The office of Assemblyman Bill Monning, D-Carmel, revealed Thursday that the state legislator is looking into a bill that would allow city and county governments, when successful in defending rent control ordinances, to charge the party who brought the challenge for the government's legal expenses.
A representative from Monning's office relayed the news to a meeting of mobile and manufactured home residents from across the county at the DeAnza Mobile Home Park.
The legislation could embolden local governments such as Santa Cruz County and Capitola, which have spent significant amounts of money defending rent control ordinances over the last decade. Watsonville and Scotts Valley also have rent control ordinances.
"Santa Cruz County has spent $1 million over the last 10 years to defend its rent control ordinance," said Supervisor John Leopold. "There are about 2,500 units in the county, which house thousands of people. We couldn't replace that affordable housing."
The Mobile and Manufactured Home Commission organized the meeting, and provided the opportunity for residents to meet with a representative of the Golden State Manufactured-home Owners League, who updated the crowd of about 80, many of them seniors, on the status of laws designed to protect mobile home park residents.
Staff in Monning's Sacramento office said the bill is in the research phase, and the assemblyman has not decided whether to propose it to the Legislature. All new bills most be introduced by Feb. 18.
"I'd vote for that twice," said Capitola City Councilman Michael Termini. "I'm wholeheartedly in favor. We have been attacked from all sides, all the time in a clear attempt to break our will. We couldn't be more bold than we are now; we are forcefully defending the ordinance on all fronts. But a bill that would let us get back legal expenses when the city is successful would certainly help our budget."
As of December 2010, Capitola had spent about $950,000 defending its rent control ordinance, Capitola officials said.
In late 2003, after defending its mobile home rent control law against continuous legal challenges for four years, the City of Santa Cruz ended rent control and pushed the residents and park owner of DeAnza to reach a settlement. While the agreement stabilized rents somewhat for the residents there at the time, whenever home ownership changed the park could raise rent as much as it wanted. DeAnza sits on a picturesque bluff sandwiched between Natural Bridges State Beach and the Long Marine Lab.
Residents of DeAnza Mobile Home Park who attended the Thursday meeting, said they have seen neighbors walk away from their homes because once the rent was increased to a certain amount, all their equity was gone. Mobile and manufactured home owners typically own the structure, but not the land it sits on, which is rented from the park owner.
Mobile home park owners have long argued that the various rent control ordinances prevent them from collecting a fair return on their investment.
"The fact is the government already has an overwhelming advantage when private parties challenge a law," said attorney Thomas Casparian, who has argued several cases on behalf of mobile home park owners, including Paul Goldstone, owner of Alimur Mobile Home Park in Soquel. "This could have a chilling effect for people who are challenging government actions and defending their rights. Any provision probably should be at least reciprocal."
Goldstone is involved in an on going case with the county for the right to subdivide Alimur Mobile Home Park and sell off individual, rent-controlled lots.
FAIR USE NOTICE. This
document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been
specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this
article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of
tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair
use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the
U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes
of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the
copyright owner.