Landlord Drops Eviction Proceeding Over Noise Complaints against Family with Autistic Child

Wednesday, October 23, 2013
Jake Edmiston
Ottawa Citizen

A Centretown landlord is no longer pursuing “eviction proceedings” against the family of a child with autism after noise complaints about the boy stopped amid threats of a human rights complaint.

Earlier this month, John From and his wife, Kerri Oastler, were given seven days to fix the “running, jumping and screaming” coming from their new townhouse condo or face eviction on Oct. 30.

But this week, the owner and property manager of the second-level unit told the couple that no noise complaints were filed during the seven-day period, meaning the formal notice “is now void.”

“We are committed to co-operating with you and working together to reach a resolution to this situation,” reads a Tuesday email from From’s landlord, Gabby Horan, provided by the family.

The couple and their landlord were planning to meet to discuss improved “sound baffling” options.

From, who has previously stated he no longer wished to live in a “hostile environment,” said he was relieved by the development but hoped to have written assurance that “I’m not going to be constantly worried about my son making too much noise.”

His eight-year-old son Logan is a “climber and a jumper,” From said.

The couple uses behaviour modification techniques to quell the disruptions, including a small, specialty trampoline. In the seven days they were given to stop the noise, From said, he and his wife “continued to be responsible parents, staying on top of his jumping.” The couple also moved Logan’s bed away from the wall they share with an adjacent neighbour, so the boy could not drum his feet against it.

In the two weeks after they moved into the unit late last month, neighbours below and beside the unit complained about noise that sounded like “a 50-pound box being dropped repeatedly” during the hours that the boy was at home and awake.

But the couple said they’ve been encouraged by residents in the condo as of late, with one woman delivering muffins over the Thanksgiving weekend.

After news reports of the situation, the previous tenant of the unit contacted the couple to inform them that in seven years, he consistently received similar noise complaints from the downstairs neighbour.

In an interview Wednesday, Dave Harris said complaints about him started in 2005, shortly after he moved into the unit, which has wooden joists with no concrete in the floor. He said a neighbour informed him that she suffered from migraines and noise transference was disturbing her.

“It was seven years of anxiety,” Harris said.

Harris provided a January email from Horan in which the landlord wrote that the neighbour had been “extremely sensitive to any and all sounds.”

Had they known of the history, From said, he and his family would have never moved in.

Horan would not comment on the story Wednesday.

Before delivering the “notice to terminate tenancy early” to From on Oct. 9, Horan, of Cityview Rental Services and J. van Husen Holdings, told the tenants in an email that “my hands are tied. The condo property management has formally asked me to begin eviction proceedings.”

In emails to his landlord this month, From threatened to file a human rights complaint, claiming the Human Rights Code provides that the normal noise associated with a child with autism should not lead to denial of housing.

A statement earlier this month said Horan was unaware of the extent of the boy’s disability and was committed to finding a solution that would allow the family to stay.

Since no complaints were filed during the seven-day period, the landlord will not apply to the Landlords and Tenants Board to evict the tenants, according to an email chain provided by the couple. From has suggested moving to a vacant ground-floor unit in row of townhouses at Bay and Lisgar streets, but the landlord said it is not viable because she only owns the single unit in the complex.

The condominium property management company and condo board were unavailable for comment Thursday. The two neighbours who allegedly filed complaints also could not be reached.

FAIR USE NOTICE. Tenants Together is not the author of this article and the posting of this document does not imply any endorsement of the content by Tenants Together. This document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the copyright owner. 

Help build power for renters' rights: