Residents of a Green Valley Road mobile home park are fighting a rent hike that would more than double what most residents pay each month.
The city, which must approve increases above an allowed cost of living adjustment under its rent control ordinance, is being drawn into the fray, and could face expensive litigation.
Top rents at the 41-year-old Green Valley Village are less than $400, and many are under $300. Park owner, Vieira Enterprises of Santa Clara, wants residents to pay $750. Two other options presented to the city would raise monthly rents $150 to $200.
"Nobody here has a lot of money," said Marged McNeely, who's lived in Green Valley Village since it opened in 1970 and is the spokeswoman for a recently formed tenant committee. "We're not like people from the Santa Cruz area. These are either older retired people or young families with low-paying jobs."
McNeely, 71, said previous cost of living adjustments have resulted in increases of $5-$7 a month. She said if residents have to pay $750, some will have to move out.
For McNeely, whose rent is $273.28, news of the proposed hike came just weeks after she lost the part-time secretarial job she had held since she retired from a career teaching at Aromas and Bradley elementary schools in 1995. She said she thought she'd be able to get by without the extra $4,800 a year until the rent-hike notice came in early January.
"If that went through, I would have to rent out a room (in her home) or get a job," she said.
Calls to Vieira Enterprises and to its lawyer, Mark Alpert of Santa Ana-based Hart, King and Coldren, were not returned Monday.
Assistant City Manager Marcela Tavantzis said the landlord presented three options for a rent hike, two of which rely on appraised property value, which isn't allowed under the city ordinance. A third, which calls for jump of $150, looks at fair market value. But the property owner hasn't agreed to pay the $10,000 to $15,000 required by the city to hire a consultant to analyze the proposal, and a hike can't be imposed until the analysis is done.
The City Council has discussed a potential challenge to its rent control rules from Vieira in closed session, according to its agenda.
Vieira Enterprises also is seeking a rent hike at Cabrillo Mobile Home Estates in Capitola, and has warned city officials of legal action if it's not approved.
Capitola has spent more than $1 million on cases in the last decade defending its ordinance and on Friday will consider amending it in hopes of avoiding more legal expenses.
Bill Neighbors, speaking not as a member of the Watsonville City Council but as chair of the county Mobile Home Commission, said the problem for cities is that they can't recover their legal costs from mobile home park owners, even if the cities prevail. He said that's why he supports a bill introduced by Assemblyman Bill Monning that would change that.
"Different owners are attacking mobile home rent control," he said. "If we can't get the money for attorney costs, it makes it difficult to defend."
Whatever happens with the rent proposal at Green Valley Village, McNeely said the issue has people talking, and complaints have surfaced about reductions to amenities such as the removal of the park clubhouse a few years back and the imposition of parking fees. Without a clubhouse, it's difficult to find a place to meet, she said. But last Friday evening, residents gathered outside at the end of a street.
"Everyone's really upset. What he's done," McNeely said of the landlord, "is brought people together."
FAIR
USE NOTICE. Tenants Together is not the author of this article and the posting
of this document does not imply any endorsement of the content by Tenants
Together. This document may contain copyrighted material the use of which
may not have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants
Together is making this article available on our website in an effort to
advance the understanding of tenant rights issues in California. We believe
that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided
for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this
copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you
must obtain permission from the copyright owner.