The city has received a petition
calling for the repeal of recent changes to its rent control ordinance,
and if the signatures are confirmed, the City Council will have to
approve the repeal or allow Capitola voters to decide.
A decade-long battle between the city and mobile home park owners
over rent control seemed to reach a crescendo March 18, when the council
voted to amend its ordinance, allowing for incremental rent increases
and total decontrol when a current resident leaves the park. The
decision was driven by a desire to reach a settlement agreement with Ron
Reed, the owner of Surf and Sand Mobile Home Park, who had filed two
lawsuits.
But the park's residents turned to one last recourse, filing a
petition challenging the amended ordinance. They went door-to-door
gathering signatures, and five-minutes before the 5 p.m. April 25
deadline they delivered the petition to repeal the changes to the city
clerk. The residents gathered 875 signatures, well over the 400
required.
"There wasn't much else we could do," said Surf and Sand resident
Shirley Hill, 80. "Either we get the petition signed and let the people
vote on whether they want this mobile home park to stay here or not, or
we file a lawsuit. We are mostly low-income people. We can't afford a
lawsuit."
Mayor Dennis Norton said there was "no chance" the council would
repeal the changes, and if the petition is verified, the issue will be
left up to Capitola's voters.
"This doesn't have any support except for some people in the mobile
home parks," Norton said. "The community doesn't support it, and if the
ordinance is repealed, we would be facing millions of dollars in
litigation costs again. Then we will have to start by cutting major
services that affect all our residents to find the money."
Councilman Sam Storey was not as quick to rule out a repeal, saying
the council would have to review the issue again once the petition is
verified.
Both the city clerk and city attorney will review the petition to
ensure signatures were gathered appropriately. Also, the county
elections department will check the signatures to make sure they come
from registered Capitola voters.
Reed, like many mobile home park owners, has argued that rent control
prevents him from getting a fair return on the property his family has
owned for more than five decades. The changes to the ordinance were
implemented to reach a settlement with Reed, whose two lawsuits
challenge the city's decision to deny an application to close the park
and the city's denial of an application to subdivide the mobile home
park.
Capitola has spent more than $1.22 million to defend its rent
stabilization ordinance against various lawsuits, City Manager Jamie
Goldstein said. About a third of the money for that defense has come
from a mobile home administrative service fee paid by Capitola's mobile
home park residents.
Reed was seeking $27 million in damages, a staggering figure for a
city that has an operating budget of $12.3 million for 2010-2011.
The Surf and Sand residents' attorney, William Constantine, said the
city is likely to win the two lawsuits based on previous court
decisions, and that the cost of going to trial is not as steep as the $1
million the city projects.
The majority of Surf and Sand residents pay between $260 and $400 in
monthly rent. Under the agreement, all rents would jump to at least $475
while low-income residents would be offered a minimum of a 34-year
lease and rents will go up based on the consumer price index each year.
Moderate income tenants would have their rents raised to market level over an eight-year period.
If a resident terminates the lease and leaves the park, rent for that
space could be raised to fair market value. Because the owner could
raise rents to market level once a coach is sold, residents say all
equity in their homes is lost because potential buyers would balk at
both a high rent and a mortgage.
"There are a lot of people's lives involved here," said Surf and Sand
resident Jack Alsman. "A lot of people don't have other places to go.
I'm 65 and my plan when I bought this place in 1982 was to retire here.
I'd probably be forced out of here if the ordinance stands."
FAIR
USE NOTICE. Tenants Together is not the author of this article and the posting
of this document does not imply any endorsement of the content by Tenants
Together. This document may contain copyrighted material the use of which
may not have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants
Together is making this article available on our website in an effort to
advance the understanding of tenant rights issues in California. We believe
that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided
for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this
copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you
must obtain permission from the copyright owner.