Manufacturing Suburban Blight: How City Officials are Mischaracterizing Parkmerced to Justify its Demolition

Thursday, February 17, 2011
Dean Preston
BeyondChron

The Planning Commission has approved the controversial Parkmerced
redevelopment plan by a 4-3 vote. The plan directly violates city
policy regarding the demolition of sound rental housing. To justify the
demolitions, supporters of the project are using a playbook that is
familiar to residents of neighborhoods like the Western Addition and
other redevelopment zones. From the start, advocates of the project
have mischaracterized the existing homes and community at Parkmerced in
an effort to pave the way for demolition.

Listening to the developer, City staff, SFHAC’s Tim
Colen, and Planning Commissioners Ron Miguel and Gwyneth Borden, one
would think that Parkmerced’s rent controlled homes were blighted,
outdated, and so hopeless that the only logical choice is to demolish
rather than renovate them. Add to that the repeated reference to
Parkmerced as “suburban” and a “gated community,” and the picture has
been painted that San Franciscans should embrace the demolition of these
supposedly dilapidated homes that really aren’t part of San Francisco
anyway.

Physical Condition of the Existing Units

Tim Colen, head of the developer’s group SFHAC, maintains that “the
inexpensive post war low rise buildings are at the end of their useful
lives. We ask what aspect of this declining underutilized asset demands
your protection?”

Planning Commissioner Borden echoed the theme, claiming that the current
buildings are “in a state where you are putting band aids on them.”
“Even if you didn’t demolish, the people would have to move out of those
units because they are being renovated. It would require similar
relocation.” “It’s not as efficient to do band aids on existing,
not-as-well-built structures when you could put in new structures to
plan for the future.”

What is she basing this on? Has anyone done a study of what it would
take to renovate, rather than demolish, the garden apartments? No, and
that is the problem. Instead of complying with its own policy to
require a Soundness Report on proposed demolition and to discourage
demolitions, the Commission is simply accepting the mischaracterization
of Parkmerced by developers and city officials whose zeal for
development has eclipsed objective analysis.

San Francisco has a policy against demolishing sound rental housing, a
policy that has been violated by the Planning Commission in approving
this project. As part of the policy, the Planning Commission is
supposed to require a Soundness Report before any housing can be
demolished. No such report was provided on the Parkmerced homes slated
for demolition.

The Suburbs Strategy

From the start, City staff and the developer have referred to Parkmerced
as being suburban. I’m sure it is not lost on the project’s advocates
that the “suburbs” are not especially popular in San Francisco, a city
whose residents pride themselves on being urban and, in many respects,
anti-suburban.

According to Planning Commissioner Miguel, “This was and is San
Francisco suburbia.” “It’s as close to San Francisco has to a gated
community.”

In fact, Parkmerced is among the least suburban places on this side of
the City. There are highrise apartment buildings in Parkmerced,
something more commonly found in New York City than the suburbs.
(Interesting, Planning Commissioner Borden would like to see the
existing towers torn down: “I personally find them very unattractive and
wish they were the ones being demolished.” The towers house large
numbers of working class San Franciscans.)

All of the arguments being used against the current community at
Parkmerced could be applied to any 152-acre part of the west side of San
Francisco. Entire stretches of the outer Sunset, Ingleside and many
other neighborhoods are low density and filled with older housing with
deferred maintenance.

Imagine for a minute how this project would be received if the proposal
were to demolish over 1500 homes in the Outer Sunset, with promises of
20-30 years of construction. The project sponsor would be laughed out
of San Francisco.

There is a fundamental problem with a proposal to bulldoze an existing
residential community in the name of building new housing, especially
when the housing to be demolished is sound, rent-controlled housing.
Rather than addressing this problem, the project’s advocates are
mischaracterizing the existing community to make it seem worthy of
demolition. 

FAIR USE NOTICE. This
document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been
specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this
article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of
tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair
use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the
U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes
of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the
copyright owner.

Help build power for renters' rights: