Landlords Balk at Rental Registration Policy

Tuesday, June 15, 2010
Dan O'Brien
Business Journal Daily

YOUNGSTOWN, Ohio -- Landlords that own multiple housing units for rent
already pay a high price to do business in the city, say area real
estate investors.

Take, for example, the house at 717 East
Pasadena on the city's South Side, says owner Sherry DeMar, president
of DeMar Realty, Inc. and president of The Mahoning Valley Real Estate
Investors Association.

"We just finished rehabbing this house on Friday," she said. "We've
pumped in about $7,000, and I'll never see return on that from this
property."

The house has remained vacant since February and
it's been broken into twice. Thieves the first time entered through the
back door and absconded with the copper plumbing. Thieves the second
time broke down the front door, but left empty handed since the coveted
copper pipes had already been stolen.

On Monday, DeMar was
putting the finishing touches on the improvements so renters could move
in later that day. These renovations include a new roof, new pipes, new
carpeting and a new paint job for the entire interior.

"I've replaced pipes on all of my properties in the city -- all of them," DeMar says.

The
Real Estate Investors' group wants to quash an ordinance passed by City
Council that requires landlords to pay a $20 fee annually on each
rental unit they own. The fees would be used by the city to pay for a
stepped-up inspection program to ensure that landlords comply with
proper codes within a specified period of time.

However, DeMar
said that landlords are hesitant to make these interior improvements --
some of which could cost thousands of dollars -- until the house is
rented and occupied. Pumping in money on new renovations in a vacant
unit is too risky because of crime.

"It's not the $20 fee,"
DeMar explained. Rather, she said the ordinance forces landlords to
pump a significant amount of money into vacant properties that are
likely to be broken into or vandalized. Should these improvements not
be made by a certain period of time, the landlord could be fined
another $50 for a second inspection, and up to $100 for a third.

DeMar
said the legislation unfairly targets landlords such as herself who
work hard to maintain their rental units. "The real problem is
foreclosures, tax lien sales and people who just walk away from their
properties -- not landlords," she emphasized.

Vacant, decrepit
houses not only affect the neighborhood, they dramatically impact the
value and investment landlords such as DeMar have made over the course
of their business.

"I own between 90 and 100 rental
properties," DeMar said. "I've probably invested $1 million over the
last 30 years, so I have a lot at stake. I want to protect my
investment."

Instead of targeting landlords, DeMar said a
comprehensive strategy is needed that would address all aspects of
neighborhood blight.

True, there are landlords who don't make
the proper investments on behalf of their tenants and they should be
held accountable, she said.

But DeMar argued that the main
source of blight in the community is foreclosure, unemployment,
unresolved probate estates, and vacancies caused by owners walking away
from their properties, resulting in negotiated tax lien sales. A
strategy developed around cooperation between business and local
government is more appropriate. "It's a waste of time targeting the
good landlords," she noted.

DeMar said the Real Estate Investors
Association plans to go to court an fight the legislation, which was
passed by City Council in 1999.

"We successfully defeated the
same bill in 1999," DeMar said. The national chapter of the landlords'
organization has defeated similar ordinances in other cities, she
added.

Youngstown Community Development Director Bill
D'Avignon said the ordinance has been upheld as constitutional. But the
city couldn't enact the program until additional monies were made
available -- this time through the $2.5 million in federal government
neighborhood stabilization funds that the city received in 2008.

D'Avignon
said the guidelines mailed to rental-property owners aren't onerous and
are "pretty basic" improvements such as handrails, smoke alarms and
secured steps. "We don't want this to be characterized as placing a
burden on landlords. Our criteria is less stringent than Section 8
criteria," he said. "We're not requiring them to do major repairs."

Inspections
could begin as early as the end of July, D'Avignon said. The first
round of inspections would be selected based on the number of
registrations in a given area. Should a cluster of registrations come
from the Brownlee Woods neighborhood, for example, that group of
properties would be inspected first. Inspections of other groupings in
specific neighborhoods would follow.

D'Avignon said that he
understands some of the group's concerns, and city officials plan to
meet with representatives of the 70-member organization to discuss how
the program could be modified.

His office also is drafting
another component of a neighborhood plan that calls for registration of
vacant properties in the city.

Even so, those proposals are still unacceptable to the Real Estate Investors group.

"As investors, we have a lot at stake," DeMar said. "We just think this is very wrong."


FAIR USE NOTICE. This
document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been
specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this
article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of
tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair
use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the
U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes
of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the
copyright owner.

Help build power for renters' rights: