Just a month after the Merced City Council approved an ordinance that supporters said offered better protection than federal laws for renters facing eviction after a foreclosure, the ordinance was brought back onto the agenda for consideration of repeal Monday night.
And ultimately tabled in a 6-0 vote, with Mayor Stan Thurston abstaining.
The repeal of the Just Cause for Eviction ordinance item was tabled until the California Fair Political Practices Commission gets back to the council on the matter of whether the new mayor, Thurston, had a potential conflict of interest. The commission assists state and local agencies in the development and enforcement of conflict-of-interest codes, according to its website.
Tenants Together, the San-Francisco-based nonprofit that defends California tenants' rights, had asked city attorney Greg Diaz, to look into potential conflicts of interest for Thurston and newly elected Councilman Tony Dossetti over residential properties late last week. It had asked Thurston and Dossetti to recuse themselves from voting based on a conflict of interest.
Thurston, who refused to recuse himself during the meeting, called the request a "tactic." Dossetti also declined to recuse himself.
Dossetti said he had one rental property in town.
"This ordinance will not materially affect me or my property. It will have no affect on me," he said.
Dean Preston, executive director for Tenants Together, said he thought the city did the right thing. "We believe there is a conflict of interest," Preston said, adding it was "wise" to get the opinion of the commission. He said the ordinance was "overwhelmingly" popular in the city.
Diaz said if a member of the City Council owned three or more residential properties, they could possibly have a conflict.
The city attorney decided the mayor, who has two rentals, a duplex and a family home, didn't have a conflict of interest based on the 1974 Political Reform Act. Moreover, Diaz said the mayor's two rentals don't make up a significant part of the market share of Merced's rentals. He said 57 percent of all housing units in Merced are rentals.
The City Council may have to wait up to 90 working days before the state gets back with a response, according to Diaz. "Realistically, that's six to nine months," he said.
As such, the ordinance will go into effect Wednesday.
The nonprofit has said the law spells out specific circumstances in which eviction is permitted, such as when a tenant fails to pay rent or if the owner wants to move into the property. Foreclosure is not a recognized reason for evicting tenants under the law. Fifteen other California cities already have laws against eviction of tenants because of foreclosure. Merced's was the first in the Valley.
Councilman Josh Pedrozo said he thought the council should send the matter to the Fair Political Practices Commission to get it checked out. He said the ordinance was probably something the council should have looked at three years ago when the foreclosures "were really, really bad."
"When you look at the numbers, you see foreclosures are going down," Pedrozo said before Monday night's meeting. "It's been dropping the last two quarters in the previous year," Pedrozo said. In past meetings, opponents such as Realtors have said it weakens neighborhood revitalization programs and creates confusion about terms of leases.
Councilwoman Mary-Michal Rawling said she wasn't surprised the ordinance was brought back, but was "disappointed." The ordinance was "one small thing the City Council can do to help alleviate the pain for the real people in Merced, the neighborhoods who are suffering from the blight of foreclosures. I think it's really time to close the chapter on this and move forward."
In a Sun-Star op-ed Monday, council members Rawling, Bill Blake and Noah Lor wrote, "Opponents recklessly claim that the law will allow tenants to live rent free, despite the fact that the law explicitly allows for eviction if the tenant does not pay rent or abuses the property."
FAIR
USE NOTICE. Tenants Together is not the author of this article and the posting
of this document does not imply any endorsement of the content by Tenants
Together. This document may contain copyrighted material the use of which
may not have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants
Together is making this article available on our website in an effort to
advance the understanding of tenant rights issues in California. We believe
that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided
for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this
copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you
must obtain permission from the copyright owner.