Mission District Housing Moratorium May Head for November Ballot

Monday, May 4, 2015
Cory Weinberg
San Francisco Business Times

Voters will be asked in November whether to halt market-rate housing construction in the Mission District if neighborhood activists have their way, the Business Times has learned.

Edwin Lindo of the San Francisco Latino Democratic Club said Monday that a coalition of affordable housing and progressive groups soon will submit a potential ballot measure to the city attorney that would delay market-rate housing projects in the Mission for up to 18 months.

They would then attempt to collect the roughly 9,400 signatures needed to qualify the measure for the ballot.

A draft of the ballot measure, obtained through a public records request by a neighborhood activist, showed that the moratorium would apply to projects larger than 20 units. The moratorium would apply to the entire neighborhood, not just the 24th Street area on the south side of the neighborhood considered a Latino cultural district, as had been previously floated by Supervisor David Campos.

“Our goal is not to stop all development. Our goal is to stop incredibly large development that focus exclusively on market-rate housing,” Lindo said. “We need a pause to ensure that if developers are going to build in our city they're going to figure out a way to build affordable housing, even if that could be cutting into their 15 to 20 percent profit margins.”

Many economists, urban policy groups like SPUR, and policymakers like Mayor Ed Lee and Scott Wiener have all said this kind of strategy will exacerbate the neighborhood’s problems. With a shriveling pool public dollars available to build affordable housing, the city has looked toward more market-rate development to pay for housing for low-income residents through inclusionary laws and fees.

“This is a misdirected idea that will have the exact opposite effect of what they intend,” said Gabriel Metcalf, president of SPUR, which advocates against limiting market-rate development. “It’s a venting of frustration but it won’t make the Mission more affordable.

The measure also is sure to draw intense fire from the real estate industry, especially because developers see the Mission as one of the most desirable places to build and is well-served by public transit.

A rush of market-rate development hasn’t yet happened, as just about 500 new units have been completed since 2010, according to city planning records.

But about another 500 units have been entitled or are under construction, bringing the neighborhood closer to the 1,700 units planned under the Eastern Neighborhoods rezoning plan from 2009. Some of those projects – like a 350-unit project next to the 16th Street BART station– have elicited heated opposition.

Projects in the pipeline will provide little affordable housing, according to data compiled by the Council of Community Housing Organizations, which is supporting the moratorium. Only 7.1 percent of the units entitled or under construction are slated to be affordable, though the city is also seeking developers to build housing for low-income residents on public sites.

During the moratorium, the Planning Department would study how to create a “neighborhood stabilization plan” that would boost affordable housing with new zoning rules and funding.

With a pause or a moratorium, it puts everyone on notice everyone from the city to the community activists to the market-rate developers that you have this limited time period to achieve solution to particular problem,” said Fernando Marti, co-director of CCHO.

While cities across California have tried market-rate housing moratoriums, Lindo said he believed this first attempt to do so at the ballot box. Lately, those moratorium efforts have mostly failed legislatively and sit mostly on shaky legal ground unless they prove to improve public health.

Campos, whose office has worked with activists on crafting a potential ballot measure and legislation, did not return requests for comment. Rumors have been percolating across City Hall that he would announce legislation or a ballot measure to help combat neighborhood displacement or block market-rate housing temporarily. Mission activists are planning a rally for affordable housing Friday at City Hall.

Joseph Smooke, Campos’ aide on housing issues, said he is “not ready to talk about anything right now, but we can talk later this week.”

Campos said at a town hall last month in the Mission that a moratorium should be an option. He also indicated that he would throw political capital behind anti-eviction efforts and more funding for the city to buy affordable housing sites.

“We need to make sure there are protections in place so things don’t get any worse than there are right now,” Campos said at a neighborhood town hall last month. “Because things are not working, how about putting a pause on this development until we’ve figured out a strategy? I don’t think it’s a radical idea at all, but it’s something we have to think about.”

He may have voters on his side, according to a February poll of likely voters by David Binder Associates. Sixty-five percent of the about 600 people polled said they’d support a ballot measure to halt “new project approvals in the Mission District for one year,” the San Francisco Examiner reported.

The election already has several controversial land-use issues, including one to curb AirBnB rentals. The fate of the Giants’ Mission Rock project, the Warriors’ Mission Bay arena and Kilroy Realty Corp.’s Flower Mart office project may also hit the ballot.

FAIR USE NOTICE. Tenants Together is not the author of this article and the posting of this document does not imply any endorsement of the content by Tenants Together. This document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the copyright owner. 

Help build power for renters' rights: