In
one of the most contentious development fights in the Bay Area's recent
history, America's largest private company, Cargill Inc., and
Arizona-based luxury home developer, DMB Associates, propose to build a
new city of 30,000 people on retired salt ponds in Redwood City. The
development, which would build 12,000 new units, has been fiercely
contested by environmentalists, led by Save the Bay, who seek to
restore the salt ponds back to tidal marsh.
Largely invisible in
this clash are six mobile home parks on Bayfront Road, east of Highway
101 in Redwood City, which provide affordable housing to many hundreds
of area residents. The closest existing neighborhood to the salt ponds,
they are only separated from the proposed development by a fence and
narrow flood canal. Residents currently enjoy fresh Bay breezes and
some have sweeping views across the Bay to the East Bay hills.
If
the new city was to be built, the impacts on these residents would be
severe: 30 years of loud and dirty construction literally in their
backyard, a wall of multi-story housing out their windows, and a major
overpass right over their homes. Moreover, the mobile home park owners
likely would seek to displace low-income residents to make room for new
market-rate housing.
The threatened destruction of this
affordable neighborhood puts a different perspective on the developers'
repeated vague assurances that a percentage of their upscale
development may be "below market." In San Mateo
County, prices anywhere near market are simply unaffordable for most
working families. DMB Associates is known for its upscale developments.
In addition, based on recent court rulings, the enforceability of
developers' promises to create below-market rentals is in question.
Mobile
homes provide crucial affordable housing, particularly for seniors on
fixed incomes. Mobile home park residents around the state have been
fighting drastic rent increases, evictions and predatory companies that
buy up parks on prime land, quickly moving to transform the properties
into high-value real estate developments by overturning rent control
and forcing out long-time residents.
Park owners have done
everything possible to undermine rent control and other protections
that keep this housing affordable, even putting millions of dollars
behind a deceptive 2008 state ballot measure (Proposition 98) to
abolish renter protections, which California voters rejected by a wide
margin.
It is extremely disappointing that the impacts of the
Cargill/DMB project on this important piece of the Peninsula's
affordable housing stock have been ignored by Redwood City as it
finalizes a new general plan. While the plan's environmental study
discusses the impacts on views for more affluent hills residents, for
example, there is little if any mention of how the planned freeway
flyover, four new lanes of traffic, and other aspects of development
would affect the quality of life of mobile home park residents.
Park
residents have been speaking out against the Cargill development since
day one. Many are not surprised to find they are invisible in the
city's deliberations, as they have felt ignored by city leaders for
years. It seems like many, including at times the park owners, would
prefer they were not there. In 2003, at Le Mar Trailer Park, park
owners gave some tenants 48 hours' notice to raise the rent by 70
percent. In 2006, the owners of Harbor Village Mobile Home Park donated
$10,000 to the salt pond developers.
Cargill is proposing a
massive development. Aside from the obvious environmental concerns,
Redwood City needs to take into account how this will impact
neighboring mobile home residents. Ignoring this threat to the existing
affordable housing stock will not make the threat go away.
FAIR USE NOTICE. This
document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been
specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this
article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of
tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair
use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the
U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes
of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the
copyright owner.