Landlord to Pay $1 Million Over Treatment of Tenants

Wednesday, February 10, 2010
CHRISTINE HAUGHNEY
New York Times

Attorney General Andrew M. Cuomo
said Thursday that he had reached a $1 million settlement with a large
New York City property owner that became a lightning rod for complaints
about landlords’ treatment of tenants in rent-regulated apartments.

Under the settlement,
the landlord, Vantage Properties, must stop harassing tenants in its
9,500 apartments in Queens and Manhattan with “baseless legal notices”
and “frivolous housing court evictions,” according to a statement from
Mr. Cuomo.

The attorney general’s office, which started its investigation in the
summer of 2008, found that in Vantage’s search for profits, it tried to
force tenants out of apartments so it could renovate them and raise
rents. Last month Mr. Cuomo said he intended to sue Vantage.
The settlement said that over two years Vantage filed more than 1,000
notices against tenants and took a “significant number” to housing
court.

Many residents complained that they had been falsely accused of not
paying rent or of living elsewhere, Mr. Cuomo said. In many cases,
Vantage filed cases based on “unreliable sources of information” when
the tenant had every legal right to live there.

Of the $1 million, $750,000 has been earmarked for residents “who can
demonstrate that they unjustly vacated their apartments or were subject
to frivolous housing court proceedings,” the settlement says. Nonprofit
groups that help tenants will receive $250,000 and whatever is left of
the $750,000 after tenants are paid. It is unclear how much individual
tenants will receive and which nonprofit groups will benefit from the
ruling.

“Today’s agreement with Vantage not only preserves the rent-regulated
apartments owned by them,” Mr. Cuomo said in the statement, “but also
sends a strong message that my office will continue to protect tenants
and bring unscrupulous landlords to justice.”

Executives of Vantage, which bought the properties in 2006, said they welcomed the settlement
because it gave them a clearer definition of some of the boundaries in
managing affordable housing, according to Orin Snyder, a lawyer for
Vantage.

“This is a sector that for decades has been filled with tension and
uncertainty about the rules between landlords and tenants,” he said.
“What we have now is really an unprecedented set of guidelines, ground
rules, that govern the landlord-tenant relationship, and Vantage is and
has been enthusiastic.”

Affordable housing advocates praised the outcome because they said it
sent a warning to other landlords that bought apartments at the peak of
the real estate boom and sought profits by pressuring lower-paying
renters to leave and replacing them with higher-paying tenants.

“It establishes a precedent that this predatory equity model is a
threat to affordable housing and is illegal when it crosses the line,”
said Robert McCreanor, director of legal services for the Catholic Migration Office. “Unfortunately, there’s a substantial percentage of affordable housing stock affected by this.”

He said that his group, along with other legal services groups and
nonprofit agencies, represented hundreds of Vantage tenants who were
subject to “a barrage of baseless legal proceedings” since 2006.

He pointed to Ricardo Aguaiza,
a 47-year-old Manhattan doorman who moved into his apartment building
in November 1993. Mr. Aguaiza said he had no problems for 14 years.
Then in June 2007, after Vantage bought the building, he started to
receive notices that he had not paid his rent, even though he regularly
paid with money orders.

Mr. McCreanor said Mr. Aguaiza, who lives in a one-bedroom apartment
with his wife and 7-year-old son, was taken to court three times in
eight months on baseless lawsuits. In one case, Vantage claimed he did
not live in his apartment.

On Thursday, Mr. Aguaiza welcomed the news.

“I wait for this decision,” he said. I’m very, very happy.”

FAIR USE NOTICE. This document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.   

Help build power for renters' rights: