A plan by the owner of a Santa Rosa mobile home park to stop renting
spaces and start selling them was panned by angry senior citizens
Thursday and unanimously rejected by the Santa Rosa Planning Commission.
In a 6-0 vote, commission
members cited the strong opposition by mostly low-income residents and
the apparent motive of the owner to sidestep rent control as reasons
for blocking the plan.
“This
is a slam dunk for me,” said Commissioner Erin Carlstrom. “I don't
intend to make an entire community of seniors essentially homeless.”
The
out-of-area investment group that owns the 178-unit Country Mobile Home
Park off Fulton Road has been seeking the conversion for four years. A
2007 city ordinance aimed at protecting residents of the city's 14
mobile home parks from such conversions was repealed after the courts
shot down a similar county law. That paved the way for the owner to
again push the project this spring.
But
city planners and attorneys have taken a dim view of the plan, calling
it a sham conversion not for the benefit of the residents but rather
aimed at avoiding rent control.
After
attorneys for both sides jousted about the complex legal and
legislative history of laws governing such conversions, City Attorney
Mike Casey told the commissioners they had a limited, but important,
say in the matter.
“Our hands are tied, but they are not tied so much that you can't exercise a little bit of discretion here,” Casey said.
Contrary to the park owners'
contention, Casey said commissioners could consider a survey of
residents when trying to determine if the conversion was bona fide.
That survey found that 138 households, or 77 percent, opposed
conversion, while only nine, or 5 percent, wanted it.
The
residents' attorney, Will Constantine, told the commission it was the
park owners' refusal to even discuss the prices residents would need to
pay to buy their lots that brought such strong opposition.
“Never once have they made a serious attempt to get resident support,” Constantine said.
Resident
Suzanne Angeo told the commission that she and her husband are “just
above low income” and therefore would lose protection from state rent
control laws if the conversion passed. Since they can't afford to buy
their space, their rent would go up to the market rate of more than
$1,000 a month, double what they pay now. They said they would be
forced to move, sell their home at a loss, leaving them with nothing,
she said.
“That's economic displacement,” Angeo said.
Resident
Bill Sleet said the conversion would erode the city's stock of
low-income senior housing “sorely needed for our rapidly aging
population.”
He called the plan little more than a “scheme to circumvent rent control and at the same time make the owners a lot of money.”
Residents applauded several speakers and erupted in cheers as the commissioners voted.
Constantine,
who specializes in helping mobile home communities throughout the state
oppose such conversions, said he expects the owners to appeal the
decision to the City Council, and to the courts if necessary.
FAIR USE NOTICE. This
document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been
specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this
article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of
tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair
use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the
U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes
of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the
copyright owner.