Many Bay Area homeowners in real estate limbo

Sunday, July 25, 2010
Sue McAllister and Eve Mitchell
Mercury News

Tens of
thousands of Bay Area homeowners are trapped in a bizarre real estate
limbo, living in houses but no longer paying for them, waiting and
wondering if someone will help them — or throw them out.

Some are
victims of their own economic circumstances, unable to afford their
mortgage and expecting to lose their homes if they can't get a break
from their bank. Others are opportunists, choosing not to spend on a
house worth less than they owe. Instead, they can live rent-free until
their lender makes a move.

The limbo phenomenon is a radical
departure from previous real estate crashes, when there were far fewer
troubled loans and banks moved speedily on those who fell behind on
payments. Now many lenders simply can't keep up, and others appear reluctant to flood a weakened market with foreclosed homes.

It
all adds up to lingering instability for the Bay Area housing market,
as lenders slowly work through the backlog while homeowners endure
uncertainty that could last months or even years.

"It's bad all
the way around, for the neighbor, the community, the city, state,
nation," said Chris George, founder and CEO of CMG Mortgage, based in
San Ramon. "It's a continued indication that there are a lot of people
in trouble, particularly with their job situations."

Some homeowners say ignoring the mortgage is the only option they have.

"I stopped paying payments about 12 months ago," said Jeff Dunkin, who has twice sought to modify the loan on his
San Jose condo near Branham High School, and twice been denied. The
25-year-old construction worker has been employed only sporadically
since early 2009, and the unemployment checks he's collected are less
than half what he used to make. He knows some people may think living
mortgage-free sounds like a cushy deal. But that's not how it feels to
him.

"It's a lot of anxiety, a lot of stress," Dunkin said.

'On the edge'

Dunkin
has plenty of company. An estimated 40,283 homeowners across a
seven-county region spanning the South Bay, East Bay and the San
Francisco metro area were at least three months behind on their
mortgages but not yet in foreclosure as of April, according to
CoreLogic, which tracks mortgage performance data. That's about 4.5
percent of total mortgages in those areas, and a drastic increase from
0.25 percent in January 2007. In the San Jose metro area in January
2007, only 513 loans were more than 90 days late but not in
foreclosure. In April of this year there were 11,558. In the East Bay,
the total grew from 1,435 in early 2007 to 23,155 in April.

"We
have all these people who are really kind of on the edge," said Kevin
Stein, associate director of the California Reinvestment Coalition,
which fights for homeowners seeking loan modifications. "They're
anxious because they know they're behind, and they know all these
foreclosures are happening, and they know they could be next."

Dunkin,
for example, bought his two-bedroom condo in September 2007 for
$355,000. His fiancee and a roommate helped him pay the mortgage. But
in early 2009 the relationship with his fiancee crumbled, and
construction business in the valley plunged. As he scrimped to keep up
with his $2,486 monthly mortgage payments, he let his homeowner
association dues lapse, and the association sued him for the overdue
amount. He spent months paying it, but let his mortgage slide.

Dunkin
has yet to receive a notice of default, but he did receive letters this
spring from his lender about the possibility of a short sale — selling
the condo for less than he owes.

"I have not responded to that,"
he said. For now, he's sitting tight, saving money so he can rent a
place after foreclosure, which he considers nearly inevitable.

Nationwide
"roughly 3.5 million loans are in this limbo land, and are not
proceeding through very quickly. It could take years," said Sam Khater,
an economist with CoreLogic, which tracks mortgage performance. "I have
a feeling it's going to follow the path of unemployment and have a long
tail."

Part of the reason homeowners wind up staying in their
homes so long lies with the lending industry, Stein said. Many
companies are overloaded with people who are behind in payments, and
financial institutions are hesitant to process thousands of
foreclosures at once, because dumping all those properties on the
market would lower prices even more.

Khater said many lenders are
moving slowly because they hope the government will eventually step up
to help cover their losses. They also may be hoping an economic
recovery will allow many borrowers to catch up with their payments, but
"they're going to be waiting a while," he said.

Too slow, critics say

Critics
of loan modification programs say the housing market would be better
served if foreclosures moved more quickly, and that any resulting drop
in home prices is necessary to reset housing values to their pre-bubble
levels. Allowing delinquent homeowners to remain in their homes for
months or years means many of the owners will stop maintaining their
properties, which hurts their neighborhoods, and their own delinquency
may even encourage neighbors to default, prolonging the housing
market's pain, some say.

But Kenneth Rosen, chair of the Fisher
Center for Real Estate and Urban Economics at UC Berkeley, said banks
and the government "are being quite rational" in stretching out the
foreclosure process to avoid displacing homeowners and depressing
prices. He estimated that fewer than 15 percent of Bay Area
mortgage-holders who are 90 days overdue will get foreclosed on. "Most
people will catch up if they can get a job" or a loan modification, he
said. In the San Jose metro area, about 1.9 percent of mortgages were
in foreclosure in May, or about 4,900 loans, CoreLogic said. In the
East Bay, the rate was 2.5 percent, or about 10,090 loans. Bay Area
median home prices, though rebounding from lows reached last year, are
down 38 percent from their peak in July 2007.

Foreclosure is certainly taking longer than it used to.

According
to figures from ForeclosureRadar, for the California homes that were
foreclosed on in June, it took an average of 234 days from the "notice
of default" to the time the property was foreclosed. That's nearly
eight months on average — meaning some homeowners stay in their homes
much longer. In January 2007, the average time to foreclose was a
little more than four months. New state laws have built more time into
the foreclosure process, adding a requirement that lenders try to
contact borrowers in person before they are allowed to file a notice of
default, for example. Between legislated timelines, delays because
lenders are swamped with loan modification cases, and possible
strategic delays on the part of banks, many homeowners can stay put,
payment-free, for months on end.

Jobs aren't enough

There's
another unfamiliar wrinkle in delinquency trends now, said Hans
Johnson, who studies housing at the Public Policy Institute of
California. Any time unemployment rises, mortgage delinquency does too,
he said, just as it has in the past few years. But this time around
"even people who are employed are debating whether to keep paying the
mortgage because they're so far underwater," he said.

New
research from consulting firm Oliver Wyman found among borrowers
nationwide who defaulted in the first half of 2009 and remained in
default at the end of last year, 19 percent could have afforded to keep
paying. In June, mortgage financing company Fannie Mae said it would
punish such strategic defaulters by prohibiting them from getting a
Fannie-backed loan for seven years after their foreclosure, instead of
the typical five.

Pinole resident Charles Rinne, 63, is no longer
employed, but the retired postal worker says he could keep paying the
$1,300-a-month mortgage on his two-bedroom condominium. Instead, in
February, he stopped.

He considers defaulting a way to live more affordably after years of racking up debt.

Rinne
purchased his condo for $26,500 in 1973 and over the years refinanced
it several times. He said he ran up credit card debt and had some
dental surgery that was not fully covered by insurance.

"All of a
sudden late last year I just could not pay all the bills down to zero,"
he said. So he plans to file for bankruptcy, which will delay
foreclosure proceedings.

"That will allow me to save as much money as possible so I have the money to move," he said.

There's
no survey data on the demographics of nonpaying homeowners. But with
unemployment and recession affecting all socioeconomic levels, the
nonpaying phenomenon spans poor neighborhoods and rich ones, from tiny
condos to multimillion-dollar houses, said Jon Maddux, CEO of YouWalkAway.com. The company provides legal and financial advice to homeowners who've stopped paying.

Maddux
said defaulting is one way owners have of "lashing back" at lenders
when they've been frustrated by a lack of response or denial of their
loan modification. He rejects the notion that borrowers have an ethical
obligation to keep paying, saying mortgages are contracts that
specifically include language about what happens if the borrower stops
paying.

"We've made it so sacred to pay your mortgage, when it
shouldn't be that way. People shouldn't make their families suffer to
pay a mortgage that has an exit strategy in the contract," he said,
referring to foreclosure.

S.J. man fights back

San
Jose homeowner and Santa Clara Valley Transportation Authority bus
driver Darrell Thomas stopped paying his mortgage in late 2008 after he
lost overtime pay and while he was seeking a loan modification. He was
offered a trial modification in April last year, but as he was about to
start making the new payments, he learned he'd been foreclosed on. With
help from an attorney, he successfully sued to get back his triplex,
where he lives and has tenants.

But he's still pursuing legal
action against his lender, Wells Fargo, because he feels he was
improperly denied a loan modification under the Home Affordable
Modification Program. In May he began making mortgage payments for the
first time in almost a year and a half, as part of an agreement with
Wells Fargo to ensure the bank would not foreclose on him during
litigation.

While some might find relief in walking away from
their homes after prolonged struggle, "I don't look at it that way,"
said Thomas, 46. "That's home. I'm established, that's where my
family's at, and it's hard to start over."

With unemployment
still high in the Bay Area and home price stability not yet assured,
San Jose condo owner Jeff Dunkin puts his own situation — in default,
working infrequently and bracing to move out of his first home — in
perspective. "I'm just one person in a sea of problems," he said.

FAIR USE NOTICE. This
document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been
specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this
article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of
tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair
use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the
U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes
of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the
copyright owner.

 

Help build power for renters' rights: