants moving in or evicting them under the state Ellis
Act, which allows evictions for the purposes of changing property use.
He said LGBT activists should work to strengthen tenants rights as a
cost effective way to fight the loss of low income housing.

"People
with AIDS are getting kicked out of their homes in the Castro because
of real estate speculators," added Basinger. "The problem is poverty
and the lack of affordable housing and all of the things that go with
it. Rent control is the largest anti poverty program in San Francisco.
It doesn’t cost a penny to the city. But try to get those people to do
anything to expand rent control and they are hostile. They keep
electing officials and policy positions that are undermining rent
control."



FAIR USE NOTICE. This
document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been
specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this
article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of
tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair
use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the
U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes
of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the
copyright owner.

Help build power for renters' rights: