Landlord Crybabies <i>Forced</i> To Ellis Because Landlording Became So Unpleasant

Sunday, May 9, 2010
Dave Crow
Crow & Rose Tenant Rights Blog


Last month the San Francisco Business Times published a
reprehensible editorial, “Tenant
activists exacerbate rental housing crisis
.” They were reacting to
the  occupation of
an empty building in the Mission
by Homes Not Jails on April 4.

This is what riled me up: “Aided by reliable mouthpieces on the board
of supervisors, they’ve helped make it so unpleasant over the years to
be a landlord in San Francisco that owners of several hundred rental
units each year invoke a nuclear option known as the Ellis Act and
detonate their rental business by evicting all their tenants.”

I’m sorry, but if being a landlord is so unpleasant, why don’t you
just sell your building without evicting the tenants?

Essentially that was the question the California Supreme Court posed
in Nash
v. City of Santa Monica
in 1984. “Nash was a 17-year-old
student when, approximately a year before the rent and demolition
controls were enacted, his mother obtained on his behalf a $260,000
apartment building in Santa Monica. He soon became disenchanted,
however, with operating rental housing: ‘There is only one thing I
want to do, and that is to evict the group of ingrates inhabiting my
units, tear down the building, and hold on to the land until I can sell
it at a price which will not mean a ruinous loss on my investment.’”

The Court ruled that there was nothing unconstitutional about rent
control or demolition control that protected tenants. They reasoned that
Nash was getting a fair return on his “investment” and that he could
sell the building if he wanted to get out of the landlord business.

That’s when the landlord lobby really started to scream. In 1985 they
persuaded their friends in the legislature to pass the so-called Ellis
Act to supersede the ruling in Nash to allow landlords to evict
all their tenants before they exited the landlord business. The rest is
history.

As we
all know now, for the last decade, the Ellis Act has been used by
speculators who enter the landlord business for five minutes to evict
long-term tenants, seniors and the disabled in order to sell units as
TICs (tenancies in common.)
We also know that those speculators were
fueled by a flood of monopoly money from banking geniuses who were
later bailed out by taxpayers.

Now the bubble has burst and (big surprise) Ellis
evictions dropped 78% in the last year
in San Francisco. The Business
Times
editorial noted this, “But in whatever number, they [Ellis
evictions] are a symptom of the dysfunction in the San Francisco rental
market and not a cause. Basically, there’s little incentive to remain a
landlord in San Francisco — and every incentive to try to get yourself
out.” Of course most of the landlords who used Ellis evictions were
never in the landlord business and those who were didn’t get out until
they saw an opportunity for obscene profit.

If the  Business Times cannot recognize that vacant
buildings are not a cause of dysfunction in the rental market,
what can they see? Not much. The editorial also excuses scofflaw
landlords because, “[Rent control] contribute[s] to blight by
discouraging landlords from maintaining and upgrading their units.” They
misstate the law claiming, “That the owner of the property would in
fact be breaking the law by offering it again for rent was apparently
lost on the protesters.” In fact, the landlord can re-rent but he would
be required to offer the unit to the original renter at the
rent-controlled price.

That’s the point. Landlords start to cry like babies when they can’t
get exactly what they want, when they want it. “Unpleasant” translates
to “I can’t get as rich as I want to as fast as I want to” and “I don’t
want to spend the money to maintain my building.” Sob, sob. They also
clinch their fists and threaten, “But given that the owner of property
ultimately controls whether it remains on the rental market at all,
learning at the least to live with them [landlords with their power to
Ellis evict at will] would be in everyone’s interests — including, most
notably, their [tenant activists] own.”

Unfortunately that threat will remain bone-chilling real until the
Ellis Act is either repealed or amended to require that landlords
actually be in the business for five or so years until they can get out.
And occupying vacant buildings is a laudable method to remind us that,
like Jerome Nash, landlords will go to any extreme, including refusing
to re-rent units in vacant buildings, to force tenants to bend to their
will.

FAIR USE NOTICE. This
document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been
specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this
article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of
tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair
use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the
U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes
of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the
copyright owner.

Help build power for renters' rights: