Residents of a St. Helena mobile home park owned by vintner
Kathryn Hall have filed suit, claiming her attempts to close the
park violate federal and state laws.
A suit filed Nov. 19 in federal court on behalf of the 10
remaining tenants accuses Kathryn Hall and Hall Vineland Property,
LLC, of pressuring tenants to leave Vineland Vista Mobile Home Park
and retaliating against those who decided to stay by raising their
rents.
The suit claims Hall’s actions were discriminatory because 96
percent of the tenants were Latino. It also alleges violations of
federal and state housing and civil rights laws.
In 2008 Hall bought the nearly 50-year-old, 18-space mobile home
park, which is located on Highway 29 adjacent to Hall St. Helena
winery. She soon announced plans to close the mobile home park and
replace it with a vineyard and, eventually, market-rate
housing.
The property’s zoning of Agricultural Preserve with a Planned
Development overlay would allow one house and one “granny unit” on
each of the two parcels. The suit claims Hall approached county
officials about building multi-family residential housing, but was
told that wasn’t permitted.
According to the suit, many of the remaining tenants are
farmworkers and longtime residents of the St. Helena area with deep
ties to the community. If the park closes, St. Helena’s high
housing prices would force them to move out of the area.
Hall did not return a call for comment by the Star’s press
deadline.
In February Hall told St. Helena’s Multicultural Committee she
was committed to helping tenants find new housing, but stressed she
was under no legal obligation to retain affordable housing on the
property.
She said buying the park was a business decision, and she
intended to make money off it.
Hall hasn’t given tenants formal legal notice that the park is
closing. In February she said she instead wanted to negotiate with
individual tenants to help them relocate.
The suit claims that in 2009 Hall encouraged the tenants to move
out and offered to buy their mobile homes. By spring 2010 about
half of the tenants were gone, and the rest had hired
attorneys.
In June Hall informed the remaining tenants she was raising
their rents by 20 to 29 percent, the suit claims. The rate hikes
took effect. Nov. 1.
The tenants are represented by California Rural Legal
Assistance, the California Affordable Housing Law Project of the
Public Interest Law Project, and Relman, Dane & Colfax, a
Washington, D.C.-based civil rights law firm.
The park is outside the St. Helena city limits, but in January
the St. Helena City Council passed a resolution encouraging the
Board of Supervisors to support the park and maintain it as
affordable housing, preferably as a mobile home park.
The council urged supervisors to work with the Halls “to find a
workable solution for the mobile home park residents so that they
may remain in the St. Helena area.”
Antonio Manzo, a tenant who is a plaintiff in the suit, told the
council in January that he and his family are deeply rooted in the
St. Helena community.
“I love St. Helena and I would like to spend my life here,” he
said. “All the residents are looking for an opportunity to be part
of St. Helena, and we need affordable housing."
FAIR USE NOTICE. This
document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been
specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this
article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of
tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair
use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the
U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes
of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the
copyright owner.