As New York Landlords Push for Buyouts, Tenants Stand their Ground

Wednesday, July 9, 2014
Mireya Navarro
New York Times

The first offer from the landlord’s representative came in April: Take $90,000 to move out, the tenants said they were told, or the landlord would sue and they would lose their apartment anyway.

Lin Thai Ng, who lives in a cramped $500-a-month studio in NoLIta with her husband, said no. The landlord persisted and offered $100,000.

But after they refused again, the couple received a notice saying they were not the lawful tenants and declaring them squatters. They were told they had 18 days to get out or they would be evicted.

“He wants us to move,” Ms. Ng, 57, an immigrant from Malaysia, said in Cantonese through an interpreter, “but where are we going to move?”

Buyouts have long been part of the city’s real estate lore, complete with only-in-New York stories of tenants who made millions relinquishing apartments they did not own. But as offers have become more common at the lower end of the ravenous housing market, buyouts have become instruments of illegal harassment and a growing threat to the stock of affordable housing, tenant groups and housing officials said.

In fast-changing neighborhoods, like Chinatown and East Harlem in Manhattan and the Flatbush section of Brooklyn, offers are often anything but amicable and rarely are generous enough to help tenants settle elsewhere in the city, they said.

Richard R. White, who leads the state’s Tenant Protection Unit, said some landlords failed to make repairs, declined to cash rent checks or threatened illegal evictions “to force tenants to accept what are often unconscionably meager buyouts.”

Helen Rosenthal, a councilwoman from the Upper West Side of Manhattan who is sponsoring a bill to allow tenants to collect compensatory and punitive damages from landlords for harassment, said landlords’ motive for pushing out tenants was obvious. “They can make a killing in the market,” she said.

The intense demand for housing has made rent-regulated apartments even more precious. It has also drawn the attention of Mayor Bill de Blasio, who pledged during his campaign last year to address economic inequality. The mayor joined tenant groups in calling for a first-ever rent freeze by the Rent Guidelines Board, which voted last month to allow the lowest percentage rent increase in its 45-year history for nearly one million apartments.

The stock of rent-stabilized apartments has been shrinking, though, mostly through rent increases after a unit becomes vacant. If a vacant unit can rent for $2,500 or more a month, it can be freed from rent regulation.

Landlords and their lawyers said that buying out longtime tenants in low-rent apartments was the lawful way to make room for those who would pay more.

The Rent Stabilization Association, the trade organization for the city’s landlords, said that harassment was not common and that complaints about buyouts could be a negotiating tool intended to extract a better offer.

“If someone is abusive and rude, that’s one thing,” said Mitchell Posilkin, general counsel for the association. “But if someone is being persistent, that’s another.”
Continue reading the main story

Tenants groups said repeated buyout offers could be intended to intimidate or pressure residents. Some landlords also hire relocation specialists, who receive a fee for each vacancy, which law enforcement officials said was an incentive for wrongdoing.

A number of state and city laws prohibit conduct meant to force tenants to vacate an apartment or waive tenancy rights. A 2008 city law bans interrupting essential services, initiating baseless eviction proceedings or locking out a tenant.

Since that law went into effect, the city’s Department of Housing Preservation and Development said the number of complaints had been rising — to 748 last year, from 541 in 2012. While most cases are ultimately withdrawn or dismissed, of the 3,200 filed since 2008, about 600 led to settlements and 44 ended in a finding of harassment.

Tenant groups said the law had been ineffective because the cases were hard to prove and because, if they lose, tenants might have to pay the landlord’s lawyer fees.

In a case settled in December, the state accused Castellan NYC Partners and Liberty Place Property Management of offering sums as low as $2,000 to get mostly Spanish-speaking immigrants to waive their tenancy rights in buildings in Brooklyn, Harlem, the South Bronx and the Washington Heights section of Manhattan. In one federal court case, a group of black tenants in a Flatbush development, Homewood Gardens Estates, said they were offered $4,000 to $15,000 to leave their apartments as part of a harassment campaign that included landlords’ refusals to do repairs.

“Our clients rarely have the resources to find other affordable apartments,” said Edward Josephson, director of litigation for Legal Services NYC, which filed the federal lawsuit in April.

Jacob Laufer, the lawyer for Homewood Gardens Estates, said his client “categorically denies harassing tenants.” But Mr. Laufer, citing the pending litigation, declined to answer questions.

For tenants who decide to stay, even an offer of $100,000 loses appeal when measured against the realities of the real estate market.

Ms. Ng and her husband, a 61-year-old bus driver for the city who spoke on the condition that his name not be used because he feared it would jeopardize his job, said they subtracted taxes, moving costs and other expenses from the offer amount. Then they calculated how long the money would last if they rented another apartment for about $2,000 a month.

“In two and a half years all the money would be gone,” he said.

For most low-income residents, tenant groups said, a buyout seldom paid off.

“Keeping your affordable apartment, in a market where affordable housing is becoming harder and harder to come by, is worth more than any lump sum a landlord might throw at you,” said Brandon Kielbasa, lead organizer of Cooper Square Committee, a community group in the East Village.

For Ms. Ng and her husband, though, staying now means facing eviction. Their landlord, Samy Mahfar of SMA Equities in Great Neck, N.Y., who bought the 16-apartment building on Spring Street in 2012, said in an interview that he offered buyouts to tenants because “sometimes it’s just easier” than taking them to court. But he said Ms. Ng and her husband were not the apartment’s leaseholders and were occupying the studio illegally.
Continue reading the main story Continue reading the main story
Continue reading the main story

Mr. Mahfar, who has bought more than a dozen residential properties in Lower Manhattan in recent years, said that he was aware of tenants’ complaints about the relocation specialist and that “we’re trying to be more sensitive.” He said buyout offers at his buildings ranged from $5,000 to $100,000 depending on the case. Many of his tenants were illegally subleasing or were in arrears on their rent, he said.

For lawful occupants who want to stay, Mr. Mahfar said he did not press them to leave. “We can’t force people to take the money,” he said.

In the case of Ms. Ng, her apartment could rent for $2,500 to $3,000, Mr. Mahfar said — up to six times the current rent.

Sadia Rahman, a supervising lawyer at the Urban Justice Center, an organization that was advising the tenants in the building, said that the previous landlord had registered Ms. Ng in state documents as an occupant of her apartment since 2010 and that under such circumstances Ms. Ng and her husband would have an opportunity to establish their right to stay. Last year, the center sued and reached a settlement with Mr. Mahfar over the treatment of tenants at another of his buildings on the Lower East Side.

Ms. Rahman, who is working with CAAAV Organizing Asian Communities, an immigrant advocacy group, to assist the tenants, said the court proceedings are a form of harassment. “If the landlord had a strong case to begin with, he wouldn’t have put $100,000 on the table,” she said.

In another building owned by Mr. Mahfar on the Lower East Side, Steven M. Yee is holding out and also helping to organize the Chinese immigrant families in the building to do the same.

“Buyouts destroy communities,” Mr. Yee said.

He said that tenants there received offers of $40,000 to $70,000 since the building changed hands earlier this year, and that some tenants had accepted. Mr. Yee, 45, a restaurant/bar consultant, conceded that he would consider a buyout himself for $250,000 or more.

If money wins, he said, “they’ve got to give you enough to buy a home because, in essence, you’re losing your home.”

FAIR USE NOTICE. Tenants Together is not the author of this article and the posting of this document does not imply any endorsement of the content by Tenants Together. This document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.  

Help build power for renters' rights: