With rents skyrocketing throughout the Bay Area and numerous low-income residents faced with evictions and no place to go, the San Mateo City Council is considering ways to address the region’s affordable housing crisis.
While city officials frequently hear from people facing evictions as new landlords take over or residences are remodeled, Councilman David Lim said he’s tired of getting the silent treatment from certain property owners.
Joined by tearful residents whose lives are being uprooted, the City Council met Monday to discuss how it can embark on a fact-finding mission by bringing all stakeholders to the table.
One probing question bothering the council: Are certain landlords raising rents to support needed building improvements or simply because they can?
Somewhat controversial even among his fellow councilmembers, Lim suggested those who don’t comply with requests for information be subpoenaed and required to testify under oath in front of the council — an ability San Mateo holds as a charter city.
“This issue has reached crisis proportions. The one part I would emphasize is I don’t think this is just a policy issue in the abstract, it’s nothing less than an assault on our middle class,” Councilman David Lim said. “This is affecting the heart and soul of our community. We are in danger of losing who we are as a community, we are in danger of losing our middle class workers, our teachers, our nurses our police officers.”
The issue was broached by Mayor Maureen Freschet with the council concurring it couldn’t wait for the San Mateo County Board of Supervisors to conduct its own study through a Blue Ribbon Task Force on Housing.
“I know that we all share a sense of urgency to ease the plight of our seniors, families and low income [individuals],” Freschet said. “We arrive at the best solutions when we thoroughly understand the problem, bring all of the stakeholders together. … And I mean every member of the community that has a vested interest.”
The council heard from the public, including Barbara O’Neil, a Bowditch Middle School teacher who said she may have to stop contributing to her pension due to a rent increase and is concerned landlords are taking advantage of an inflated market.
Jose Navarrete tearfully said his family was recently served an eviction notice and he now fears they may have to move out of state due to the high cost of living.
The council also heard from Daniel Lee, a property owner who said landlord’s views must be considered as well.
“We need to build affordable housing, not punish somebody like myself or the small property, mom and pop, owner. I understand that some people are bleeding, if you’re going to punish small property owners, we will be bleeding too. You are responsible to help everybody,” Lee said.
The council will schedule public hearings, likely beginning in September, while hoping representatives from all stakeholder groups will lend input as city officials consider how to improve housing opportunities and tend to what is a regional issue.
With rent having increased nearly 50 percent over the last four years and a one-bedroom apartment in San Mateo County averaging about $2,500 per month, the city needs to consider short-term and long-term solutions, said Josh Hugg, program manager at the Housing Leadership Council of San Mateo County.
While no specifics have been solidified — which could range from renter protections to building more housing — the council ultimately seeks to start by gathering more information.
Lim and Councilman Joe Goethals, both attorneys, said if inviting developers or landowners to participate fails, the city could use its authority to subpoena.
Deputy Mayor Jack Matthews said he was extremely opposed to the council subpoenaing individuals, citing what happened when people were summoned during the battle two years ago over a 7-Eleven moving into a residential neighborhood.
“It was inappropriate, it was grossly inappropriate. It was demeaning, it was not called for. I don’t think this council should do that ever again. If you want to work with property owners … you don’t call them in for a public hearing under oath to testify that they’re not crooks,” Matthews said. “We need to start off with a nice invitation.”
Lim quickly assured it wasn’t intended as a witch-hunt and finding an amicable resolution is preferred. However, Lim said it’s not fair to have the market inflated at the community’s expense.
“What we’re seeing is just unmitigated speculation, [people] who know nothing about being a true landlord or property owner and I realize they’re in the minority. But they’re starting to swoop up property. … We cannot let these bad apples ruin the entire barrel and destroy our communities,” Lim said. “I believe they have a right to own property and profit off of it. But I don’t believe they have a right to gouge our middle class.”
Having been told repeated requests to speak with certain landlords have been ignored, Lim said the subpoena process is a tool that should remain in the council’s back pocket.
“That is how a public agency gathers information,” Lim said. “But the thought of making them (property owners) slightly uncomfortable … to me is outweighed, as they are evicting our residents. They are evicting our friends. So if they feel a little bad about having to come here after ignoring our phone calls, then too bad.”
Ultimately, the council agreed to hosting public hearings, encouraging all stakeholders to participate and gathering the facts needed to identify the problem.
These are “regular people, teachers, nurses, insurance people, people who have lived places for years here in San Mateo, for a decade or two, who are part of who we are in San Mateo. And the circumstances may differ from building to building, landlord to landlord, but we don’t know, and we won’t know unless we get some people together,” said Councilman Rick Bonilla. “Facts are what we need right now, so we can start to make a difference for the people who live here.”
FAIR USE NOTICE. Tenants Together is not the author of this article and the posting of this document does not imply any endorsement of the content by Tenants Together. This document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.