In these tough economic times, nothing is more important than
continued public investment to stimulate growth, create jobs, and
provide greater stability for communities. In California, we are lucky
to have redevelopment agencies to help us meet this need at the local
level. These unique agencies provide municipalities with the necessary
funding structure to invest local property tax revenues directly in
their communities.
Governor Jerry Brown’s proposal to eliminate redevelopment agencies
has shocked local government officials and left a lot of us wondering
how serious he is about his campaign pledge to “get California working
again.” Across the state, local plans for affordable housing projects,
cleanup of blighted areas, infrastructure improvements, and business
development efforts now hang in the balance.
Brown and other critics claim that redevelopment agencies
unnecessarily take money that should be spent on other programs and
services. This dismissive attitude is not only frustrating to those on
the front lines of community development work, it is a concerning
indication that the Brown Administration may not fully understand the
important role public investment plays in the health of local economies
and the communities that depend on them.
As a councilmember for the City of Arcata, I fear what the theft of
local redevelopment monies could mean for my community and for hundreds
of others. City plans for affordable senior housing, transitional
housing for the homeless, and streetscape improvements in an underserved
part of Arcata are among the projects that could be impacted if Brown’s
plan goes through. Other communities throughout the state are in the
same boat, waiting to find out whether they will have to delay, scale
back or scrap projects.
Like other socially conscious communities, Arcata has gone above and
beyond state requirements in our efforts to expand housing opportunities
for residents of modest means. Using redevelopment funds, our staff
works with local developers and nonprofits to create affordable housing,
both for renters and first-time homebuyers. These are new housing
opportunities and construction jobs that would not exist without
financial and planning assistance from local government.
Unfortunately, redevelopment has not been such a positive experience
for all communities. Some redevelopment agencies have wasted public
money, helping to bankroll luxury housing and commercial developments
that are incompatible with existing neighborhoods. Even worse,
redevelopment efforts have spurred gentrification in some areas,
displacing low income people and minority populations.
This complicated history makes redevelopment an easy target for
critics on both the right and the left, as well as politicians seeking
to balance the state budget at all costs. Yet even the most valid
criticisms fail to provide a basis for the argument that redevelopment
is inherently wasteful or useless. Most problems can be traced back to
the management practices and policy decisions of certain redevelopment
agencies. Such problems could be addressed by carefully reforming the
program to minimize waste and abuse, but doing away with it entirely
would be a mistake.
Evidence that redevelopment works is available and compelling. In
2006-2007 alone, redevelopment activities in California generated $40.8
billion in economic activity and more than 304,000 new jobs.
Redevelopment also provides environmental and social benefits. It
reduces sprawl by focusing development in already urbanized areas and
sets aside 20% of agency-generated property tax funds for affordable
housing. Redevelopment agencies have helped to build or rehabilitate
98,000 affordable housing units since 1993.
Voters have repeatedly approved measures to keep local funds local.
In November of last year, Californians passed Proposition 22, which
protects funding for redevelopment agencies and other local government
projects and services. Even if the legislature agrees to Brown’s plan,
Proposition 22 may put a stop to it, although legal opinions vary.
Brown has been more honest about his approach to the budget than his
predecessor was, but unfortunately his general methodology is very
similar. Rather than having the courage to significantly cut
California’s bloated prison system, proposing bold revenue measures
aimed at the wealthy, or pursuing creative ideas like a government-run
bank to keep money from leaving the state, Brown is seeking to balance
the budget at the expense of vital programs that help working families
and struggling communities survive.
This, of course, is the problem with the idea that austerity is the
path to stability. The Brown Administration and the legislature should
tread carefully when cutting programs that are important for the
long-term health and prosperity of the state. Redevelopment is only one
of these programs, but it deserves to be recognized as such and
preserved.
FAIR USE NOTICE. This
document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been
specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this
article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of
tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair
use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the
U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes
of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the
copyright owner.