Despite a contentious meeting and fierce opposition, the Merced City Council approved the Just Cause for Eviction ordinance that its supporters say offers better protection than federal laws for renters facing eviction after a foreclosure.
Supporters say the ordinance lets tenants stay where they are despite foreclosures and short sales. Opponents say it weakens neighborhood revitalization programs and creates confusion about terms of leases.
In a 5-2 vote, the ordinance was approved, with Mayor Bill Spriggs and Councilwoman Michele Gabriault-Acosta opposing.
Opponents of the ordinance voiced concerns that it would affect neighborhoods, increase litigation and cause other harm.
Tenants Together, a San Francisco-based nonprofit that defends California tenants' rights, asked the council earlier this year to consider a Just Cause for Eviction ordinance as soon as possible to stabilize Merced's housing market.
The nonprofit has said the law spells out the specific circumstances where eviction is permitted, such as one in which the tenant fails to pay rent or where the owner wants to move into the property.
Foreclosure is not a recognized reason for evicting tenants under the law. Fifteen other California cities already have laws against eviction of tenants because of foreclosure.
But Rickey Wallace, a lawyer who spoke on behalf of the opponents Monday night, said one of his main concerns was how the ordinance would affect neighborhood revitalization. For example, if a person buys a property in a foreclosure sale and decides to upgrade it or add improvements, the tenants would still pay the same rent and have the same terms after revitalization.
"Are people who are going to purchase the properties going to upgrade the properties knowing after they do so their hands are going to be tied?" he asked. "Neighborhood revitalization is going to go down the tubes."
He said looking at the terms of the provision, the ordinance would increase the likelihood of litigation for frivolous lawsuits. And it probably "nullifies" the cash-for-keys program.
After a foreclosure happens, the new owner can go to the tenant and say 'if you can be out, we can give you the money that can assist you to relocate.' What the tenant does is weighs the right to stay in the property," he said. "You may take away the very rights of the tenants that protect them federally."
Council documents said a "rental agreement means an agreement, oral, written or implied, between a landlord and tenant for the use and/or occupancy of a residential rental unit." Wallace said he wasn't sure what an "implied agreement" meant.
However, supporters such as Dean Preston, executive director for Tenants Together, said the ordinance doesn't apply once a buyer buys the house and wants to live there.
"The whole idea that someone is going to buy the property and live there, it does not apply once a purchaser who wants to live there acquires it," Preston said at the meeting.
Moreover, he said federal law sets a minimum protection that applies across the country. Federal protections ensure a tenant 90 days' notice to vacate, he said. "It doesn't stop evictions and prolonged vacancies and blight," Preston said.
He said what the ordinance changes is that "unless there is a basis for an eviction, they can't serve that 90-day notice at all. They have to let the tenant continue renting."
Other opponents, including a number of local Realtors, were concerned with the implied and oral part of the ordinance. They also noted that with the ordinance in effect, when an owner buys a property, he doesn't know for how much or how long the lease is for.
They requested the council to hold off making a decision and refer it back to the city attorney with questions.
Former Merced Mayor Ellie Wooten, a Realtor, said cities in California have adopted the ordinance — and four of them are in trouble already. "Please consider if nothing else the numbers. This will create an increase of calls to the police department, increase in city sewer and water," she said, asking the council to consider giving the matter another couple of weeks.
Councilman Josh Pedrozo, who ultimately voted in favor of the ordinance, initially said he wanted to let the city attorney answer some of the questions raised by the opponents. He said since he voted in the majority of the decision, that allows him to still ask some questions to both sides of the issue.
"I have the ability to bring it back (to council)," he said Tuesday afternoon. "It's not a guarantee I will, I still think there are a lot of questions that need to be worked out."
"Having that option is something that will protect the city and protect the tenants," he said.
City attorney Greg Diaz said for the council, technically, any member of the legislative body can ask for an item to be brought back for discussion.
Gabriault-Acosta agreed, saying the attorney needed to look at the legal points brought up by the opponents.
But Councilman Bill Blake said the council had a "moral obligation" to protect the weakest. "It's about making money and it's about making money at the expense of our most vulnerable service, it's all about the money," he said.
Councilwoman Mary Michal-Rawling agreed, saying it should be the council's "first priority" to pass the ordinance.
This was the second reading for the ordinance. All ordinances take two readings. The second reading usually confirms the ordinance is in the form the council is comfortable with. But "if somebody pulls it off (for discussion), anything can happen," Diaz said.
Thirty days later, the ordinance is enacted.
FAIR
USE NOTICE. Tenants Together is not the author of this article and the posting
of this document does not imply any endorsement of the content by Tenants
Together. This document may contain copyrighted material the use of which
may not have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants
Together is making this article available on our website in an effort to
advance the understanding of tenant rights issues in California. We believe
that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided
for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this
copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you
must obtain permission from the copyright owner.